Table 1.
Study | Recruitment years | Study population or setting | Study design | Age range, years | Selection of study population | Specimen sample sites | HPV detection method | Risk score | Sample size |
Estimated HPV prevalence |
Inclusion in analyses |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Any type | HR-HPV | Overall | Age | Type | |||||||||||
Australia and New Zealand (Oceania) | |||||||||||||||
Australia | Machalek et al (2017)55* | 2014–16 | Sexual health clinics, general practice clinics, and outreach using Facebook | Cross-sectional | 16 to 35 | Convenience | Glans, corona, foreskin, and shaft | PCR-PGMY09-PGMY11, Cobas HPV test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) | High | 511 | 28% | 19% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Eastern and South-Eastern Asia | |||||||||||||||
China | Tang et al (2006)76 | 2003–04 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 18 to 70 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR-MY09-MY11 and restriction fragment length polymorphisms | High | 305 | 14% | NR | Yes | Yes | Yes |
China | He et al (2013)41* | 2007–09 | Rural community | Cross-sectional | 25 to 65 | Cluster | Glans, corona, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-SPF1/GP6+ | Low | 2236 | 18% | 6% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
China | Wei et al (2016)86* | 2014 | Urban community | Cross-sectional | 18 to 55 | Convenience | Glans, corona, penile, perianal, and anal canal | PCR-GP5+/6+ | Low | 1509 | 11% | 10% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
China | Zhang et al (2018)90* | 2013 | Rural community | Cross-sectional | <30 to >50† | Convenience | Urethra | Human Papillomavirus Genotyping Kit (Gene Chips; Genetel Pharmaceuticals, Shenzhen, China) | High | 104 | 13% | 10% | Yes | No | Yes |
China | Ma et al (2019)54 | 2016–18 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 18 to 67 | Convenience | Glans, corona, shaft, scrotum, and urethral | Real-time PCR genotyping (Liferiver, Shanghai, China) | High | 737 | 26% | 19% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
China | Wang et al (2021)84 | 2015–20 | Men attending Henan Provincial People's Hospital | Cross-sectional | 20 to 85 | Convenience | Glans, corona, shaft, prepuce, and distal urethra | PCR-HPV genotyping kit (Gene Chips; Genetel Pharmaceuticals, Shenzhen, China) | High | 3690 | 30% | 12% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Japan | Takahashi et al (2003)74 | 2002 | University students | Case-control | 18 to 35 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | Hybrid Capture 2, for high-risk and low-risk HPV types (Digene, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) | Low | 75 | 1% | 1% | Yes | No | No |
Japan | Takahashi et al (2005)75* | 2004 | University students | Cross-sectional | 18 to 35 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | Hybrid Capture 2, for high-risk and low-risk HPV types (Digene, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) | Low | 150 | 8% | 8% | Yes | No | No |
Japan | Matsuzawa et al (2020)56* | 2011–15 | Urology clinic | Cross-sectional | 15 to 95 | Convenience | Glans | PCR-GENOSEARCH-HPV31 (Medical and Biological Laboratories, Nagoya, Japan) | High | 759 | 25% | 13% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Malaysia | Khoo et al (2021)48 | 2014–16 | Community | Cross-sectional | 18 to 60 | Convenience | Shaft | PCR-BGISEQ-100 (Beijing Genome Institute-assembled Ion Proton Sequencer from Life Technologies, South San Francisco, CA, USA) | Low | 389 | 21% | 19% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
South Korea | Shin et al (2004)70 | 2002 | University students | Cross-sectional | 18 to 28 | Convenience | Glans, corona, foreskin, penile, and scrotum | PCR line probe assay | Low | 381 | 9% | 4% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Philippines, Taiwan, and Australia | Vardas et al (2011)80 | 2004–08 | Community (baseline data of men participating in the Gardasil trial) | Cross-sectional | 16 to 14 | Convenience | Penile, scrotum, and perineal or perianal areas | PCR multiplex real-time fluorescent detection (Atila BioSystems, Mountain View, CA, USA) | Low | 263 | 10% | 9% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Europe and Northern America | |||||||||||||||
