Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 9;29(8):e13418. doi: 10.1111/srt.13418

TABLE 3.

Summary table of advantages/disadvantages of each device.

VISIA‐CR® Spectrophotometer SpectraFace®
Ease of use and deployment ++ + –/+
Standard tool of colorimetric visualization and measurement Standard tool of spectral color measurement but rather adapted to in vitro measurement Nonstandard, innovative tool of spectral color measurement
Color measurement technology –/+ ++ ++
RGB color measurement within the illuminant of the VISIA, not compliant with D65 color measures Spectral reflectance measurement allowing standardized color measure, compliant with D65 color measures Spectral reflectance measurement allowing standardized color measure, compliant with D65 color measures
Measurement type ++ –/+ +
Imaging: Spatial information available Spot measurement Imaging: Spatial information available
(resolution: 34 μm) (diameter of the spot: 5 mm) (resolution: 110 μm)
Region of interest ++ –/+ ++
Possibility to define specific region of interest with different size and locations Spot measurement Possibility to define specific region of interest with different size and locations
Repeatability ++ ++ ++
Good repeatability Good repeatability Good repeatability
Discriminability ++ –/+ ++
Significant difference between superior and inferior lips in L*, a*, C* Significant difference between superior and inferior lips in a* Significant difference between superior and inferior lips in L*, a*, C*
Capture time ++ +
Immediate 10 s Approximately 3 s
Simulation of illuminants –/+ + ++
Only the illuminant of the system Conversion of color data under other illuminants, but no associated image Creation of images under other illuminants