Table 2.
Domain | Attribute | Attribute definition | Example features* | Examples of considerations related to equity, diversity and inclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|
Organizational climate and structures | Economic arrangements | “Economic Arrangements” refers to the income and expenditures relating to service delivery within organizations |
• Funding model • Costs of healthcare delivery • Funding/ endowment |
• Does the funding model/process consider equity? • Do the economic arrangements support accessible care for communities or populations who would otherwise not be able to afford it? • How can the funding organizations ensure that researchers/stakeholders meaningfully engage equity-deprived populations in studies or planning programs? • Does the organization ensure it is allocating and supporting programs that serve equity-deprived populations based on their needs? • Are there varied voices and perspectives in decisions regarding funding? |
Elements of organizations | “Elements of organizations” refers to the characteristics of units and organizations. This attribute is akin to sociodemographic characteristics for individuals |
• Type of ownership • Location • Organizational size • Setting/type of environment • Physical structures • Programs (differentiation) |
• Does the type of ownership affect what care is offered and accessible and the quality of care provided? • Does the location of the organization (for example, rural/urban areas, low- or high-income communities, distance of setting from the communities or populations served) affect health equity? • Are the healthcare services accessible to communities or populations with different needs (for example, are there ramps? Do they have flexible opening times? Are they accessible by public transit)? |
|
Organizational climate | “Organizational climate” refers to shared recurring patterns of behaviour, attitudes and feelings which characterize life in that organization [39] |
• Climate (atmosphere) • Team climate • Conflict |
• Is the health services team diverse and inclusive? • Is the social climate (atmosphere) welcoming to all? • Does the organization encourage self-reflection on unconscious bias toward equity-deprived populations? • Does the organization encourage tolerance and open discussion of different perspectives? |
|
Physical and technological resources | “Physical and technological resources” refers to physical structures and technological resources of an organization that are required to deliver services |
• Space • Equipment and supplies • Technology • Online resources • Evidence-based resources • Documentation • Reminders |
• Are the physical and technological resources accessible (for example, formats that are readable; are there alternative for persons with low vision)? • What accommodations might be needed to make resources accessible? • Are information materials available in different languages? • Do consumers have input or co-create resources? |
|
Organizational social behaviour | Internal relationships | “Internal relationships” refers to the ways in which two or more people or groups within an organization regard and behave toward each other [40] |
• Social networks • Social capital • Partnerships (collaborative practices) |
• Does the organization encourage self-reflection of unconscious bias toward equity-deprived populations? Do they provide training for self-reflection and self-reflection of unconscious bias? • Does the organization encourage tolerance and open discussion of different perspectives? • Are patients/clients/consumers included as stakeholders in care and service decisions, and policy-making and research? • Does the organization have trusting relationships with equity-deprived populations? |
Organizational culture | “Organizational culture” refers to the normative beliefs and shared expectations that govern the work behaviour of an organization [41] |
• Cultural norms • Shared expectations |
• Does the organization encourage reflections on its own cultural norms/shared expectations? • Does the organization promote reflection on the influences of norms/expectations on service providers and patients’ behaviours? • Are there processes to co-create and encourage shared expectations? |
|
Organizational response to change | Organizational change processes | “Organizational change processes” refers to the process of altering an organization’s strategies, processes, procedures, technologies and/or culture to improve service delivery [42] |
• Formal change systems and processes • Quality improvement processes • Engagement • Champions/opinion leaders |
• Are there processes to consider the needs of all stakeholders including equity-deprived populations? • Does the organization have processes to ensure inclusion of all stakeholders, including equity-deprived populations, in change processes? • Are the champions/opinion leaders representative of the diversity of the organization? |
Receptivity to change | “Receptivity to change” refers to an openness and responsiveness to ideas, impressions or suggestions, and a readiness or fit of critical features of the environment as they specifically relate to a targeted practice [43]. Receptivity to change may occur at multiple levels (for example, patients, healthcare professionals/providers, leaders and organization) |
• Change culture • Tension for change • External pressure for change • Readiness for change • Compatibility • Change saturation |
• Are assessments of readiness for change inclusive, and do they consider the diversity of the community or population? • Are the priorities of the service providers compatible with the priorities of the patients/ clients/consumers? • Does receptivity to change include equity considerations? • To what degree are equity factors integrated in changing care and services, policy and research conduct? For example, approaches related to actions on gender equity and health can be described as a continuum from gender unequal to gender blind to gender sensitive to gender specific and then gender transformative [62] |
