Table 1.
Study | Trial Design/Country/ Type of Patients |
Study Fluids |
Indication and Dose (Planned, Maximal and Cumulative) of HES | Endpoints | Definition of Renal Endpoint |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Septic patients | |||||
Perner, 2009–2011, published in 2012 (6S) [40] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–398 patients Ringer’s acetate–400 patients |
Indication: volumen expansion Planned: 33 mL/kg daily Daily maximal: 50 mL/kg (exceeded only in case of two patients) Cumulative: 44 mL/kg (IQR: 24–75 mL/kg) (~3168 mL/patients) |
|
|
Müller, 2015 [86] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–398 patients Ringer’s acetate–400 patients |
Indication: volumen expansion Planned: 33 mL/kg daily Daily maximal: 50 mL/kg) (exceeded only in case of two patients) Cumulative: 44 mL/kg (IQR: 24–75 mL/kg) (~3168 mL/patients) |
|
|
Dubin, 2010 [93] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–9 patients 0.9% saline–11 patients |
Indication: intravenous volume expansion to increase microvascular flow index (MFI) Planned: unknown Daily maximal: unknown Cumulative: unknown |
|
|
Guidet, 2012 (CRYSTMAS) [41] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–100 patients 0.9% saline–96 patients |
Indication: (initial) hemodynamic stabilization Planned: unknown Fluid intake prior randomization: 35.5 ± 25.3 mL/kg) Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 on the first day; 25 mL × kg−1 × d−1 from the second to the fourth day Cumulative: 1379 ± 886 mL, 2615 ± 1499 mL over four consecutive days |
|
|
Myburgh, 2012 (CHEST) [38,39] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–3315 patients 0.9% saline–3336 patients |
Indication: correction of hypovolemia Planned: unknown Daily maximal: unknown. Daily dose: 526 ± 425 mL (~6.6 ± 5.3 mL/kg) Cumulative: unknown |
|
|
Annane, 2013 (CRISTAL) [84] |
|
Crystalloid infusions–1443 patients (isotonic saline, hypertonic saline, buffered solutions) Colloid–1414 patients (hypooncotic (eg. gelatines, 4% or 5% of albumin), hyperoncotic (eg. dextrans, hydroxy-ethyl starches and 20% or 25% of albumin) |
Indication: fluid resuscitation Planned: unknown Daily maximal: 30 mL/kg Cumulative: 1500 mL (95% CI: 1000–2000 mL), (~21.4 mL/kg [14.3–28.6 mL/kg]) 973 patients (68.8%), duration 2 (95% CI: 1–2) days |
|
|
Cardiac surgery patients | |||||
Gallandat 2000 [50] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES in saline–30 patients 6% (200/0.5) HES–29 patients |
Indication: acute normovolemic hemodilution + priming the heart-lung machine + intra/postoperative fluid management Planned: 500 mL for hemodilution, 1000 mL for priming the heart-lung machine Daily maximal: 3000 mL (~36.1 mL/kg) Cumulative: intraoperatively: 1475 ± 100 mL (~17.8 mL/kg), postoperatively: 1150 ± 511 mL (~13.9 mL/kg), total: 2550 ± 561 mL (31.0 ± 7.4 mL/kg) in 130/0.4 HES group |
|
|
Van der Linden, 2005 [52] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–64 patients modified fluid gelatine–68 patients |
Indication: priming the heart-lung machine + postoperative fluid management Planned: not reported Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: 21.3 ± 8.3 mL/kg (~1683 ± 656 mL) intraoperatively, 27.5 ± 12.6 mL/kg (~2173 ± 995 mL) postoperatively, 48.9 ± 17.2 mL/kg (~3863 ± 1359 mL) total |
|
|
