Table 4.
Study | Assay | Sample | Subjects | PD duration | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
aSyn-SAA | |||||
Fairfoul et al. [17] | 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (Stratech) | BH and CSF |
Discovery: DLB:29 PD:2 AD:30 PSP:2 CBS:3 ILBD:13 HC: 20 Validation: PD:20 HC:15 RBD: 3 |
Not provided |
DLB v HC: Sns 0.92, Spc: 1.00 PD v HC: Sns 0.95, Spc: 1.00 3/3 RBD patients + aSyn-SAA |
Shahnawaz et al. [19] | 1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist (local) | BH and CSF |
PD: 76 OND: 65 NDG: 18 AD: 14 |
Not provided |
PD v disease controls: Sns: 0.89 Spc: 0.94 Time to reach 50% maximum aggregation inversely correlated with HY stage |
Groveman et al. [20] | 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn K23Q + 6hist (local) | BH and CSF |
PD: 12 DLB: 17 Non-aSyn: 31 |
2.9y | PD and DLB v non-aSyn: Sns: 0.93, Spc: 1.00 |
Bargar et al. [174] | 1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (rPeptide) | BH, CSF, Saliva, Skin, colon |
PD: 88 DLB: 58 Controls: 68 |
Not Provided |
CSF: PD and DLB v controls: Sns 0.98, Spc 1.00 Sns and Spc not analyzed for other tissues |
Iranzo et al. [169] | 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (Sigma) | CSF |
RBD: 52 HC: 40 |
NA |
RBD v HC: Sns 0.90 Spc 0.90 During 7y follow up 32 photoconverted to PD or DLB (31/32 + aSyn SAA) |
Siderowf et al. [197] | 0.3 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist | CSF |
PD: 545 HC: 163 SWEDD: 54 |
Sporadic PD 0.6y ± 0.5 LRRK2 PD 3.0y ± 2.1 GBA PD 3.5y ± 2.4 |
All PD cases v HC: Sns 0.88 Spc: 0.96 Sporadic PD v HC: Sns: 0.93, Spc: 0.96 LRRK2 PD v HC: Sns: 0.68, Spc: 0.96 GBA PD v HC: Sns: 0.96, Spc 0.96 |
Rossi et al. [168] | 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT | CSF |
Clinical RBD: 18 PAF: 28 PD: 71 DLB: 34 OND: 135 Path-validated LB + : 21 LB-: 101 |
Clinical PD: 56.8 m ± 45.8 |
Neuropathologically validated cases with aSyn Sns: 0.95 Spc: 0.98 Clinical diagnoses aSyn v OND: Sns: 0.95, Spc 0.98 18/18 RBD + aSyn SAA, 26/28 PAF + aSyn-SAA |
Russo et al. [167] |
AbbVie RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (local), Caughey RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn K23Q PMCA: 0.3 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist |
CSF |
PD: 30 HC: 30 SWEDD: 20 |
PPMI: 6.7 m ± 6.5 SAA: 9.0 m ± 8.4 |
PD v HC at baseline: AbbVie: Sns:0.89, Spc: 1.00 Caughey: Sns: 0.86, Spc: 0.97 Amprion: Sns: 0.96, Spc: 0.97 PD v HC Year 3 AbbVie: Sns: 0.93, Spc: 0.93 Caughey: 0.89, Spc: 0.97 Amprion: 0.96, Spc: 0.93 |
Poggiolini et al. [170] | 1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT | CSF |
PD: 74 MSA: 24 RBD: 45 HC: 55 |
PD 2.1y ± 1.4y |
PD v HC: Sns: 0.89 Spc 0.96 No major correlations of kinetic parameters and clinical features in PD MSA v HC: Sns: 0.75 Spc 0.96 (longer T50, lower Fmax) Some correlations of kinetic parametiers and clinical features in MSA RBD v HC: Sns: 0.64 Spc 0.96 14/45 phenoconverted in the 0.2–7.9 y of followup. 9/14 + aSyn SAA at baseline |
Kang et al. [166] |
RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (Sigma) PMCA: 0.3 mg/ml rec aSyn WT + 6hist |
CSF |
PD: 105 HC: 79 |
8 (4–17) |
RT-QuIC: PD v HC Sns: 0.95 Spc: 0.96 PMCA: PD v HC Sns 0.90 Spc: 0.82 |
Kuzkina et al. [172] |
RT-QuIC Cleveland aSyn rec WT (rPeptide) RT-QuIC Wurzburg 5 mg/ml aSyn rec WT (in house) |