Canada | Ogilvie et al (2009)62* | 2006–07 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 16 to 69 | Convenience | Glans, foreskin, penile shaft, and scrotum | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) | High | 261 | 61% | 57% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Canada | El-Zein et al (2019)37* | 2005–11 | University students | Cohort | 17 to 45 | Convenience | Glans, corona, foreskin, shaft, and scrotum | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) | Low | 535 | 59% | 42% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Canada | Nelson et al (2019)59* | 2011–13 | Urban community | Cross-sectional | 16 to 83 | Convenience | Foreskin and shaft | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) | High | 175 | 43% | 24% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Croatia | Bosnjak et al (2013)34 | 2009–11 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 17 to 60 | Convenience | Genital | PCR-AMPLICOR HPV test (Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany) | High | 330 | 32% | 32% | Yes | Yes | No |
Czechia | Jaworek et al (2021)46 | 2013–16 | Men in couples treated for infertility | Cross-sectional | 22 to 57 | Convenience | Glans and corona | PCR-PapilloCheck test (Greiner Bio-One, Frickenhausen, Germany) | High | 195 | 41% | 31% | Yes | No | Yes |
Denmark | Hebnes et al (2015)42* | 2006–07 | Military conscripts and employees | Cross-sectional | 18 to 65 | Population-based | Glans, corona, foreskin, shaft, scrotum, and perineum | PCR-INNO-LiPA HPV Genotyping Extra II (Innogenetics, Ghent, Belgium) | Low | 2436 | 42% | 30% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Denmark | Kjaer et al (2005)49 | 1998 | Miltary conscripts | Cohort | 18 to 29 | Population-based | Glans and corona | PCR-GP5+/6+ | Low | 337 | 34% | NR | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Finland | Kero et al (2011)47 | No data | Male spouses of pregnant women in their third trimester | Cohort | 19 to 46 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR-GP5+/6+ and MY09/11 | Low | 128 | 23% | 9% | Yes | No | Yes |
Italy | Bartoletti et al (2014)31 | 2005–06 | STI clinic | Case-control | 18 to 45 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR-INNO-LiPA HPV Genotyping Extra (Innogenetics, Rome, Italy) | High | 1081 | 27% | 11% | Yes | No | No |
Netherlands | Bleeker et al (2005)33 | 2002 | Outpatient clinic (not an STI clinic) | Cross-sectional | 23 to 73 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | PCR-GP5+/6+ | Low | 83 | 25% | 19% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Netherlands | Vriend et al (2013)83* | 2009–11 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 16 to 24 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | PCR-SPF10-DEIA line probe assay (DDL Diagnostic Laboratory, Rijswijk, Netherlands) | High | 414 | 54% | 40% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Netherlands | Luttmer et al (2015)53* | 2011–12 | Healthy men | Cross-sectional | 18 to 65 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | PCR-SPF10-DNA enzyme-linked immunoassay (DDL Diagnostic Laboratory, Rijswijk, Netherlands) | Low | 170 | 34% | 26% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Netherlands | Koene et al (2016)50* | 2011 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 18 to 61 | Convenience | Glans, corona, shaft, and urethra | PCR-RHA Kit SPF10-LiPA25 version 1 (Labo Bio-medical Products, Rijswijk, Netherlands) | High | 111 | 65% | 42% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Russia | Smelov et al (2013)71* | 2006–09 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 16 to 60 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR-Bioplex 200 Luminex system (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA) | High | 895 | 25% | 17% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Slovenia | Golob et al (2014)39* | 2010–13 | Male partners from couples attending a clinic due to inability to conceive within at least one year of unprotected regular sexual intercourse | Cross-sectional | 16 to 55 | Convenience | Penile surface | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Diagnostics, Pleasanton, CA, USA) | High | 299 | 37% | 17% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Spain | Álvarez-Argüelles et al (2013)28* | 2002–11 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 17 to 87 | Convenience | Balanopreputial or urethral | PCR-MY11/MY09 and GP5+/GP6+ | High | 565 | 12% | 3% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Sweden | Wikström et al (2000)89 | No data | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 18 to 54 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | PCR reverse hybridisation DNA sequencing | High | 235 | 13% | 8% | Yes | No | Yes |
