Table 1. Comparison of Parameters Extracted for Pr4+ from This Work with Other 4f-Based RE Ionsa.
| RE ion | host lattice | excited state (cm–1) | AJ (MHz) | gav | T (K) | T1 (ms) | Tm (μs) | T* (K) | ref |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pr4+ | BaSnO3 | ∼2000 | ∼1800 | ∼0.58 | 5 | ∼33 | ∼18 | ∼60 | this work |
| Ce3+ | CaWO4 | 53–135 | N/A | ∼1.4 | 5 | ∼24.7 | ∼14.2 | ∼18 | (42) |
| Nd3+ | Y2SiO5 | ∼77 | ∼530 | ∼2.6 | 5 | ∼30 | ∼106 | ∼7 | (16) |
| Gd3+ | CaWO4 | ∼33,000d | ∼15 | ∼2 | 6 | ∼8 | ∼5.4 | ∼70 | (43) |
| Gd3+ | trensalb | ∼33,000d | ∼2 | 5 | ∼0.03 | ∼12 | >30 | (44) | |
| Gd3+ | sTPATCN | ∼33,000d | ∼2 | 7 | ∼0.36 | ∼18.3 | >50 | (45) | |
| Er3+ | CaWO4 | ∼19 | ∼125 | ∼5 | 3.5 | ∼7 (50)e | (11) | ||
| Yb3+c | Y2SiO5 | ∼115 | ∼500 | ∼4 | 5 | ∼7 | ∼10 (73)e | ∼9 | (18) |
| Yb3+c | trensalb | ∼500 | ∼600 | ∼3.8 | 5 | ∼0.4 | ∼0.5 | 20 | (46) |
T* corresponds to the temperature at which Tm is limited by T1 given by Tm/T1 = 1.
Molecular complex.
Value reported for 171Yb.
For Gd3+, the excited state corresponds to the SOC multiplet and not a CF excited state. Given the 8S7/2 GS, the CF splitting is usually very small. This minimizes mixing from the excited 6P7/2 and 6D7/2 SOC multiplets and has been proposed to suppress decoherence due to the vanishing orbital angular momentum.
The values in the parenthesis correspond to the maximum value reported but measured at a lower temperature of 2–3 K. For a more direct comparison, the table is constructed with values reported at the base temperature of this study at T = 5 K.