Skip to main content
. 2023 May 3;20(4):932–954. doi: 10.1007/s13311-023-01379-z

Table 4.

Selected studies in aSyn-SAA and skin immunofluorescence/immunohistochemistry

Study Assay Sample Subjects PD duration Results
aSyn-SAA
Fairfoul et al. [17] 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (Stratech) BH and CSF

Discovery: DLB:29

PD:2

AD:30

PSP:2

CBS:3

ILBD:13

HC: 20

Validation: PD:20

HC:15

RBD: 3

Not provided

DLB v HC: Sns 0.92, Spc: 1.00

PD v HC: Sns 0.95, Spc: 1.00

3/3 RBD patients + aSyn-SAA

Shahnawaz et al. [19] 1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist (local) BH and CSF

PD: 76

OND: 65

NDG: 18

AD: 14

Not provided

PD v disease controls: Sns: 0.89 Spc: 0.94

Time to reach 50% maximum aggregation inversely correlated with HY stage

Groveman et al. [20] 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn K23Q + 6hist (local) BH and CSF

PD: 12

DLB: 17

Non-aSyn: 31

2.9y PD and DLB v non-aSyn: Sns: 0.93, Spc: 1.00
Bargar et al. [174] 1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (rPeptide) BH, CSF, Saliva, Skin, colon

PD: 88

DLB: 58

Controls: 68

Not Provided

CSF: PD and DLB v controls: Sns 0.98, Spc 1.00

Sns and Spc not analyzed for other tissues

Iranzo et al. [169] 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (Sigma) CSF

RBD: 52

HC: 40

NA

RBD v HC: Sns 0.90 Spc 0.90

During 7y follow up 32 photoconverted to PD or DLB (31/32 + aSyn SAA)

Siderowf et al. [197] 0.3 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist CSF

PD: 545

HC: 163

SWEDD: 54

Sporadic PD 0.6y ± 0.5

LRRK2 PD 3.0y ± 2.1

GBA PD

3.5y ± 2.4

All PD cases v HC: Sns 0.88 Spc: 0.96

Sporadic PD v HC: Sns: 0.93, Spc: 0.96

LRRK2 PD v HC: Sns: 0.68, Spc: 0.96

GBA PD v HC: Sns: 0.96, Spc 0.96

Rossi et al. [168] 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT CSF

Clinical

RBD: 18

PAF: 28

PD: 71

DLB: 34

OND: 135

Path-validated

LB + : 21

LB-: 101

Clinical PD:

56.8 m ± 45.8

Neuropathologically validated cases with aSyn

Sns: 0.95 Spc: 0.98

Clinical diagnoses aSyn v OND: Sns: 0.95, Spc 0.98

18/18 RBD + aSyn SAA, 26/28 PAF + aSyn-SAA

Russo et al. [167]

AbbVie RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (local),

Caughey RT-QuIC:

0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn K23Q

PMCA:

0.3 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist

CSF

PD: 30

HC: 30

SWEDD: 20

PPMI: 6.7 m ± 6.5

SAA: 9.0 m ± 8.4

PD v HC at baseline:

AbbVie: Sns:0.89, Spc: 1.00

Caughey: Sns: 0.86, Spc: 0.97

Amprion: Sns: 0.96, Spc: 0.97

PD v HC Year 3

AbbVie: Sns: 0.93, Spc: 0.93

Caughey: 0.89, Spc: 0.97

Amprion: 0.96, Spc: 0.93

Poggiolini et al. [170] 1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT CSF

PD: 74

MSA: 24

RBD: 45

HC: 55

PD 2.1y ± 1.4y

PD v HC: Sns: 0.89 Spc 0.96

No major correlations of kinetic parameters and clinical features in PD

MSA v HC: Sns: 0.75 Spc 0.96 (longer T50, lower Fmax)

Some correlations of kinetic parametiers and clinical features in MSA

RBD v HC: Sns: 0.64 Spc 0.96

14/45 phenoconverted in the 0.2–7.9 y of followup. 9/14 + aSyn SAA at baseline

Kang et al. [166]

RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (Sigma)

PMCA: 0.3 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist

CSF

PD: 105

HC: 79

8 (4–17)

RT-QuIC: PD v HC Sns: 0.95 Spc: 0.96

PMCA: PD v HC Sns 0.90 Spc: 0.82

Kuzkina et al. [172]

RT-QuIC

Cleveland

aSyn rec WT (rPeptide)

RT-QuIC

Wurzburg

5 mg/ml

aSyn rec WT (in house)

Skin: 5 mm. C7, T12, thigh, lower leg

PD: 34

HC: 30

11.7y ± 6.9

Sns: 0.91, Spc 0.87

Κ = 0.86 for patient results between labs

Manne et al. [21]