Sweden | Söderlund-Strand et al (2013)79 | 2008 | Sexual health clinic | Cross-sectional | 20 to 29 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR-HPV MassArray (Agena Bioscience, Hamburg, Germany) | High | 597 | 22% | NR | Yes | Yes | No |
Sweden | Söderlund-Strand et al (2015)72 | No data | Sexual health clinic | Cross-sectional | 21 to 56 | Convenience | Shaft | PCR-HPV MassArray (Agena Bioscience, Hamburg, Germany) | High | 127 | 49% | 34% | Yes | No | Yes |
UK | Jalal et al (2007)45 | 2003 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 15 to 77 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR reverse blot hybridisation | High | 437 | 21% | 13% | Yes | No | Yes |
UK | Cuschieri et al (2011)35* | 2007–08 | Youth clinic | Cross-sectional | 16 to 25 | Convenience | Shaft | PCR-INNO-LiPA HPV Genotyping Extra II (Fujirebio, Gent, Belgium) | High | 117 | 29% | 20% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Baldwin et al (2003)30 | 2000–01 | STI clinic | Cross-sectional | 18 to 70 | Convenience | Glans and corona | PCR-PGMY09/11 and reverse line blot or PCR-L1 consensus | High | 393 | 28% | 12% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Weaver et al (2004)85 | 2001–02 | University students | Cross-sectional | 18 to 25 | Population-based | Glans, foreskin, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-MY09/MY11/HMB01 | Low | 317 | 33% | NR | Yes | Yes | No |
USA | Nielson et al (2007)61 | 2003–06 | STI clinic and the community | Cross-sectional | 18 to 40 | Convenience | Glans, corona, shaft, scrotum, urethra, perianal area, anal canal, and semen | PCR-PGMY09/11 and reverse line blot | High | 463 | 65% | 29% | Yes | No | Yes |
USA | Partridge et al (2007)65 | 2003–06 | University students | Cohort | 18 to 20 | Population-based | Glans, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-based direct DNA sequencing | Low | 240 | 26% | 20% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Hernandez et al (2008)43* | 2004–06 | University population | Cohort | 18 to 79 | Convenience | Glans, corona, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-PGMY09/11 and reverse line blot | Low | 410 | 40% | 24% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Hernandez et al (2013)44 | 2010–12 | Community clinic and medical practices | Cross-sectional | 14 to 59 | Convenience | Glans, corona, foreskin, and shaft | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | High | 450 | 44% | 16% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Sudenga et al (2017)73* | 2005–09 | Community (HPV Infection in Men study [HIM]) | Cohort | 18 to 70 | Baseline | Glans, corona, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-L1 consensus and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 1274 | 47% | 28% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Gargano et al (2017)38* | 2013–14 | Community (NHANES) | Cross-sectional | 14 to 59‡ | Population-based | Glans | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) | Low | 1623 | 47% | 26% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA | Widdice et al (2019)88 | 2013–14 | Hospital-based adolescent primary care clinic, STI clinic, and the community | Cross-sectional | 13 to 26 | Sequential sampling | Glans, corona, shaft, scrotum, and perianal or anal areas | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, CA, USA) | High | 310 | 61% | NR | Yes | No | Yes |
