Table 3.
The final Conversation skills Assessment Tool (ChAT) tool.
Definition of observable behaviour | Clarifications/examples | Score | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. Comments about the Researcher personally: The P comments on R’ interests, opinions, personal stories. The P can also ask questions that are personal. |
P: What did you do over the weekend (Personal question) P: You look tired today (Personal comment/observation) |
|||||||
I1 | I2 | I3 | I4 | I5 | 1 – present 0 – absent |
Subtotal 1 | ||
2. Gives appropriate answers: There is a clear connection between what the R asks/says and what the P replies or asks back. |
R: What are your hobbies? (Appropriate answers) P: Fishing, hunting (Inappropriate answer) P: Annoying my brother |
|||||||
I1 | I2 | I3 | I4 | I5 | 0 – absent 0.5 – not consistent 1 – present |
Subtotal 2 | ||
3. Asks appropriate question(s) about the topic: P asks questions that are not too personal or potentially controversial |
Appropriate: Occupation, education, interests, hobbies. Inappropriate: Age, sexual orientation, money, politics, religion. |
|||||||
I1 | I2 | I3 | I4 | I5 | 1 – present 0 – absent |
Subtotal 3 | ||
4. Communicates at a reasonable pace: R doesn’t need to ask the P to repeat something, unless the R has difficulty understanding the P's accent. At the same time, there aren’t long pauses after a question, that the R doesn’t need to repeat the question. |
R asks a Q; P responds within 3 s; P talks at a speed that is clear and understandable Note any consistent need to repeat a question/statement |
|||||||
Add the Number of long pauses for the whole conversation: I1 – I5 | 1 – Five or more 2 – Three or Four 3 – Two |
4 – Once 5 – None |
Subtotal 4 | |||||
5. Shows continued interest in topic: Keeps the interaction going (i.e., asking sub-questions, making subsequent comments, laughing appropriately,). Engaged body language |
Says ‘aha’ or ‘yeah’, ‘em’, ‘yes’, ‘right’, ‘sure’ or similar Nodding Looking at R, not laying back on the chair, not folding his/her arms, etc. |
|||||||
I1 | I2 | I3 | I4 | I5 | 0 – no interest 0.5 – shows interest in part of the interaction 1 – consistent interest |
Subtotal 5 | ||
Definition of observable behaviour | Clarifications/ Examples | Score | ||||||
6. Elaborates on open ended questions: Does not provide a quick, brief, concise answer but rather offers a more detailed, informative and expansive response SHORT: One phrase/sentence MEDIUM: two phrases/sentences (separated by comma or full stop) LONG: Three or more phrase/sentences (separated by commas and/or full stops) Phrase: a few words without verb or subject Sentence: a verb and subject along with other words 7. |
R: What do like to do in your spare time? P: I like to do a lot of interesting and exciting things in my spare time, such as play football (1 sentence- SHORT) [The first sentence doesn’t offer any info] P: I like to play football and basketball (2 sentences - MEDIUM) [Play basketball is the implication] P: I like to play football, soccer, basketball, tennis and watch Homeland, House of Cards, The Americans, The Good Fight, on TV (8 Sentences- LONG) [Implication of play 4 things and watch 4 things] P: I like watching my team because they are entertaining to see play, kind to their fans and well-behaved off the court (3 sentences – LONG) [Implication: Are kind … are well-behaved..] |
|||||||
I1 | I2 | I3 | I4 | I5 |
First & follow-up questions in an interaction 1 – short & short 2 – short & medium 3 – short & long |
4 – medium 5 – long |
Subtotal 6 | |
7. Allows the other person to be part of the conversation: The P does not take over the conversation; he/she gives the R the chance to be equal partners in the conversation. OR does not get interrupted when trying to speak. The R's body language does not change |
The R does not go quiet (not even saying ‘yeah’, ‘aha’, emm, or similar) R doesn’t start slouching, looking at the watch, looking elsewhere for more extended periods. |
|||||||
Add the Number of interruptions for the whole conversation: I1 – I5 Note 0.5 – The participant thought the researcher finished speaking and spoke themselves 0.5 – There is a pause by both researcher and participant and then they speak together 1 – A clear interruption by the Participant |
1 – four or more 2 – three 3 – twice 4 – once 5 – none |
Subtotal 7 | ||||||
Subtotal 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 = Total score |