Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 28;9(8):e18574. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e18574

Table 11.

Robustness; estimation results of DOLS.

Variables Specification models without interaction terms
(VAA)
(PSV)
(GEF)
(REQ)
(ROL)
(COC)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
LNDEBT −0.771*** (−7.678) −0.018*** (−5.936) −0.329*** (−5.711) −0.761*** (−5.906) −0.684*** (−8.437) −0.733** (−3.653)
IQ 0.723*** (5.741) 1.273*** (7.359) 1.204** (3.231) 0.987*** (5.793) 0.859*** (7.493) 0.663*** (5.683)
LNTFP 0.991*** (5.649) 1.285*** (8.943) 2.069** (3.108) 1.992** (3.345) 2.794*** (5.920) 2.804** (3.169)
LNINF −1.229*** (−5.967) −0.112*** (−6.715) −3.324*** (−4.759) −2.668* (−2.998) −2.901*** (−6.793) −1.082*** (−7.893)
LNGS −0.793** (−4.221) −1.357*** (−9.681) −1.193 (−1.001) −0.992* (−2.590) −0.903*** (−6.451) −0.909*** (−5.993)
LNEXP 1.793*** (5.181) 1.385*** (6.259) 1.115* (2.928) 1.672*** (7.208) 1.092*** (5.998) 0.934*** (6.664)
C 6.223 (0.971) −5.731*** (−7.757) 5.334** (3.250) 8.890*** (6.839) 8.773*** (6.875) 9.339*** (7.228)
Specification models with interaction terms
LNDEBT −0.894*** (−7.203) −0.439*** (−8.648) −0.664*** (−7.342) −0.663*** (−6.345) −0.732*** (−5.632) −0.786*** (−5.274)
IQ 0.946*** (8.344) 1.092*** (5.903) 1.228*** (5.444) 0.893** (4.452) 1.345*** (5.879) 0.868*** (6.403)
LNDEBT × IQ 1.374*** (8.456) 1.002*** (5.633) 1.883*** (9.884) 1.996*** (4.999) 1.453*** (5.673) 1.868*** (5.329)
TFP 1.957*** (5.838) 1.905*** (5.994) 1.832 (1.883) 0.991*** (5.577) 2.441*** (6.342) 1.168** (4.740)
LNINF −0.484*** (−5.991) −0.994*** (−6.442) −1.221*** (−6.456) −2.662** (−4.002) −0.662* (−2.229) −1.862*** (−6.731)
GS −0.486*** (−6.453) −0.223*** (−7.334) −0.112*** (−5.680) −0.342** (−3.801) −0.289*** (−6.221) −0.868*** (−6.741)
LNEXP 0.684* (2.455) 1.039*** (5.449) 1.002*** (5.072) 1.331*** (5.553) 1.822*** (4.422) 1.868 (1.723)
C 5.793** (4.683) 4.967** (3.458) 5.783*** (6.443) 5.908*** (6.742) 5.666*** (5.722) 4.878** (3.441)

Note: *, **, and *** indicate the significance level at 10%, 5%, and 1% respectively. Numbers in the parenthesis indicate the t-statistics.