0.1 mg/ml

aSyn rec WT

Skin

Frozen

PD: 25

HC: 25

Formalin fixed

PD: 12

HC: 12

Not described

Frozen

Sns 0.96 Spc 0.96

Fixed

Sns: 0.75 Spc: 0.83

De Luca et al. [177] 5 mg/ml aSyn rec WT Olfactory Mucosa

PD: 18

MSA: 11

OND: 18

10.1y ± 5.1

PD Sns: 0.56

MSA Sns: 0.82

Spc: 0.83

Skin IF/IHC
Donadio et al. [138]

IF Zamboni

pSer129 aSyn/PGP

Cryosectoining

CSF and skin

RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (rPeptide)

3 mm C7, thigh, leg

CSF

IF reproducibility

PD: 4

MSA: 4

DLB: 1

OND: 12

IF v RT-QuIC

PD: 17

DLB: 5

MSA: 8

PAF: 3

OND: 38

HC: 24

Not available

aSyn v non aSyn

Skin IF: Sns: 0.90 Spc: 1.00

CSF RT-QuIC: Sns 0.78 Spc 1.00

Skin RT-QuIC: Sns 0.86 Spc 0.80

Gibbons et al. [15]

IF: Zamboni, pSer129 aSyn/PGP

Cryosectioning

3 mm distal leg, proximal/distal thigh, forearm

PD: 28

HC: 23

PD nAF 4.3y ± 5.1

PD AF 8.6y ± 7.3

Sns 0.95 Spc 0.91
Wang et al. [133]

IF: Zamboni, pSer129 aSyn/PGP

Cryosectioning

3 mm distal leg or distal/proximal thigh

PD: 29

HC: 21

5.5y ± 5.1

50 µm sections: Sns 1.00,

20 µm sections: Sns: .90,

10um sections: Sns:73

Spc: 1.00

Donadio et al. [124]

IF: Zamboni

pSer129 aSyn/PGP Cryosectioning

3 mm C7 2 × or C7 and T12 PD: 28

15 patients unilateral symptoms 3y ± 2

13 patients bilateral symptoms

10y ± 6

Sns 1.00 from C7

Sns 0.62 from T12 site

No differences in laterality in spite of lateralized motor symptoms

Donadio et al. [132]

IF: Zamboni

pSer129 aSyn, PGP

Cryosectioning

3 mm C8, thigh, distal leg

PD: 21

Other Parkinsonism: 20

HC: 30

PD: 13y ± 6 Sns 1.00 Spc 1.00
Doppler et al. [126]

IF: PFA 4%

pSer129 aSyn PGP Cryosectioning

5 mm

Proximal and distal leg, T12, C7

PD: 25

RBD: 18

HC: 20

PD Sns: 0.80, RBD Sns: 0.56 Spc:1.00
Doppler et al. [136]

IF: PFA 4%

pSer129 aSyn, PGP. Cryosectioning

5 mm, proximal and distal leg, T12, finger

PD: 31

HC 35

9.0y (range 0.3–27) PD v HC Sns 0.52 Spc: 1.00
Al-Qassabi et al. [137] IF: FFPE pSer129 aSyn/PGP 3-5 mm Leg or C8

PD: 20

RBD: 28

Other parkinsonism: 10

HC: 21

PD 8.4y ± 4.4 PD Sns 0.70, RBD Sns: 0.82, Other parkinsonism 0.20. Spc 1.00
Chahine et al. [116] IHC: FFPE aSyn. Proteinase K 3 mm C7-8, mid thigh

PD: 58

HC: 21

4.8y ± 4.6 Sns 0.24 Spc 1.00

For aSyn-SAA studies, the type of aSyn used for reactions is detailed and for skin immunofluoresence/Immunohistochemistry, basic aspects of these assays are reported along with biopsy sites and type

RT-QuIC real-time quaking induced conversion, PMCA protein misfolding cyclic amplification, rec aSyn recombinant alpha-synuclein, WT wild type, 6hist histidine tag, BH brain homogenate, CSF cerebrospinal fluid, PD Parkinson’s disease, DLB dementia with Lewy bodies, AD Alzheimer’s disease, PSP progressive supranuclear palsy, CBS cortico basal syndrome, HC healthy controls, OND other neurological disorders, NDG other neurodegenerative diseases, MSA multiple systems atrophy, Sns sensitivity, Spc specificity, HY Hoehn and Yahr stage, RBD REM sleep behavior disorder, PAF pure autonomic failure, IF immunofluorences, IHC immunohistochemistry, PFA paraformaldehyde, FFPE formalin fixed paraffin embedded, PGP neuron specific protein gene product