Ooi, 2009 [72] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–45 patients succinylated gelatine–45 patients |
Indication: priming the heart-lung machine + intra/postoperative fluid management Planned: not reported Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: intraoperatively: 1225.6 ± 158.3 mL (~17.5 mL/kg), first 24 h postoperatively: 716.7 ± 910.2 mL (~10.2 mL/kg), total: 1942.3 ± 1046.1 mL (27.7 mL/kg) in HES group |
|
|
Skhirtladze, 2014 [94] |
|
HA group: 5% albumin up to 50 mL × kg−1 × day−1–76 patients HES group: 6% HES 130/0.4 up to 50 mL × kg−1 × day−1–81 patients RL group: RL up to 50 mL × kg−1 × day−1–79 patients |
Indication: priming the heart-lung machine + intra/postoperative fluid management Planned: 1500 mL for priming, intraoperative dose was restricted to 33 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: intraoperatively: 2500 (IQR: 2250–2750) mL, postoperatively: 625 (IQR: 50–1000) mL, total: 3000 (IQR: 2750–3500) mL in HES group |
|
|
Joosten, 2016 [77] |
|
6% (130/0.4) maize HES–59 patients 6% (130/0.42) potato HES–59 patients |
Indication: priming the heart-lung machine + intra/postoperative fluid management Planned: 1000 mL for priming (~13 mL/kg), intraoperative dose in 250 mL boluses to maintain SVV <13% Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: intraoperatively: 1000 mL (IQR: 000–1250 mL) (~13 [IQR: 13–16 mL/kg]) in maize and 1000 mL (IQR: 1000–1200 mL) (~13 [IQR: 13–16 mL/kg]) in potato HES (NS); up to POD2: 1950 mL (IQR: 1250–2325 mL) (~25 [IQR: 16–29 mL/kg]) mL in maize HES and 2000 mL (IQR: 1500–2700 mL) (~27 [IQR: 20–66 mL/kg]) mL in potato HES (NS) |
|
|
Svendsen, 2018 [91] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–20 patients Ringer’s acetate–20 patients |
Indication: priming the heart-lung machine Planned: 1700 mL for priming Daily maximal: unknown Cumulative: unknown |
|
|
Duncan, 2020 [69] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–69 patients 5% human albumin–72 patients |
Indication: hypovolemia Planned: 250 or 500 mL boluses if hypovolemia detected by monitoring of cardiac index, HR, systolic blood pressure, vasopressor requirement and CVP/PCWP or in case of severe acute surgical haemorrhage Daily maximal: 35 mL × kg−1 × day−1 Cumulative: unknown |
|
|
Postoperative patients after abdominal surgery | |||||
Mahmood 2007 [63] |
|
6% 200/0.62 HES–21 patients 6% 130/0.4 HES–21 patients 4% gelatine–20 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during and after the surgery Planned: 3 mL/kg bolus of colloid followed by a maintenance rate of 2 mL × kg−1 × h−1 during surgery and increased to maintain a urine output greater than 0.5 mL × kg−1 × h−1. Further colloid administration was based on maintenance of MAP over 85 mmHg and CVP between 8 and 10 cmH2O Daily maximal: 3911 ± 1783 mL (~51 ± 23 mL/kg) in 130/0.4 HES group Cumulative: from 8 h before surgery to 24 h after the surgery: 3443 ± 1769 mL (~45 ± 23 mL/kg) in 200/0.62 HES group 3911 ± 1783 mL (~51 ± 23 mL/kg) in 130/0.4 HES group |
|
|
Godet, 2008 [70] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES in saline–29 patients 3% modified fluid gelatine–31 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during and after the surgery Planned: according to anesthesiologist’s judgement during surgery based on MAP, CVP, fluid balance and the need of catecholamines Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: Day 1: 1709 ± 836 mL (23.9 ± 11.9 mL/kg) Day 2: 1577 ± 714 mL (21.8 ± 9.5 mL/kg) Day 3: 1780 ± 752 mL (24.8 ± 10.5 mL/kg) Day 4: 1862 ± 1171 mL (25.4 ± 15.4 mL/kg) Day 5: 1874 ± 1308 mL (26.2 ± 17.7 mL/kg) Day 6: 1779 ± 1204 mL (24.0 ± 16.2 mL/kg) Total (day 1– day 6): 10 237 ± 4561 mL (139.7 ± 58.2 mL/kg) |
|
|
Mukhtar 2009 [64] |
|
6% 130/0.4 HES–20 patients 5% albumin–20 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during and after the surgery Planned: 250 mL bolus based on maintenance of CVP and/or PAOP between 5 and 7 cmH2O Daily maximal: 50 mL × kg−1 × d−1 during the intraoperative period and first 4 postoperative days Cumulative: intraoperatively: 3080 ± 417 mL, postoperatively: 6229 ± 1140 mL in 130/0.4 HES group |
|
|
Yang 2011 [53] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–30 patients 20% human-albumin–30 patients Ringer’s lactate–30 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during and after the surgery Planned: 1000 mL/d (~16 mL/kg) in POD1–3 and 500 mL/d (~8 mL/kg) on POD4–5 Daily maximal: unknown Cumulative: intraoperatively: 3484.6 ± 1072.5 mL (~56 ± 17 mL/kg), total: 10,235.0 ± 393.9 mL (~165 ± 6 mL/kg) in 130/0.4 HES group |
|
|
Demir, 2015 [92] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–18 patients 4% gelatine–18 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during the surgery Planned: according to hemodynamic data (SVV, CVP, MAP) Daily maximal: unknown Cumulative: 2.3 ± 0.8 L (~32 ± 11 mL/kg) in 130/0.4 HES group |
|
|
Ghodraty, 2017 [74] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–46 patients Ringer’s lactate–45 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during the surgery Planned: 2 mL × kg−1 × h−1 as a maintenance fluid plus fluid loss in 1:1 ratio Daily maximal: unknown Cumulative: 10.4 ± 4.1 mL/kg |
|
|
Joosten, 2018 [83] |
|
6% (130/0.4) waxy maize HES in balanced crystalloids–80 patients balanced crystalloids–80 patients |
Indication: maintenance infusion during the surgery Planned: EGDT (multiple 100-mL mini-fluid challenges) based on hemodynamic measurements (SVV; closed-loop system) Daily maximal: 33 mL/kg Cumulative: 900 mL (IQR: 400–1300 mL) (~13 mL/kg [IQR: 6–18 mL/kg]) intraoperatively. Only one patient (1%) reached the maximal dose |
|
|
Kammerer, 2018 [95] |
|
6% (130/0.4) HES–47 patients 5% human-albumin–53 patients |
Indication: replacement of blood loss in 1:1 ratio during the surgery, postoperative fluid management Planned: replacement of blood loss in 1:1 ratio during the surgery, postoperative fluid management Daily maximal: 30 mL/kg Cumulative: 2000 ± 969 mL (~27 ± 13 mL/kg) |
|
|
Werner, 2018 [89] |
|
balanced 10% HES 130/0.42–20 patients balanced 6% HES 130/0.42–22 patients balanced crystalloid–21 patients |
Indication: intraoperative fluid management Planned: EGDT (multiple 100-mL mini-fluid challenges) based on hemodynamic measurements (SVV) Daily maximal: 30 mL/kg for 10% HES; 50 mL/kg for 6% HES Cumulative: 2250 (IQR: 1750–3000 mL); 33.3 mL/kg (IQR: 28.2–46.2 mL/kg for 6% HES) |
|
|
Kabon, 2019 [78] |
|
6% HES 130/0.4 in 0.9% saline–523 patients Ringer’s lactate–534 patients |
Indication: intraoperative volume replacement Planned: 250 mL over 5 min based on esophageal Doppler measurements (stroke volume, corrected aortic flow time) Daily maximal: 1500 mL Cumulative: 1 (IQR: 0.5–1.5) liter |
|
|
Futier, 2020 (FLASH) [73] |
|
6% HES 130/0.4 in 0.9% saline–389 patients 0.9% saline–386 patients |
Indication: intraoperative volume replacement Planned: 250 mL over 5 min to maximize stroke volume; in case of less than a 10% increase in stroke volume, the study fluid administration was stopped Daily maximal: 30 mL × kg−1 × d−1 (100 patients [10.5%] of patients received more) Cumulative: intraoperatively: 1000 mL (IQR: 750–1500 mL) (~12 mL/kg [IQR: 9–18 mL/kg]); postoperatively: 500 mL (IQR: 500–750 mL) (~6 mL/kg [IQR: 6–9 mL/kg]); POD2: 500 mL (IQR: 250–1000 mL) (~6 mL/kg [IQR: 3–14 mL/kg]); total: 33.4 ± 3.4 mL/kg in HES group (~2739 ± 279 mL) |
|
|
Others | |||||
Neff 2003 [65] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–16 patients 6% (200/0.5) HES + 5% albumin–15 patients |
Indication: volume replacement in the ICU for up to 28 days Planned: repetitive large doses Daily maximal: 70 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: 2297 ± 610 mL (~30 ± 8 mL/kg) daily; total: 19 ± 16 L (~246 ± 208 mL/kg) (max: 66 L!) 20 mL × kg−1 × day−1: n = 16, mean duration: 4.8 days 30 mL × kg−1 × day−1: n = 16, mean duration: 3.9 days 40 mL × kg−1 × day−1: n = 13, mean duration: 3.1 days 50 mL × kg−1 × day−1: n = 12, mean duration: 2.0 days 60 mL × kg−1 × day−1: n = 10, mean duration: 1.8 days 70 mL × kg−1 × day−1: n = 3, mean duration: 1.0 day |
|
|
James, 2011 (FIRST) [58] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–36 patients with penetrating, 20 patients with blunt trauma 0.9% saline–31 patients with penetrating, 22 patients with blunt trauma |
Indication: fluid resuscitation Planned: undetermined Daily maximal: 33 mL × kg−1 × d−1 Cumulative: Penetrating trauma: 5093 ± 2733 mL (~70 ± 38 mL/kg); Blunt trauma: 6113 ± 1919 mL (~79 ± 25 mL/kg) |
|
|
Tyagi 2019 [80] |
|
6% (130/0.42) HES–19 patients Ringer’s lactate–19 patients |
Indication: intraoperative fluid replacement Planned: If SVV was >10% in supine or lateral position, or >14% in prone position, a bolus of 100 mL of the intervention fluid was infused over 2–4 min Daily maximal: not applicable Cumulative: 689 ± 394 mL (~12 ± 7 mL/kg) |
|
|
Abbreviations: AKI: Acute Kidney Injury; AKIN: Acute Kidney Injury Network; ARF: Acute Renal Failure; BUN: Blood Urea Nitrogen; CI: Confidential Interval; CPB: Cardiopulmonary Bypass; CrCl: Creatinine Clearance; CVP: Central Venous Pressure; EGDT: Early Goal Directed Therapy; eGFR: estimated Glomerular Filtration Rate; GCS: Glasgow Coma Scale; HA: Human Albumin; HES: Hydroxyethyl Starch; ICU: Intensive Care Unit; IgG: Immunglobulin G; IQR: Interquartile Range; KDIGO: Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcome; MAP: Mean Arterial Pressure; MDRD: Modification of Diet in Renal Disease; MELD: Model of End-Stage Liver Disease; NAG: β-N-Acetyl-β-D-Glucosaminidase; NGAL: Neutrophil Gelatinase-Associated Lipocalin; PAOP: Pulmonary Arterial Occlusion Pressure; POD: Postoperative Day; POMS: Profile of Mood States; RIFLE: Risk, Injury, Failure, Loss, End-stage renal disease criteria for acute kidney injury; RL: Ringer’s Lactate; RRT: Renal Replacement Therapy; SIRS: Systemic Inflammatory Response Syndrome; SOFA: Sepsis-related Organ Failure Assessment; SVV: Stroke Volume Variation.