Table 2. The mapping among the extracted requirements (R01 to R25) based on the responses of the participants to the survey questions (Q1 to Q5) and the design research question (RQ 1 to RQ 5).
Additionally, the last column shows how far we have addressed the requirements up to now.
Requirements | Survey Questions | Research Questions | Addressed? | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q5 | RQ1 | RQ2 | RQ3 | RQ4 | RQ5 | |||
R01 | Completeness of the ENVRI-KMS search space | X | X | X | Partially | |||||||
R02 | List of the contact persons | X | X | X | Not yet | |||||||
R03 | FAIRness criteria | X | X | X | X | Yes | ||||||
R04 | Entitiy types (private, open-source, etc.) | X | X | Not yet | ||||||||
R05 | Recommendations | X | X | X | X | X | Partially | |||||
R06 | Q&A forums for technical discussions | X | X | X | Not yet | |||||||
R07 | Ontologies and semantic search | X | X | X | Partially | |||||||
R08 | Multilingual queries | X | X | X | Not yet | |||||||
R09 | Source code and API search | X | X | Not yet | ||||||||
R10 | Search RI website’s contents | X | X | X | Yes | |||||||
R11 | Standard user interface | X | X | X | Yes | |||||||
R12 | SPARQL queries | X | X | Not yet | ||||||||
R13 | High performance and availability | X | X | Partially | ||||||||
R14 | APIs to be connected to VREs | X | X | Partially | ||||||||
R15 | Automatic knowledge ingestion | X | X | X | Yes | |||||||
R16 | Visualization | X | X | Partially | ||||||||
R17 | Image search | X | X | X | Partially | |||||||
R18 | Assessment tools | X | X | X | X | Not yet | ||||||
R19 | Manual knowledge ingestion | X | X | Yes | ||||||||
R20 | Updatable knowledge base | X | X | Yes | ||||||||
R21 | Dataset geolocations | X | X | X | Yes | |||||||
R22 | Metadata of the search space entities | X | X | X | Not yet | |||||||
R23 | Continuous integration and continuous delivery | X | X | Yes | ||||||||
R24 | Different user categories | X | X | Partially | ||||||||
R25 | Categories & classifications | X | X | X | Yes |