Croatia, Finland, Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, and Sweden | Vardas et al (2011)80 | 2004–08 | Community (baseline data of men participating in the Gardasil trial) | Cross-sectional | 16 to 24 | Convenience | Penile, scrotum, and perineal or perianal areas | PCR-Multiplex Real Time Fluorescent Detection (Atila BioSystems, Mountain View, CA, USA) | Low | 354 | 21% | 20% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USA and Canada | Vardas et al (2011)80 | 2004–08 | Community (baseline data of men participating in the Gardasil trial) | Cross-sectional | 16 to 24 | Convenience | Penile, scrotum, and perineal or perianal areas | PCR-Multiplex Real Time Fluorescent Detection (Atila BioSystems, Mountain View, CA, USA) | Low | 712 | 27% | 24% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Latin America and the Caribbean | |||||||||||||||
Brazil | Rosenblatt et al (2004)67 | 1999–2001 | Partners of women screened for cervical cancer | Cross-sectional | NR | Convenience | Foreskin, shaft, dorsal and ventral prebalanic area, and urethra | Hybrid Capture 2, for high-risk and low-risk HPV types (Digene, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) | Low | 60 | 15% | 15% | Yes | No | No |
Brazil | Benzaken et al (2012)32* | 2009 | Community | Cross-sectional | 15 to 64 | Convenience | Urethra | Hybrid Capture 2, for high-risk HPV types (Digene, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) | High | 278 | 14% | 14% | Yes | Yes | No |
Brazil | Afonso et al (2013)26 | 2000–10 | Partners of women screened for cervical cancer | Cross-sectional | 18 to 51 | Convenience | Penile scrape | PCR-MY09/11 type-specific E6 | Low | 60 | 17% | NR | Yes | No | No |
Brazil | Menezes et al (2014)58 | 2011–14 | Asymptomatic men from an STI clinic, a dermatology clinic, and a metallurgical factory | Cross-sectional | 18 to 65 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism | High | 550 | 22% | 10% | Yes | No | Yes |
Brazil | Afonso et al (2016)27* | 2010–11 | Asymptomatic men having laboratory tests done | Cross-sectional | 1867 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and frenulum | PCR-MY09/11 type-specific E6 | High | 110 | 16% | 4% | Yes | No | Yes |
Brazil | Sudenga et al (2017)73* | 2005–09 | Community (HPV in Men study [HIM]) | Cross-sectional | 18 to 70 | Baseline | Glans, corona, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-L1 consensus and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 1398 | 60% | 34% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Brazil | Wendland et al (2020)87* | 2016–17 | Young people who use public health system | Cross-sectional | 15 to 25 | Convenience | Glans, corona, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-L1 consensus and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 1120 | 53% | 29% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Chile | Guzmán et al (2008)40 | No data | University students | Cross-sectional | 20 to 51 | Convenience | Corona and shaft | PCR-GP5+/6+ and reverse line blot | Low | 61 | 84% | 75% | Yes | No | Yes |
Mexico | Lazcano-Ponce et al (2001)52 | 1998 | University students and industry workers | Cross-sectional | 14 to 55 | Convenience | Corona and urethra | PCR-GP5+/6+ | Low | 96 | 43% | 20% | Yes | No | No |
Mexico | Sánchez-Alemán et al (2002)69 | 2000–01 | University students | Cross-sectional | ≥16 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and foreskin | Hybrid Capture 2, for high-risk HPV types (Digene, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) | Low | 71 | 9% | 9% | Yes | Yes | No |
Mexico | Lajous et al (2005)51* | 2000–03 | Military | Cross-sectional | 16 to 40 | Convenience | Corona, shaft, scrotum, and urethra | PCR strip assay using the reverse line blot | Low | 1045 | 43% | 32% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Mexico | Vaccarella et al (2006)78 | 2003–04 | Men seeking vasectomy | Cross-sectional | 15 to 65 | Convenience | Glans, corona, foreskin, shaft, scrotum, and urethra | PCR-L1 consensus | Low | 779 | 9% | 6% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Mexico | Parada et al (2010)64* | 2002–03 | Partners of women attending a primary health centre | Cross-sectional | 18 to 75 | Convenience | Foreskin, shaft, scrotum, and urethra | PCR-L1 consensus and reverse line blot | Low | 504 | 20% | 8% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Mexico | Vera-Uehara et al (2014)82 | 2002–03 | University students | Cross-sectional | ≥18 | Convenience | Penis, glans, and corona | PCR-MY09/MY11 