Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 5;23:566. doi: 10.1186/s12884-023-05811-2

Table 3.

Mistreatment among women with and without a labor companion present at any point during care

No labor companion present Labor companion present Total p-value
Any physical abuse, verbal abuse, or stigma, or discrimination 34(34.7%) 105(16.3%) 139(18.7%) 0.000
 Any physical abuse 8(8.2%) 16(2.5%) 24 (3.2%) 0.008
 Any verbal abuse 28(28.6%) 95 (14.7%) 124(16.6) 0.001
 Any stigma or discrimination 0(0.0%) 5(0.8%) 5(0.7%) 0.494
Failure to meet professional standards
 Caesarean section (N = 745) 23(23.5%) 180(27.9%) 203(27.3%) 0.217
 Unconsented Caesarean section (N = 203) 3(13.1%) 62(34.4%) 65(32.0%) 0.127
 Episiotomy‡ (N = 251) 32(43.2%) 219(51.1%) 251(33.6%) 0.130
 Unconsented episiotomy (N = 251) 24(75.0%) 152(69.4%) 176(70.1%) 0.001
 Induction of labor (N = 700) 17(20.5) 123(20.0%) 140(20%) 0.521
 Unconsented induction of labor (N = 140) 15(88.2) 102(82.9%) 117(83.5%) 0.177
Vaginal examination
 Woman had any vaginal examination 89(90.8%) 540(83.6%) 630(84.4%) 0.040
 Unconsented vaginal examination 57(64.0%) 319(59.1%) 376(59.7%) 0.222
Pain relief
 Woman requested pain relief 39(39.8%) 345(53.3%) 384(51.5%) 0.008
 Woman requested pain relief but did not receive pain relief 19 (48.7%) 168(48.6%) 187(48.6%) 0.002
 Woman denied pain relief during time in hospital 26(27.4%) 86(13.4%) 112(15.2%) 0.001
Neglect and abandonment
 No staff member present when the baby came out ‡ 7(9.6%) 48(10.5%) 55(10.4%) 0.506
 Woman waited along time before attended by health workers 30(30.6%) 213(32.9%) 243(32.6%) 0.367
 Woman felt ignored, neglected, or that her presence was a nuisance for health workers or staff 36(36.7%) 137(21.2%) 173(23.3%) 0.001
Communication
 Woman felt that health workers or staff not listened and responded to her concerns 44(45.4%) 444(70.0%) 488(66.7%) 0.000