|
Organizational processes | Communication processes |
“Communication processes” refers to the imparting or exchanging of information or news (for example, between professionals/ providers, patients, management, etc.) within an organization [44] |
• Formal communication • Informal communication (social interactions) • Social influence • Advocacy |
• Does the organization advocate for health equity? • Are communication strategies tailored to equity-deprived populations? • Does the organization co-create messages with clients/ consumers/patients to ensure that the terminology used, or the phrasing of the message, is respectful and inclusive? • Does the organization have processes to identify the individuals or partners who can co-create and impart messages to equity-deprived populations who might otherwise be underserved? • Does the organization ensure that there are communication channels that individuals can use without fear of discrimination or judgement after disclosure of being a member of an equity-deprived population (for example, anonymous lines)? |
Evaluation activity | “Evaluation activity” refers to the systematic collection of information about the activities, characteristics and outcomes of programs, services, policies or processes in an organization, to make judgements about the program/process, improve effectiveness and/or inform decisions about future development in that organization [45] |
• Quality improvement monitoring • Performance Measurement • Performance feedback • Review of employee performance (staff/manager) • Patient/client/consumer feedback to staff |
• Does the organization collect equity-related indicators/factors? • Does the organization evaluate gaps in access, quality of care and services, and health status amongst equity-deprived populations? • Does the organization evaluate the reach of interventions targeting equity-deprived populations? • What are the ethical considerations/obligations that organizations consider when collecting and presenting data related to equity and equity-deprived populations? • Do the equity-deprived populations have data sovereignty over their data? • Does the organization evaluate and meaningfully incorporate patients/clients/consumers/staffs/ managers' effort and perspectives in co-creating more equitable care and services? • Does the organization reflect on and learn from past experiences to facilitate building relationships with equity-deprived populations and prevent repeating mistakes that were detrimental to these populations? |
|
Governance | “Governance” refers to the rules, policies, systems, structures and processes by which an organization is controlled and directed [46] |
• Organizational mission, goals & priorities • Organizational authority structure • Power • Standard of practice or care • Internal policies • Incentives and disincentives |
• Do the organizational mission, goals and priorities consider equity? • How is power shared in the organization? • Do the standards of practice and care incorporate equity and the perspectives of patients/clients/consumers? • Are internal policies inclusive of individuals with varied needs? • Are there incentives and/or disincentives to promote equity in the workplace? |
|
Leadership | “Leadership” refers to the types and styles of leaders within an organization |
• Leadership styles • Formal leaders • Senior leaders • Role models • Mentors |
• How diverse is the leadership team? • Are there role models and mentors within the organization from diverse backgrounds? |
|
Management | “Management” refers to the process of dealing with or organizing things or people in an organization [47] |
• Formal planning • Management support • Use of resources |
• Does the organization consider equity during policy planning, work planning, strategic planning and setting annual goals? • Does the organization meaningfully engage diverse groups of individuals in formal planning? • Do the processes related to resource allocation consider equity? |
|
Organization of work | “Organization of work” refers to arrangement of tasks, responsibilities and resources within and between service providers working in the organization [48]. This attribute reflects individuals when considered as a group rather than as individuals, thus all features considered for inclusion here had to be generalizable to an organization |
• Workload • Adequacy of staff composition • Support personnel • Teamwork • Scheduling • Workflow • Work tempo • Time |
• Does the organization have individuals who provide expertise regarding equity and its integration in care and services, policy and research? • Does the organization have a diverse workforce? • Does the organization celebrate the diversity of its staff and encourage individuals to express themselves freely? • Does the organization support its staff to consider equity in their work? |
|
System processes | “System processes” refers to the processes required to deliver services within an organization |
• Quality assurance process • Project Management • Optimizing standardization of care • Continuity of Care • Organizational training and education • Process complexity • System complexity |
• Do current system processes incorporate equity? • Does the organization provide training for self-reflection and awareness of unconscious bias? • Do standards of care consider the diversity of care needs unique to each community or population? • Are there system processes in place to allow the organization to respond to circumstances that are incompatible or harmful to equity-deprived populations? |
*Example features – definitions of features are in Additional file 4