Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 10;18(8):e0287833. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0287833

Table 2. Summary of included studies.

(Part 1)
Study Sample size (T/C) Gender(T/C) Mean age(T/C) Etiology of injury Timing of repair Follow-up period Wavelength(nm) Energy density
2020 Sharifi, R. 18/18(split) 4/14 23±5 SSRO 1 day ahead 1 months 980 12 J/cm2
2022 Santos, V. P. D. 22/20 No difference 29.4 mandibular
fractures
1 day later 6 months 660∼850 7.64 J
2019 Santos, F. T. 20/20(split) 7/13 35.6 ± 11.6 SSRO within 30 days or 6 months later 1 year 780 157.5
J/cm2
2020 Qi, W. 10/10 Not mentioned No difference Tooth extraction 24 h after
extraction
1 month 808 3 J/cm2
2017 Mohajerani, S. H. 10/10 5/5
3/7
24.1± 4.6/22.8 ± 3.6 SSRO 1 day after 6 months 632–810 Laser: 5J/cm2
LED: 2J/cm2
2018 Guarini, D. 33/9 13/20
2/7
25.8/29.8 SSRO 1 day after 2 years 810–820 27J
2014 Gasperini, G. 10/10(split) 0/10 30 SSRO immediately after surgery 2 months 660/ 789/780 5/30/70J/cm2
2014 Fuhrer-Valdivia, A. 16/14 5/11
4/10
21.5±8
/23± 5
SSRO immediately after surgery 6 months 810±20 32J/cm2
2018 Esmaeelinejad, M. 20/20 18/22 26.52 ± 3.78 SSRO immediately after surgery 12 months 810 8.4 J/cm2
2017 Eshghpour, M. 16/16(split) 5/11 23.1±4.4 SSRO 1 day after 2 months 660/810 1.5/7 J/cm2
2017 Astrid Virginia Buysse 12/12(split) 6/6 30 orthognathic surgery 48h after surgery 6 weeks 808 100 J/cm2
2022 Salari, B. 26/26 6/46 35.69±13.44/36.23 ± 11.51 mandibular fractures 6 months later 6 months 810 12–14 J/cm2
1996 Khullar, S. M. B. P. 6/7 Not mentioned Not mentioned SSRO; Tooth extraction 6 months later 36∼69 820 550mW/cm2
1996 Khullar, S. M. E. B. 8/5 4/9 35.7 SSRO 2 years later 63 days 820 550mW/cm2
2020 Esteves, P. F. P 12/12(split) 6/6 30 SSRO 48h after surgery 6 weeks 808 157.5
J/cm2
(Part 2)
Study Radiation time Days of laser therapy Types of neurosensory tests
2020 Sharifi, R. 60s 0, 1, 3, 7, 14, 21, 28 VAS, BS, TPD, PD, TD
2022 Santos, V. P. D. 20 min every day for 6 months PP, TD
2019 Santos, F. T. 90s 3-to-4 weeks intervals SWMF
2020 Qi, W. 188s once every two days between 2 to 14 days VAS, TPD
2017 Mohajerani, S. H. 90s 1 , 2, 3, 7, 14, 28 VAS, BS, TPD, PP, TD, SWMF
2018 Guarini, D. 90S 1, 2, 3, 5, 10, 14, 21, 28 VAS, TPD, PD, TD
2014 Gasperini, G. 10/20/ 40s 0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19, 21, 23 TPD, PP
2014 Fuhrer-Valdivia, A. 90s 1,2,3,5,10,14,21,28 VAS, BS, TPD, TD
2018 Esmaeelinejad, M. 28s 0, 1, 2, 3 then every other day for two weeks TPD, TD, PP, SWMF
2017 Eshghpour, M. 10s 1, 2, 3 and then twice a week for 3 weeks TPD
2017 Astrid Virginia Buysse 28s 2 and two sessions per week VAS
2022 Salari, B. 30s twice a week for 6 weeks
light touch, PP, TPD, TD, EPT
1996 Khullar, S. M. B. P. 85s 20 sessions between 36 and 69 days TD, SWMF
1996 Khullar, S. M. E. B. 85s 20 sessions between 20 and 63 days VAS, SWMF
2020 Esteves, P. F. P 28s 2rd day and then two sessions per week VAS

T = treatment group; C = control group; TD = thermal discrimination; VAS = visual analog scale test; SWMF = Semmes-Weinstein monofilament test; TPD = two-point discrimination; PP = pinprick; PD = pain discrimination; EPT = electric pulp test; BS = brush stroke

SSRO = sagittal split ramus osteotomy