Table 1.
Study characteristics.
Study | Experimental design | Subjects | Supplementation | Fluid replenishment time and dose | Exercise protocol | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hogervorst et al. (1999) | Double-blind RCT with a crossover design | 15 healthy male competitive cyclists or triathletes (23.3 ± 3.6 years) | 1) Placebo water 2) Placebo- carbohydrates 68.8 g/L 3) carbohydrates combined with caffeine 150 mg/L 4) with caffeine 225 mg/L 5) with caffeine 320 mg/L. Each subject was tested at different times for 5 solutions. | With 8 mL fluid/kg body weigh ingestion before trial at warm-up session and 3 mL fluid/kg body weigh ingestion every 20 min during the trial. | An all-out 1 h time trial on a bicycle ergometer. | The Stroop Color-Word Test. Signal Detection Task. The Motor Choice Reaction Time Test and the visual Verbal Learning Test with Interference were measured. |
Pomportes et al. (2019) | Single-blind RCT with a pseudo counter-balanced design | 10 pentathlon athletes (6 males and 4 females, age 18.6 ± 2 years) | 1) A 6% carbohydrate complex 2) A 200 milligrams (mg) caffeine added with orange sugarless syrup 3) A 3.4 grams (g) guarana complex 4) A placebo. | Two before exercise and one during exercise. | The exercise involved a 40 min run on a treadmill at a steady speed and each athlete participates four times. | Simon tasks were measured. |
Winnick et al. (2005) | Double-blind RCT | 20 active men (N = 10,24.9 ± 2.08 years) and women (N = 10,22.9 ± 1.45 years), with experience competing in team sports. | 1) A 6% CHO solution 2) A flavored placebo (PBO). | Subjects received 5 mL/kg of fluid before exercise and 3 mL/kg after exercise, in addition to 3 mL/kg over a 5 min span after the first and third quarters, and 8 mL/kg during a 20 min halftime. Consumption of carbohydrate was approximately 41 g h−1 in the CHO trial. | Four 15 min quarters of shuttle running with variable intensities ranging from walking (30%VO2max), to running (120%VO2max), to maximal sprinting, and 40 jumps at a target hanging at 80% of their maximum vertical jump height. | The Stroop Color and Word Test were measured. |
Zhu et al. (2020) | A single-blind RCT with a cross-over design. | 14 male soccer athletes (age, 24.3 ± 3.7 years) | 1) Control (electrolyte solution without CHO) 2) CHO (4.2 g/100 mL CHO, 3 mL/kg in each trial), 3) CHO-M (brief MBI). | Participants were instructed to consume 3 mL/kg in each trial during the half-time break. | Soccer games. | The Stroop effect task (ST), Corsi-block-tapping test (CBT), and rapid visual information processing task (RVIPT) |
Dupuy and Tremblay (2019) | RCT | 85 recreationally active males (24.4 ± 4.6) | 1) Water (control) 2) Glucose (60 g/L) 3) A commercial sports drink (CSD) 4) Diluted maple syrup 5) Concentrated maple water. | Subjects ingested 166 mL of the experimental solution, drinking a total of 1 L of the same solution throughout the experimentation. | Six 3 min bouts at 95% of their maximal aerobic power on a stationary bike, with 3 min of passive rest between efforts. | Plasma glucose concentration, peak power output, maximal oxygen consumption, cognitive task and cerebral oxygenation were measured. Cognitive performance was assessed by the computerized modified Stroop task. |
Harper et al. (2017) | Randomised, crossover. | 15 male University soccer players (age: 22 ± 2 years) | 1) Water; WAT 2) Carbohydrate-electrolyte, 12% CHO, 60 g·500 mL−1 3) Placebo-electrolyte; PL) | Beverages were ingested towards the end of the warm-up (250 mL) and at HT (250 mL); both <15 min before each half commenced. | 90 min of soccer-specific exercise (including self-paced 6 exercise at the end of each half). | Physical, technical and cognitive (memory, attention, decision making) performance were assessed. |
Sun et al. (2020) | Double-blind RCT with a crossover design | 16 male college soccer players (21 ± 1 years) | 1) Carbohydrate-electrolyte-solution (CES,6% CHO in the form of sucrose) 2) Carbohydrate-electrolyte-protein-solution (CEPS,4% CHO in the form of sucrose plus 2% whey PRO) 3) Placebo (PLA). | Before warming up (5 mL/kg BM) and every 15 min thereafter (during resting period, 2 mL/kg BM). | In each trial, they completed 30 min of 70% VO2peak cycling, and one of two solutions (CES or CEPS) was consumed. | The Visual Search Test, the Stroop Test, and the Rapid Visual Information Processing Test were measured. |
Pomportes et al. (2016) | A double blind, randomized, crossover research design | 17 high-level squash and fencing athletes (7 females and 10 males, 19.1 ± 1 years) | 1) 7% carbohydrate complex (CHO: fructose and maltodextrine, Isoxan Sport) 2) Placebo (Pl, 250 mL tap water added with orange sugarless syrup). | During each experimental session, subjects ingested 60 min (Ing1) and 30 min (Ing2) before exercise either 250 mL of a 7% carbohydrate complex or placebo. | 6 sprints (5 s) with a passive recovery (25 s) followed by 15 min submaximal cycling. | Physiological parameters, perceived exertion, shooting performance and cognitive function were measured. Cognitive function included a simple reaction time (SRT) task at rest, a visual scanning task (VS) and a Go/No-go task (GNG) during a submaximal cycling exercise. |
Wong et al. (2014) | Randomized crossover study design | 9 healthy active males (n = 9) and 10 eumenorrheic females (n = 10), 23.1 ± 1.2 years for males, 22.6 ± 0.8 years for females. | 1) Carbohydrate-electrolyte solution (CES, CHO 6.6%) 2) Lemon tea (LT) 3) Distilled water (DW) | The total intake volume of fluid during REC was equivalent to 150% of BM loss during the previous 60-min run. The fluid was consumed in 6 equal volumes at 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, and 180 min of the REC. | All participants completed a 60 min moderate endurance run at 60% VO2max on a motorized treadmill in a hot and humid environment (temperature: 29.2 ± 0.9°C; relative humidity: 71 ± 5%) of 3 times. Immediately after the run, the 4 h recovery (REC) period commenced. | Plasma volume (PV) changes, serum osmolality, plasma sodium, potassium concentrations, abdominal discomfort (AD), stomach fullness (SF), and the CogState battery were measured. |
Pollow et al. (2016) | Double-blind RCT with a crossover design. | 7 well-trained cyclists and triathletes (26.9 ± 3.9 years) | 1) A carbohydrate–electrolyte beverage (5 mL/kg, 6.3% CHO, 18 mM sodium) 2) A capsule containing 6 mg/kg of caffeine 3) A capsule containing a placebo. | A first CHO beverage was consumed 1 h before trials and a second at the onset of each trial. | Two trials to exhaustion (TTE) at 90% VO2 peak and two 50 km time trials (TTD) | Exercise performance, metabolic parameters, alertness, cognitive performance and perception of trial substance were measured. Cognitive function included a computerized ANAM® test and Stroop word-color test. |