Table 3. Methodology and main outcomes of some studies including a single group of COVID-19 patients and evaluating the impacts of pulmonary rehabilitation program (PRP) on social disadvantage data.
| 1 st author (Yr), [country], (reference) | a. Study design (Type PRP)
b. Participants, N (male) c. Age (Yr) |
Outcomes | Summary of findings |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Betschart (2021)
[Switzerland] 26 |
a. Pilot study (outpatient)
b. 12 (8) c. 61 (26-84) a |
PA/FS: PCFS
HRQoL: EQ-5D-5L VAS |
Improve in PCFS
*
Improve in EQ-5D-5L VAS * |
|
Gloeckl (2021)
[Germany] 29 |
a. Prospective observational cohort study (rehabilitation unit)
b. 50 (22): mild/moderate: 24 (4), severe/critical: 26 (18) c. Mild/moderate: 52 (47-56) c , severe/critical: 66 (60-71) c |
PS: GAD-7, PHQ-9
HRQoL: SF-36 |
Mild/moderate: no improve
Severe/critical: improve in GAD-7 β , PHQ-9 β and SF-36 mental component β , ¥ |
|
Daynes (2021)
[United Kingdom] 28 |
a. Observational study (outpatient)
b. 30 (16) c. 58 ±16 b |
PA/FS: FACIT (fatigue)
PS: HAD HRQoL: EQ 5D |
Improve in FACIT * |
|
Puchner (2021)
[Austria] 32 |
a. Observational multicenter study (rehabilitation unit)
b. 23 (16) c. 57 ±10 b |
PA/FS: BI
PS: HAD, IES |
Improve in BI * |
|
Bouteleux (2021)
[France] 27 |
a. Observational longitudinal study (outpatient)
b. 39 (17), PFS: 29 (11), NPFS: 10 (6) c. 48 ±15 b |
PS: HAD
HRQoL: VQ11 |
Improve in VQ11 * |
|
Piquet (2021)
[France] 31 |
a. Retrospective study (rehabilitation unit)
b. 100 (66) c. 66±22 c |
PA/FS: BI | Improve in BI * |
BI: barthel index dyspnea. COVID-19: coronavirus disease 2019. EQ 5D: EuroQual 5 domains. EQ-5D-5L: Euroqol 5 domains. FACIT: functional assessment of chronic illness therapy. FS: functional state. GAD-7: generalized anxiety disorder-7 questionnaire. HAD: hospital anxiety and depression scale. HRQoL: health-related quality of life. IES: impact of event scale. N: number. PA: physical activity. PCFS: post-COVID-19 functional status scale. PHQ-9: patient health questionnaire 9. PS: psychological state. SF-36: short form 36. VAS: visual analogue scale. VQ11: health quality of life questionnaire. Yr: year.
Data were:
Median (minimum-maximum);
Mean ±SD;
Median (interquartile range).
p<0.05: before PRP vs. after PRP. For the study of Gloeckl et al.:
p<0.05 before PRP vs. after PRP for the group mild/moderate;
p<0.05 before PRP vs. after PRP for the group severe/critical;
p<0.05 between-group difference mild/moderate vs. severe/critical for the same period.