Table 2.
A priori concepts derived from existing models
| References | Direct costs | Indirect costs | Material resources | Psychological response | Financial coping behavior | Financial outcome | Health outcome | Risk factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanratty et al. (2007) [28] | Rising health care costs and increasing health care use | Financial strain: the subjective perception of financial hardship | ||||||
| Kankeu et al. (2013) [26] | Economic consequences: Direct costs | Economic consequences: Indirect costs | Social resources (e.g assistance from others) | Coping strategies (e.g. Intra- and inter- household labor substitution; Hiring other labor and other strategies; Reducing/delaying consumption of non-health goods and services (food, education, electricity, leisure, etc.); Use of savings; Sale of assets; Borrowing; Delaying investments) | Treatment seeking behavior: Yes or No | |||
| Gordon et al. (2017) [2] | Currency (monetary) values of OOP costs | Percentage of OOP costs to income ratios | Perceptions of cancer-related financial burden and psychological impact | Tangible solutions to ease financial burden such as increasing debt levels, borrowing money from family or friends, selling assets | ||||
| Altice et al. (2017) [3] | Material conditions: Increased OOP expenses | Material conditions: Lower income that can result from the inability to work during/following cancer treatment | Psychological response: Response to the increase in household expenses that must now be managed as patients navigate cancer care | Coping behaviors: patients adopt to manage their medical care while experiencing increased household expenses during/following cancer care | Medical debt/bankruptcy | |||
| Santacroce et al. (2018) [29] | Monetary: Direct costs | Monetary: Indirect costs | Patient-reported: Psychosocial | Patient-reported: Financial coping | ||||
| Witte et al (2019) [33] | Objective financial burden: Direct costs (OOP) | Objective financial burden: Indirect costs (income loss) | Subjective financial distress: Material | Subjective financial distress: Psychosocial | Subjective financial distress: Behavioral | |||
| Yabroff et al. (2018) [34] | Level of risk factors: patient/family, provider and care team, health care system, employer, state and national policy | |||||||
| Thomas et al. (2019) [27] | Direct (medical) costs, indirect (non-medical) costs | Biological responses to stress |
Financial coping behavior: Treatment non-adherence |
Medical insurance | ||||
| Imber et al. (2020) [42] | Direct costs: Patient’s OOP responsibilities owing to prostate cancer | Indirect costs: Opportunity costs of prostate cancer | Individual economic circumstances: Baseline wealth, pre-existing debts and economic reserve | Expectations of possible financial burdens: Knowledge and perception of the economic effect that a prostate cancer diagnosis will have on one’s family | Patient-specific values and self-management behaviors | |||
| Belcher et al. (2020) [23] | Distress: General stress, cancer-specific stress, cancer worry, depression, anxiety | Inability to make ends meet, not enough money for necessities, cutbacks and adjustments | Functional health: physical function; symptom burden; symptom interference; comorbidities; social role, ability | |||||
| Newton et al. (2020) [31] | Monetary measures of financial toxicity: direct medical costs, direct non-medical costs | Monetary measures of financial toxicity: indirect costs | Subjective measures of financial toxicity: Distress | Objective measures of financial toxicity: Coping mechanisms | Subjective measures of financial toxicity: Indebtedness | Subjective measures of financial toxicity: Health outcomes | Treatment seeking behavior: Diagnosis, health literacy, self-advocacy, personal financial circumstances, perception of the health system, clinician's recommendations, private health insurance status, proximity to treatment centers | |
| Tucker-Seeley and Thorpe (2019) [43] | Material domain: Material hardship, making ends meet, material disadvantages | Psychosocial domain: Financial stress, financial worry, financial satisfaction | Behavioral domain: Financial adjustments, financial planning, spending/consumption | |||||
| Santacroce and Kneipp (2019) [30] | Financial costs: Direct costs | Financial costs: Indirect costs | Financial distress: Biological response to stress | Financial distress: Financial coping behavior | Family financial outcomes: Recent material hardship and impoverishment |
Parent health outcomes: Symptoms, quality of life, risk for disease onset; Child health outcomes: symptoms, quality of life, relapse |
Pre-existing parent factors: age, gender, language, marital status, work status; Pre-existing family factors: residence, income, assets, debts, number of children, general health; Post-cancer diagnosis: treatment decision and initiation |
|
| Carrera et al. (2018) [32] | Objective financial burden: Expenditures on drug costs, other direct medical costs, treatment costs | Subjective financial distress: Wealth – wages, salaries or replacement income; savings and assets | Subjective financial distress: anxiety and discomfort | |||||
| PDQ Adult Treatment Editorial Board (2002) [5] | Medical costs, non-medical costs | Financial strain and distress | Formal bankruptcy | Health outcomes | Pre-illness health, assets, debt, income, illness or injury, medical insurance, treatment choice | |||
| Pisu et al. (2010) [25] | Direct costs: medical costs, non-medical costs, time costs |
Time costs (at work) Indirect costs: Productivity losses due to cancer |
Psychosocial cost: loss of quality of life | |||||
| McNulty and Khera (2015) [45] | Patient/family: Increased stress and uncertainty |
Spending savings/retirement funds, borrowing money, losing home/selling property, lifestyle changes, avoiding purchases, reduced spending on food and clothing, changes in decision making/priority selling; Cancer treatment: decreased adherence to cancer treatment |
Incurring significant debt, bankruptcy |
Patient/family: Parent cost, disability Decreased health related quality of life: Increased stress, uncertainty, anxiety and depression, demands on the caregiver |
Risk factors: Patient/family socio-demographics, financial/employment, environmental/logistical, cancer and disease related | |||
| Lentz et al. (2019) [24] | Costs related to medical, surgical and radiation treatment, including costs of supportive care, end-of-life care | Material consequences: Reduced income | Psychological consequences: Distress | Maladaptive coping: Skipping or reducing medication doses, adjusting non-medical spending | Material consequences: Depletion of savings, debt, bankruptcy | Psychological consequences: reduced quality of life |
Causes: Baseline factors: demographics, health, socioeconomic status Cancer: type and stage Medical insurance status: Premiums, deductibles, coinsurance, absence of |
OOP out of pocket