Table II.
Summary of long-term studies' PROM.
| Author | LOE | Follow-up mo, mean (range) | Number B shoulders | Treatment | ASES, mean (SD) [range] | Constant, mean (SD) [range] | SST (SD) [range] | DASH (SD) [range] | SANE (SD) [range] | PSS (SD) [range] | VAS (SD) [range] |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Onlay glenoid TSA | |||||||||||
| Walch et al (2012)50 | 4 | 77 (14 to 180) | 92 | Asymmetric reaming with all-polyethylene glenoid (7 shoulder treated with PGBG) | Pre: 32.4 (NR) [4 to 68] Post: 68.8 (NR) [25 to 95] | ||||||
| Chin et al (2015)6 | 3 | 60 (23 to 120) | 87 | Asymmetric reaming with pegged or keeled all-polyethylene glenoid | Pre: 50 (NR) [NR] Post: 5 (NR) [NR] | ||||||
| Steinmann and Cofield (2000)47 | 4 | 60 (24 to 132) | 25 | TSA with PGBG 15 Metal-backed cemented glenoid 10 Metal-backed uncemented glenoid 3 All-polyehtylene glenoid |
|||||||
| Klika et al (2014)29 | 4 | 105 (24 to 300) | 17 | TSA with PGBG 12 Metal-backed glenoid 6 All-polyehtylene keeled glenoid 7 All-polyethylene pegged glenoid |
|||||||
| Rice et al (2008)42 | 4 | 60 (24 to 96) | 14 | TSA with wedged augmented all-polyetheylene glenoid | |||||||
| Cil et al (2014)7 | 4 | 88 (24 to 228) | 23 | TSA with polyehtylene or metal-backed augmented glenoid | Post: 55 (NR) [8-100] | ||||||
| RSA | |||||||||||
| Collin et al (2019)8 | 4 | 84 (60 to 192) | 49 | RSA (16 required bone grafting) | Pre: 30 (NR) [NR] Post: 68 (NR) [NR] |
PROM, patient-reported outcome measures; LOE, level of evidence; ASES, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score; SD, standard deviation; SST, Simple Shoulder Test; DASH, Disability of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand; SANE, Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation; PSS, Penn Shoulder Score; VAS, Visual Analog Scale; TSA, total shoulder arthroplasty; PGBG, posterior glenoid bone graft; Pre, preoperative; NR, not reported; Post, postoperative; RSA, reverse shoulder arthroplasty.