Table 2.
Publication | Study Name | Patient Population & Study Design | Description | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|
Messenger RNA | ||||
Deng 8 , 2006 | CARGO | 8 U.S. centers, 629 patients, Prospective cohort study | Derivation and validation of GEP | AUC of 0.72 to detect ACR ≥ 3A with GEP score >20, prevalence analysis resulting in 99% NPV using score >30 |
Pham 9 , 2010 | IMAGE | 13 U.S. centers, 602 patients, Randomized clinical trial | Noninferiority analysis of EMB vs. GEP starting at 6-months | With GEP score <34 to rule out rejection, similar event rates in EMB and GEP groups |
Moayedi 23 , 2019 | OAR | 35 U.S. centers, 1504 patients, Cross-sectional | Clinical validation with long-term follow-up of patients who underwent GEP surveillance | 2% prevalence of ACR both before and after six months post-transplant, 94% 5-year survival |
MicroRNA | ||||
Duong Van Huyen 24 , 2014 | 4 French centers, 113 patients, Case-control study | Pre-selected evaluation of 14 miR transcripts by RT-PCR, from both EMB and serum samples | Four miRs were differentially expressed in tissue and serum and validated in ACR and AMR as compared to controls | |
Dewi 25 , 2017 | 6 Canadian centers, 63 patients, Case-control study | Pre-selected miRs evaluated by RT-PCR evaluation in serum | Two miRs were associated with ACR, after controlling for immunosuppressive drug levels, kidney function, and C-reactive protein | |
Constanso-Conde 26 , 2020 | 1 Spanish center, 66 patients, Prospective Cohort study | Pre-selected evaluation of differential miR expression in ACR by RT-PCR | miR-181a-5p was differentially expressed in ACR ≥ 2R with rise and fall pattern associated with development/treatment of rejection | |
Shah 27 , 2022 | GRAfT | 5 U.S. centers, 157 patients, Case-control study | NGS evaluating miR expression | Distinct miR scores between 0–100 were able to distinguish ACR and AMR. Developed and validated for ACR ≥ 2R and pAMR ≥ 1 |
AUC, area under the curve; ACR, acute cellular rejection; AMR, antibody-mediated rejection; EMB; endomyocardial biopsy; GEP, gene expression profiling; mRNA, messenger RNA; miR, microRNA; NGS, next generation sequencing; NPV, negative predictive value; RT-PCR, reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction;