TABLE 1.
Study and Patient Characteristics of 30 Included Studies Reporting on Pouch Failure Following Primary IPAA Published Since 2010
| Author | Year | Country | Study Period | Study Type | N | Disease UC/IC/CD/FAP/ Other or Unspecified | Age | Gender (% Female) | Laparoscopic Approach (%) | Stapled Anastomosis (%) | Primary Diverting Ileostomy (%) | Median Follow-up Time (yrs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carcamo et al31 | 2020 | Chile | 1984–2017 | R, single center | 116 | 116 | 35 | 67 (57.8) | 11 (9.48) | – | 116 (100) | 20 |
| Cataneo et al32 | 2019 | USA | 2004–2017 | R, single center | 176 | – | – | – | 79 (44.9) | – | 176 (100) | – |
| Dafnis33 | 2016 | Sweden | 1993–2012 | R, single center | 124 | 112/0/11/0/1 | 44 | 53 (42.7) | – | 115 (92.7) | 123 (99.2) | 11.2 |
| Die et al34 | 2020 | Spain | 1983–2015 | R, single center | 139 | 139 | – | 60 (43.2) | – | 85 (61.2) | 108 (77.7) | 12 * |
| Feinberg et al20 | 2020 | USA | 1986–2016 | R, single center | 3468 | 3300/168/0/0/0 | 39 | 1512 (43.6) | – | – | 3143 (90.7) | 7.9 |
| Hashimoto et al35 | 2013 | Japan | 2000–2012 | R, single center | 119 | 119 | 35/39 | 42 (38.2) n = 110 | 33 (30.0) | 67 (60.9) | – | 5.5 |
| Helavirta et al36 | 2016 | Finland | 1985–2009 | R, single center | 352 | 352 | 36 | 149 (42.3) | – | 69 (19.6) | 133 (37.8) | 5 |
| Ikeuchi et al37 | 2010 | Japan | 1983–2007 | R, single center | 944 | 944 | – | – | 1 (0.1) | 21 (2.2) | 686 (72.6) | – |
| Karjalainen et al23,38 | 2019 | Finland | 2005–2016 | R, single center | 510 | 510 | 39 | 198 (38.8) | 0 (0.0) | 52 (10.2) | 119 (23.3) | 6.9 |
| Karlbom et al39 | 2011 | Sweden | 1985–1996 | R, single center | 188 | 188 | 32 | 72 (38.3) | – | – | 154 (81.9) | 12.5 |
| Kayal et al40 | 2019 | USA | 2008–2017 | R, single center | 386 | 363/23 | 37 | 140 (46.6) | 281 (72.8) | 275 (71.2) | 311 (80.6) | 2 |
| Landerholm et al18 | 2017 | Sweden | 1964–2010 | R, population based | 1720 | 1720 | 36.8 | 643 (37.4) | – | – | – | 12.6 |
| Lee et al41 | 2019 | USA | 2000–2015 | R, single center | 212 | 212 | 36 | 87 (41.0) | 45 (21.2) | 212 (100) | 212 (100) | 4.7* |
| Leowardi et al42 | 2010 | Germany | 1988–1996 | R, single center | 294 | 294 | 33 | 133 (45.2) | – | 0 (0) | 294 (100) | 11.5 |
| Lightner et al19Farouk et al43 | 2017 | USA | 1981–2015 | R, single center | 1875 | 1875 | 34 | 855 (45.4) | – | – | 1855 (98.4) | – |
| Lorenzo et al44 | 2016 | Italy | 1985–2014 | R, single center | 185 | 185 | 33 | 61 (33.0) | – | 128 (69.1) | 128 (69.2) | 11.3 |
| Mark-Christensen et al22,45 | 2017 | Denmark | 1980–2013 | R, population based | 1991 | 1991 | 33 | 954 (47.8) | 165 (8.3) | – | 1849 (92.9) | 11.4 |
| McCombie et al46 | 2016 | New Zealand | 1984–2013 | R, population based | 136 | 104/4/15/12/1 | 39 | 61 (44.9) | – | – | – | 12 |
| Mege et al10 | 2016 | France | 2000–2015 | R, single center | 185 | 164/1/20/0/0 | 39/43 | 78 (42.2) | 185 (100) | 180 (97.3) | 185 (100) | 3 |
| Mennigen et al47 | 2011 | Germany | 1997–2009 | R, single center | 122 | 122 | 34/38 | 44 (36.1) | – | 71 (58.2) | 89 (73.0) | 3.3 |
| Rokke et al48 | 2011 | Norway | 1988–2002 | R, single center | 134 | 134 | 43 | 57 (42.5) | – | 134 (100) | 54 (43.9) | 11 |
| Sahami et al16 | 2016 | NL, Belgium, USA | 1990–2014 | R, multicenter | 621 | 545/59/17/0/0 | 38 | 270 (43.6) | 289 (46.5) | 601 (96.8) | 305 (49.1) | 3.3 |
| Sampietro et al49 | 2018 | Italy | 2007–2016 | R, single center | 150 | 143/3/4/0/0 | 43/51 | 58 (38.6) | 150 (100) | 143 (95.3) | 138 (92.0) | 5.1 |
| Tan et al50 | 2014 | Australië | 1999–2011 | R, single center | 142 | 142 | 43 | 60 (42.3) | – | 141 (99.3) | 142 (100) | 3 |
| Uchino et al24 | 2017 | Japan | 2005–2014 | R, multicenter | 2376 | 2376 | 40 | 963 (40.5) | – | 1078 (45.4) | 1664 (70.0) | 6.7 |
| Wasmuth et al51,52 | 2010 | Norway | 1984–2007 | R, single center | 315 | 287/7/5/11/5 | 32/36 | 119 (37.8) | – | 187 (59.4) | 256 (84.2) | 13.3 |
| Wibmer et al53 | 2010 | Germany | 1997–2008 | R, single center | 185 | 141/0/0/44/0 | 37 | 79 (42.7) | 66 (35.7) | 0 (0) | 163 (88.1) | 3.9* |
| Worley et al21 | 2017 | UK, Belgium, Denmark, NL, Spain | 1976–2017 | R, multicenter | 5083 | 3603/162/29/449/840 | 30–39 | 2230 (44.0) | – | – | 2554 (81.4) | – |
| Zaghiyan et al54 | 2016 | USA | 1997–2007 | R, single center | 334 | 237/97/0/0/0 | 38 | 148 (44.3) | – | – | 334 (100) | 5.8 |
| Bertucci Zoccali et al55 | 2019 | USA | 2000–2010 | R, single center | 411 | 411 | 36 | 171 (41.6) | 151 (36.7) | 256 (62.3) | 359 (87.3) | 5.2 |
Dashes indicate not specified.
*Mean follow-up.
CD indicates Crohn’s disease; FAP, familial adenomatous polyposis; IC, indeterminate colitis; IPAA, ileal pouch-anal anastomosis; NL, Netherlands; R, retrospective; UC, ulcerative colitis; UK, United Kingdom; USA, United States of America.