and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 253 | 19% | 17% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Mexico | Sudenga et al (2017)73* | 2005–09 | Community (HPV in Men study [HIM]) | Cross-sectional | 18 to 70 | Baseline | Glans, corona, shaft, and scrotum | PCR-L1 consensus and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 1342 | 50% | 27% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Brazil, Costa Rica, Mexico, Peru | Vardas et al (2011)80 | 2004–08 | Community (baseline data of men participating in the Gardasil trial) | Cross-sectional | 16 to 24 | Convenience | Penile, scrotum, and perineal or perianal areas | PCR-Multiplex Real Time Fluorescent Detection (Atila BioSystems, Mountain View, CA, USA) | Low | 1301 | 29% | 26% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Sub-Saharan Africa | |||||||||||||||
Botswana | Ramogola-Masire et al (2022)66* | 2019–21 | Men without HIV infection from the University of Botswana | Cross-sectional | 18 to 22 | Convenience | Penile, shaft, glans, and foreskin | PCR real-time Anyplex II HPV28 assay (Seegene, Seoul, South Korea) | Low | 493 | 31% | 24% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Kenya | Ng'ayo et al (2008)60* | 2005 | Fishermen from the community | Cross-sectional | 18 to 68 | Population-based | Glans, corona, shaft, scrotum, and perianal region | PCR-MY09/MY11/HMB01 and Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 186 | 53% | 32% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Kenya | Rositch et al (2012)68 | 2002–05 | Community (circumcision trial) | Cross-sectional | 17 to 28 | Population-based | Glans, corona, foreskin, and shaft | PCR-GP5+/6+ and reverse line blot hybridisation | Low | 2702 | 51% | 35% | Yes | No | Yes |
Mozambique | Edna Omar et al (2017)36 | 2009–11 | Young people attending a youth clinic | Cross-sectional | 18 to 24 | Convenience | Urethra | PCR-Clart HPV 2 (Genomica, Madrid, Spain) | High | 176 | 10% | 6% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Rwanda | Veldhuijzen et al (2012)81* | 2007–09 | Control group in an infertility study | Case-control | 21 to 57 | Convenience | Glans, corona, foreskin, shaft, and scrotum | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 166 | 43% | 27% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
South Africa | Mbulawa et al (2010)57* | 2006–09 | Couples studies | Cross-sectional | 19 to 67 | Convenience | Glans, foreskin, and shaft | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | High | 313 | 51% | 25% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
South Africa | Auvert et al (2010)29 | 2005–06 | Community (circumcision trial) | Cross-sectional | 18 to 24 | Population-based | Urethra | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 1683 | 19% | 17% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
South Africa | Vardas et al (2011)80 | 2004–08 | Community (baseline data of men participating in the Gardasil trial) | Cross-sectional | 16 to 24 | Convenience | Penile, scrotal, and perineal or perianal areas | PCR-Multiplex Real Time Fluorescent Detection (Atila BioSystems, Mountain View, CA, USA) | Low | 518 | 42% | 36% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Tanzania | Olesen et al (2013)63* | 2009 | Urban and rural community | Cross-sectional | 16 to 65 | Convenience | Glans, corona, and shaft | Hybrid Capture 2 HPV DNA Test, for high-risk and low-risk HPV types (Qiagen Gaithersburg, MD, USA) and INNO-LiPA HPV Genotyping Extra II (Fujirebio, Gent, Belgium) | Low | 1343 | 20% | 15% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Uganda | Tobian et al (2013)77 | 2003–06 | Community (circumcision trial) | Cross-sectional | 15 to 49 | Population-based | Glans and corona | PCR Linear Array HPV Genotyping Test (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) | Low | 978 | 61% | 39% | Yes | Yes | Yes |
HPV=human papillomavirus. HR-HPV=high-risk HPV. NR=not reported. STI=sexually transmitted infection.
Authors provided additional information.
Data were reported from men younger than 30 years, men aged 30–49 years, and men aged 50 years or older; the full range of ages included was not reported.
To exclude HPV-vaccinated cohorts, only data for people aged 20–59 years were considered.