TABLE 1.
First Author | Year | Trial Sponsor | Multicenter | Method of Mutational Analysis | Timing of Mutation Analysis | Study Definition of Failure | Medication | Dosing |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Radich, J17 | 2012 | Canadian Cancer Society Research Institute, NIH, Public Health Service Cooperative Agreement | Yes | Direct nucleotide sequencing | Tx failure or discontinuation | Failure to achieve CHR by 3 months, loss of CHR, loss of PCyR or CCyR, or progression to AP or BP CML | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
Tx failure or discontinuation | Dasatinib | 100 mg D | ||||||
Soverini, S38 | 2005 | European Leukemia Net and others | Yes | D-HPLC or direct sequencing | Baseline/scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Cytogenetic resistance: failure to obtain at least a MCyR at 12 months | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
Branford, S39 | 2007 | Novartis Australia | Yes | Direct sequencing | Scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Death from any cause, development of AP or blast crisis, loss of CHR, and loss of a MCyR | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
Branford, S30 | 2003 | Novartis Australia | Yes | Direct sequencing | Scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | CP: disease progression, loss of a sustained CHR, MCyR, or CCyR with a corresponding increase in BCR-ABL levels of at least 1 log (refer to the reference for the definitions of acquired and primary resistance in CP or AP) | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
de Lavallade, H40 | 2008 | NR | No | RQ-PCR and pyrosequencing | Scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Loss of CHR or progression to advanced phase, loss of MCyR or CCyR, an increase by a factor of 2 in the transcript level, and failure to achieve CHR by 12 weeks | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
He, H20 | 2012 | NR | No | Semi-nested transcriptase PCR followed by direct sequencing | Baseline/scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Loss of CCyR or MCyR, MCyR not achieved within 12 months, and progression to advanced phase | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
Kantarjian, H16 | 2012 | Bristol-Myers Squibb | Yes | Direct sequencing | Tx failure/discontinuation | No hematologic response by 3 months, no CHR or cytogenetic response by 6 months, no partial cytogenetic response by 12 months, or no CCyR by 18 months | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
Tx failure/discontinuation | Dasatinib | 100 mg D | ||||||
Roche-Lestienne, C13 | 2002 | NR | No | Sequencing | Scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | No cytogenetic response after 3 months | Imatinib | 400-800 mg D |
Elnahass, Y33 | 2013 | NR | No | Sequencing | Scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Greater than 2-fold rising BCR-ABL level | Imatinib | 400 mg D |
Wei, Y41 | 2006 | Swedish Research Council and others | No | Sequencing | Baseline/scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Failure to achieve CHR after 3 months of imatinib therapy, failure to achieve at least a minimal cytogenetic response (65%-95% Ph+ metaphases) after 6 months of imatinib therapy, failure to achieve a MCyR <35% Ph+ metaphases at 12 months of imatinib therapy (1-3=primary resistance), and loss of an earlier obtained CHR or CyR (acquired resistance) | Imatinib | 400-600 mg D |
Cortes, J19 | 2010 | National Cancer Institute | No | Sequencing | Baseline/scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Patients who had not achieved CCyR by 6 months after treatment or who developed resistance | Nilotinib | 400 mg BID |
Patients who do not achieve MCyR or patients who discontinue therapy because of toxicity are also considered as experiencing treatment failure | ||||||||
Cortes, J18 | 2010 | National Cancer Institute | No | Sequencing | Baseline/scheduled/tx failure/discontinuation | Patients who had not achieved CCyR by 6 months after treatment or who developed resistance | Dasatinib | 50 mg BID or 100 mg D |
AP = accelerated phase; BID = twice daily; BP = blast phase; CCyR = complete cytogenetic response; CHR = complete hematologic response; CML = chronic myeloid leukemia; CP = chronic phase; CyR = cytogenetic response; D = daily; D-HPLC = denaturing high pressure liquid chromatography; MCyR = major cytogenetic response; mg = milligram; NR = not reported; PCR = polymerase chain reaction; PCyR = partial cytogenetic response; Ph = Philadelphia; RQ-PCR = real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction; tx = treatment.