Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 27;32(11):1501–1513. doi: 10.1007/s10068-023-01285-2

Table 5.

β-Carotene and β-apo-8′-carotenal contents of processed food samples analyzed in this study

Processed food sample Label Food matrix classification β-carotene (µg/g) β-apo-8′-carotenal (µg/g)
Soft drink 1 β-Carotene Low-fat liquid 1.43ijkl ND
Soft drink 2 β-Carotene Low-fat liquid 2.13efg ND
Soft drink 3 β-Carotene Low-fat liquid 1.58hijk ND
Soft drink 4 β-Carotene Low-fat liquid 1.72ijk ND
Bread 1 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 1.72ghij ND
Bread 2 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 2.43e ND
bread 3 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 3.27d ND
Bread 4 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid Trace ND
Bread 5 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 0.74mno ND
Bread 6 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid Trace ND
Bread 7 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 2.20ef ND
Bread 8 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Bread 9 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Bread 10 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 2.04efgh ND
Cake 1 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 0.50o ND
Cake 2 β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Cake 3 β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Cake 4 Negative Moderate-fat solid 0.76mno ND
Cake 5 Negative Moderate-fat solid 1.43ijkl ND
Castella β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 4.28c ND
Chip β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Cracker 1 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 4.87b ND
Cracker 2 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 4.96b ND
Waffle β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid Trace ND
Cookie 1 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 1.17klm ND
Cookie 2 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 0.63no ND
Smoked cheese 1 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid Trace ND
Smoked cheese 2 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 0.55o ND
Gouda cheese β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 1.85fghi ND
Cheddar cheese 1 β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid ND 0.35c
Cheddar cheese 2 β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Cheddar cheese 3 β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid 0.48o 1.63a
Cheddar cheese 4 Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Cheddar cheese 5 Negative Moderate-fat solid 1.17klm ND
Cheddar cheese 6 Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
cheddar cheese 7 Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Cheddar cheese 8 Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Shredded cheese β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid ND 1.31b
Blended cheese 1 β-Apo-8′-carotenal Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Blended cheese 2 Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Emmental cheese Negative Moderate-fat solid 1.40ijkl ND
Brie cheese Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Camembert cheese Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Plain cheese Negative Moderate-fat solid ND ND
Chocolate snack 1 β-carotene moderate-fat Solid 6.92a ND
Chocolate snack 2 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 4.28c ND
Chocolate snack 3 β-Carotene Moderate-fat solid 0.79mno ND
Butter 1 β-Carotene High-fat solid 1.02lmn ND
Butter 2 Negative High-fat solid 0.67no ND
Butter 3 Negative High-fat solid 2.04efgh ND
Butter 4 Negative High-fat solid 1.20klm ND
Butter 5 Negative High-fat solid Trace ND
Butter 6 Negative High-fat solid 1.55ijk ND
Butter 7 Negative High-fat solid 2.05efg ND
Butter 8 Negative High-fat solid 1.78fghi ND
Margarine 1 β-Carotene High-fat solid 1.81fghi ND
Margarine 2 Negative High-fat solid Trace ND

β-Carotene and β-apo-8′-carotenal contents followed by different letters for different processed samples are significantly different for the same compound by Duncan’s test at p < 0.05. ND and trace indicate that the result is below the method detection limit (MDL) or method quantitation limit (MQL), respective