Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 26;11:1180571. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1180571

Table 1.

Study details (n = 18).

Year First author Setting Study design, sample size Outcomes Theoretical underpinnings Mechanism of action Delivered by Delivered to Main findings
2014 Allen (19) USA RCT, 45 dyads Center for Epidemiological Studies-Depression Scale, Memorial Symptom Assessment Scale-Short Form, Brief Multidimensional Measure of Religiousness and Spirituality, Meaning in Life Scale, Caregiver Stressor Scale, Positive Aspects of Caregiving scale Folkman's stress process model Not discussed Retired Senior Volunteers Patient-carer dyads • Patients in the intervention group had a greater reduction in emotional symptoms (p = 0.02) and emotional symptom bother (p = 0.04) and improved spiritual functioning
• Caregivers in the intervention group had better Meaning of Life scale scores (p = 0.02)
2022 Chen (20) China RCT, 47 dyads Qualitative Interviews, satisfaction questionnaire, QoL, Zarit Caregiver Burden, Family Adaptability and Cohesion Evaluation Scale II Erikson's psychosocial development theory and Bowen's family system theory By improving communication and bidirectional emotional support between patient and carer, encouraging gratitude, and relieving caregivers' stress, the program enabled patients to affirm positive experiences, accept or let negative experiences go, and thus help patients achieve self- integration, and perceive a better QoL Online modules Patient-carer dyads • 5 themes emerged in qualitative interviews: (1) accepting and enjoying the program; (2) better communication; (3) feeling grateful for each other; (4) improved emotional support; and (5) decreased caregivers' stress
• QoL (p < 0.001), family adaptability(p = 0.001), and family cohesion (p < 0.001) improved
• Caregivers' care burden decreased in the intervention group (p = 0.018)
2022 Dionne-Odom (21) USA RCT, 46 dyads Intervention completion rates, qualitative interviews, likeliness of recommending intervention, Rini Decision Influence Scale, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale Social Support Effectiveness Theory and the Ottawa Decision Support Framework Not discussed Trained PC coaches Family carers • Carers completed 78% of intervention sessions
• Carers reported a likelihood of recommending the program to others of 9.9 on a scale from 1-Not at all likely to 10-Extremely likely
• Some components of the intervention showed potential benefit for effective decision support and caregiver distress
2014 DuBenske (22) USA RCT, 322 dyads Demographics, Caregiver Quality of Life–Cancer Scale, Short Version Profile of Mood States, Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale (carer-reported) Stress and coping theoretical framework The intervention improved carers appraisal and coping by bolstering cognitive, behavioral and practical support mechanisms. The authors state that more research is needed to understand the mechanism of action Online modules Patient-carer dyads • Carers in the intervention group reported lower burden (p = 0.021) and negative mood (p = 0.006) than those in the control group
• The effect on disruptiveness was not significant
2017 Grande (23) UK RCT, 681 people at the end of life Novel survey with questions related to adequacy of support received by carer, physical and mental wellbeing of carer in bereavement, place of death, carers feelings regarding place of death Not discussed Not discussed Volunteers Patients • Intervention group displayed a small but significant reduction in level of early grief and increased physical/mental wellbeing scores compared to control group
• No difference in feelings of needs being met between groups
2011 Greene (24) Australia Quasi-experimental, 66 carers Duke Social Support Index, Catholic Health Care Coalition Family Caregiver Questionnaire, AMA Carer Self-check, novel survey questions Not discussed Not discussed Community network facilitators Carers • Participants in the intervention group showed improvement in caregiver fatigue, sufficient support from others, decreased resentment in the role, greater confidence in asking for assistance and were better able to find resources and support
• No between-group changes were seen
2014 Hanson (25) USA Pre-Post, 218 people at the end of life Novel survey with questions related to support needs and awareness of services to help with pain and symptoms, Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy–Spiritual Well-being Scale Socioecological theory of community health promotion using existing social networks Not discussed Lay health advisors Black patients • Post-intervention 25% of patients identified hospice as source of support for pain/symptom management (pre-intervention = 4%, p = 0.04)
• 60% of patients reported unmet needs for help with errands or household tasks at enrollment, while only 20% and 15% reported these areas of unmet need after 2 months in the program
• QoL scores were unchanged
2011 Henricksson (26) Sweden Descriptive, 29 carers Qualitative interviews Not discussed Not discussed Peers Family carers • Participants reported that the intervention was relevant, the relationships formed were valuable, and the open approach produced a warm and relaxed atmosphere
