Table 4.

Credibility and selection based on author gender.

	Percentage saying that the pro-author is credible %	Percentage that selected the pro-author argument %
Man pro-author (n = 1,073)	51.8	55.1
Woman pro-author (n = 1,055)	45.6	51.8
Gender gap (difference)	6.2 (p = .001)	3.3 (p = .001)

Note: P-values represent statistical difference in the gender gap. Full regression table for left column from which predicted probabilities were derived can be found in Supplementary Material table B1. Full regression table for right column can be found in Supplementary Material table B2.