Skin: 5 mm. C7, T12, thigh, lower leg |
PD: 34 HC: 30 |
11.7y ± 6.9 |
Sns: 0.91, Spc 0.87 Κ = 0.86 for patient results between labs |
Manne et al. [21] |
0.1 mg/ml aSyn rec WT |
Skin |
Frozen PD: 25 HC: 25 Formalin fixed PD: 12 HC: 12 |
Not described |
Frozen Sns 0.96 Spc 0.96 Fixed Sns: 0.75 Spc: 0.83 |
De Luca et al. [177] | 5 mg/ml aSyn rec WT | Olfactory Mucosa |
PD: 18 MSA: 11 OND: 18 |
10.1y ± 5.1 |
PD Sns: 0.56 MSA Sns: 0.82 Spc: 0.83 |
Skin IF/IHC | |||||
Donadio et al. [138] |
IF Zamboni pSer129 aSyn/PGP Cryosectoining CSF and skin RT-QuIC: 0.1 mg/ml rec aSyn WT (rPeptide) |
3 mm C7, thigh, leg CSF |
IF reproducibility PD: 4 MSA: 4 DLB: 1 OND: 12 IF v RT-QuIC PD: 17 DLB: 5 MSA: 8 PAF: 3 OND: 38 HC: 24 |
Not available |
aSyn v non aSyn Skin IF: Sns: 0.90 Spc: 1.00 CSF RT-QuIC: Sns 0.78 Spc 1.00 Skin RT-QuIC: Sns 0.86 Spc 0.80 |
Gibbons et al. [15] |
IF: Zamboni, pSer129 aSyn/PGP Cryosectioning |
3 mm distal leg, proximal/distal thigh, forearm |
PD: 28 HC: 23 |
PD nAF 4.3y ± 5.1 PD AF 8.6y ± 7.3 |
Sns 0.95 Spc 0.91 |
Wang et al. [133] |
IF: Zamboni, pSer129 aSyn/PGP Cryosectioning |
3 mm distal leg or distal/proximal thigh |
PD: 29 HC: 21 |
5.5y ± 5.1 |
50 µm sections: Sns 1.00, 20 µm sections: Sns: .90, 10um sections: Sns:73 Spc: 1.00 |
Donadio et al. [124] |
IF: Zamboni pSer129 aSyn/PGP Cryosectioning |
3 mm C7 2 × or C7 and T12 | PD: 28 |
15 patients unilateral symptoms 3y ± 2 13 patients bilateral symptoms 10y ± 6 |
Sns 1.00 from C7 Sns 0.62 from T12 site No differences in laterality in spite of lateralized motor symptoms |
Donadio et al. [132] |
IF: Zamboni pSer129 aSyn, PGP Cryosectioning |
3 mm C8, thigh, distal leg |
PD: 21 Other Parkinsonism: 20 HC: 30 |
PD: 13y ± 6 | Sns 1.00 Spc 1.00 |
Doppler et al. [126] |
IF: PFA 4% pSer129 aSyn PGP Cryosectioning |
5 mm Proximal and distal leg, T12, C7 |
PD: 25 RBD: 18 HC: 20 |
PD Sns: 0.80, RBD Sns: 0.56 Spc:1.00 | |
Doppler et al. [136] |
IF: PFA 4% pSer129 aSyn, PGP. Cryosectioning |
5 mm, proximal and distal leg, T12, finger |
PD: 31 HC 35 |
9.0y (range 0.3–27) | PD v HC Sns 0.52 Spc: 1.00 |
Al-Qassabi et al. [137] | IF: FFPE pSer129 aSyn/PGP | 3-5 mm Leg or C8 |
PD: 20 RBD: 28 Other parkinsonism: 10 HC: 21 |
PD 8.4y ± 4.4 | PD Sns 0.70, RBD Sns: 0.82, Other parkinsonism 0.20. Spc 1.00 |
Chahine et al. [116] | IHC: FFPE aSyn. Proteinase K | 3 mm C7-8, mid thigh |
PD: 58 HC: 21 |
4.8y ± 4.6 | Sns 0.24 Spc 1.00 |
For aSyn-SAA studies, the type of aSyn used for reactions is detailed and for skin immunofluoresence/Immunohistochemistry, basic aspects of these assays are reported along with biopsy sites and type
RT-QuIC real-time quaking induced conversion, PMCA protein misfolding cyclic amplification, rec aSyn recombinant alpha-synuclein, WT wild type, 6hist histidine tag, BH brain homogenate, CSF cerebrospinal fluid, PD Parkinson’s disease, DLB dementia with Lewy bodies, AD Alzheimer’s disease, PSP progressive supranuclear palsy, CBS cortico basal syndrome, HC healthy controls, OND other neurological disorders, NDG other neurodegenerative diseases, MSA multiple systems atrophy, Sns sensitivity, Spc specificity, HY Hoehn and Yahr stage, RBD REM sleep behavior disorder, PAF pure autonomic failure, IF immunofluorences, IHC immunohistochemistry, PFA paraformaldehyde, FFPE formalin fixed paraffin embedded, PGP neuron specific protein gene product