Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 28;11(8):2128. doi: 10.3390/biomedicines11082128

Table 1.

Overview of included studies.

Author Country Year S NS n (cT3) TL OP 2-Year
OS
3-Year
OS
5-Year
OS
5-Year
DSS
Type of Non-Surgical
Organ Preservation
TL * OP * TL * OP * TL * OP * TL * OP *
1 Bryant et al. [12] Australia 1995 R 7 97 42 55 18 28 RT alone
2 Kowalski et al. [13] Brazil 1996 R 7 221 176 45 39 27 51 28 69 29 RT alone
3 Porter et al. [14] NZ 1998 R 7 71 46 25 16 17 RT alone
4 Thakar et al. [15] India 2000 R 7 119 65 54 13 14 13 17 18 25 RT alone
5 Nguyen-Tan et al. [16] USA 2001 R 7 83 70 13 CRT
6 Sessions et al. [17] USA 2002 R 7 65 36 29 16 16 10 13 RT alone
7 Dziegielewski et al. [18] Canada 2012 R 7 126 35 91 4 34 8 46 11 63 Both CRT and RT, separate data available
8 Karlsson et al. [19] Sweden 2014 R 7 71 17 54 CRT and RT, separately not specified in data
9 Timme et al. [20] USA 2015 R 7 44 19 25 2 7 5 6 11 16 CRT
10 Connor et al. [21] Scotland 2015 R 7 106 30 76 2 21 Both CRT and RT, separate data available
11 Timmermans et al. [22] Netherlands 2016 R 7 1922 324 1598 109 510 131 661 180 973 CRT and RT, separately not specified in data
12 Daneshi et al. [23] Iran 2018 R 7 151 127 24 27 13 37 15 CRT
13 Čoček et al. [24] Czech Rep. 2018 R 7 70 45 25 8 6 11 8 17 13 CRT and RT, separately not specified in data
14 Bates et al. [25] USA 2019 R 7 7569 1044 6525 282 1631 407 2414 522 3067 CRT
15 Shi et al. [26] USA 2021 R 7 88 32 56 7 20 9 24 19 32 CRT
16 Lee et al. [27] USA 2023 R 7 137 41 96 16 19 20 32 26 51 CRT and RT, not specified in data

All the included studies were level 3 evidence as per the Oxford Centre for Based Medicine (OCEBM) criteria. S—Study type, R—Retrospective, NS—Newcastle–Ottawa Scale, NZ—New Zealand, OS—Overall survival, DSS—Disease-specific survival, TL—Total laryngectomy, OP—Organ preservation, *—Events. CRT—Chemoradiation. RT—Radiation alone.