Skip to main content
. 2016 Mar 11;2016(3):CD005563. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005563.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Al Tamimi 2015a ICU study.
Astaneh 2007 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Baldwin 2004 The intervention was not designed to prevent delirium. Cognitive impairment rather than delirium was used as an outcome measure.
Benedict 2009 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Bolotin 2014 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Brueckmann 2015 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Budd 1974 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Caplan 2006 Study not in hospitalised patients ‐ active intervention in community setting.
Cerchietti 2000 Not a delirium prevention study.
Colak 2015 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Cole 2002 Not a delirium prevention study.
Culp 2003 Randomisation not used and participants were long‐term care residents.
De Jonghe 2007 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Del Rosario 2008 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Ding 2015 PACU study.
Ding 2015a PACU study.
Ely 2004a ICU study.
Ely 2004b ICU study.
Finotto 2006 ICU study.
Gamberini 2009 ICU study.
Hsieh 2015 ICU study.
Hu 2006 Treatment study.
Hudetz 2009 ICU study.
Hudetz 2015 ICU study.
Hwang 2015 ICU study.
Inouye 1993a Not original research‐ review article.
Inouye 1999 Randomisation not used.
Kaneko 1999 A validated method for delirium diagnosis was not used. Although DSM‐IIIR diagnostic criteria used, data obtained from retrospective chart review.
Kat 2008 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Lackner 2008 Nursing home setting.
Landefeld 1995 Outcomes examined did not include delirium.
Lili 2013 Not delirium prevention.
Lundstrom 2005 Randomisation not used.
Maneeton 2007 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Marcantonio 2010 Post‐acute care, not hospital setting.
Mardani 2013 ICU study.
Marino 2009 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Mentes 2003 Randomisation not used.
Meybohm 2015 ICU study.
Milisen 2001 Not a randomised controlled trial. Before and after study.
Mudge 2008 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Myint 2013 Delirium not used as an outcome measure.
Naughton 2005 Randomisation not used.
Neri 2010 Not in hospitalised patients.
Oldenbeuving 2008 Treatment study.
Overshott 2010 Treatment study.
Pandharipande 2010 ICU study.
Parker 2015 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Parra Sanchez 2009 ICU study.
Perkisas 2015 Commentary.
Pitkala 2006 Treatment study.
Prakanrattana 2007 ICU study.
Pretto 2014 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
Ritchie 2008 No recruitment, trial stopped.
Saager 2015 ICU study.
Sauer 2014 ICU study.
Short 2015 Not a delirium prevention study.
Shu 2010 ICU study and method of delirium diagnosis not validated.
Tabatabaie 2015 Not a randomised controlled trial. Retrospective observational study.
Tabet 2005 Randomisation not used.
Takeuchi 2007 Treatment study and not randomised controlled trial.
Tokita 2001 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used. Delirium diagnosis relied on retrospective records review.
Torres 2015 A validated method for diagnosis of delirium was not used.
van de Steeg 2014 Primary outcome is screening for incidence of delirium; unable to report incidence of delirium as first date of delirium diagnosis is not recorded.
Wang 2012 ICU study.
Wanich 1992 Not a delirium prevention study.
Wong 2005 Not a randomised controlled study. Before and after study.
Yamaguchi 2014 ICU study.
Yang 2015 ICU study.

DSM‐IIR: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
 ICU: Intensive Care Unit
 PACU: post‐anaesthesia care unit