2012 Jack (27) Uganda Descriptive, 21 people at the end of life Qualitative Interviews Not discussed Not discussed Community volunteers Patients • Participants reported that the community volunteers were very beneficial, linking them and their families to practical help, counseling and education, and hospice services when appropriate
2015 Luker (28) UK Quasi-experimental, 29 carers Qualitative interviews Not discussed Not discussed Informational Booklet Carers and district nurses • Carers were positive about the booklet, but many reported they would have liked it earlier
• Carers reported feeling more positive about caregiving and more reassured and competent in their role
• District nurses found the booklet useful and reported receiving fewer phone calls from study carers than others in similar situations
2022 Parker Oliver (29) USA RCT, 78 carers Generalized Anxiety Disorder scale, Patient Health Questionnaire, Caregiver Quality of Life Index-Revised, and the Zarit Burden Interview Not discussed Not discussed Peers Family carers • Participating in Facebook support groups was associated with decreased anxiety and depression carers
• There was no significant difference in carer QoL or burden
2017 Pesut (30) Canada Pre-Post, 21 dyads Qualitative interviews, novel survey with questions related to self-efficacy and satisfaction with the intervention, McGill Quality of Life Questionnaire Not discussed Not discussed Volunteers Patients and carers • Carers were highly satisfied with the intervention
• Carers reported that the intervention helped them with decision making, social support, engaging with life, and re-framing the experience of living with illness
2008 Ryan (31) UK Descriptive, 81 carers Qualitative interviews Not discussed Not discussed Lay interventionists Carers • Carers appreciated the emotional support, time, practical help, financial advice, and education that the program provided
• Carers and health professionals both felt the program provided essential social support
2009 Steinhauser (32) USA RCT, 82 participants Qualitative interviews Byock's theory of human development and physical decline The semi-structured nature of the sessions provided catharsis for participants by empowering them to disclose anything they felt was appropriate. The sessions allowed participants to explore their sense of self with is often interrupted at the onset of illness because crisis supersedes normal roles—by reconnecting to these roles through the personal narrative exercises, participants find emotional and spiritual growth Lay interventionists Patients • Discussions of life completion may improve important health outcomes for patients at the end of life
2016 Walshe (33) UK RCT, 179 people at the end of life World Health Organization QoL Brief Scale, De Jong Gierveld 6-item Loneliness Scale, Medical Outcomes Study Social Support Survey, self-reported healthcare utilization Not discussed Not discussed Volunteers Patients • No significant differences in outcomes were found between groups at 4 weeks
• Rate of change of QoL slowed in intervention group
2021 Wang (34) USA Descriptive, 22 carers Qualitative interviews Body-Mind-Spirit Model Carers are unable to care for their loved ones if they do not first take care of themselves. The intervention targeted the bodies, minds, and spirits of carers, so they were better equipped with the self-care skills they needed to sustainably car for their loved ones Online modules Chinese immigrant carers • The most beneficial aspects were self-care curriculum related to caregiving stress, lifestyle and health behavior change, community resource support, death education and end-of-life care, and spirituality and spiritual care
• Caregivers appreciated the educational aspect of the intervention and wanted more assistance accessing community resources
2011 Williams (35) Canada Descriptive, 57 carers Qualitative interviews The population health promotion model (outlined in the Ottawa Charter) When carers feel overburdened by practical concerns (financial strain, missing work, etc) they are unable to effectively care for their loved ones. This intervention helps relieve carers' burden so they have more time and energy to focus on their role in supporting their loved one without feeling burned out Government Carers working full time • Carers discussed social determinants that affected their experience like gender, income and social status, working conditions, health and social services, social support network, and personal health practices and coping strategies
• They rated the intervention highly and felt it benefitted them
2004 Witkowski (36) Sweden Descriptive, 48 carers Qualitative interviews Not discussed Not discussed Support group leaders Carers • Carers felt that the programme was beneficial to their own health promotion, that it was an important complement to usual palliative home care, and that they benefited from mutual experiences shared among group members

MRC, Medical Research Council; QoL, Quality of life; RCT, Randomized control trial.