Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 30;2023(8):CD009365. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009365.pub2

Jang 2015.

Study characteristics
Methods Study design: RCT
Recruitment period: not reported
Recruitment mode: an orthopaedist had diagnosed people with acute LBP
Statistical analysis: a paired t‐test was carried out to examine changes according to the intervention, and an independent t‐test was used to compare the 2 groups
Sample size calculation: not reported
Participants Sample size: total: 30; EG1: 15; EG2: 15
Setting: not reported
Country: Republic of Korea
Baseline characteristics
  • Age in years, mean (SD): not reported, participants were in their 20s

  • Sex, number (%) women: EG1: 15 (100%); EG2: 15 (100%)


Duration LBP: ≤ 3 weeks, otherwise not specified
Inclusion criteria
  • Acute LBP diagnosed by orthopaedist


Exclusion criteria
  • Abnormalities other than LBP

Interventions EG1: Tai chi
  • Description: each of the sessions was composed of warming‐up exercises for 10 minutes, primary exercises for 40 minutes, and cooling‐down exercises for 10 minutes. A series of motions including yamabunjong, bongrian, baekhakyangsi, suhuibipa, nuseulyobo, jesusangse, and yeobongsapei were conducted in a flow mode for 20 minutes. The motions were carried out twice.

  • Materials/equipment: not reported

  • Non‐exercise component: not reported

  • Frequency and duration: 3 times per week, 1 hour each time, for a total of 8 weeks

  • Delivery: not reported

  • Provider: not reported


EG2
  • Description: repetitively performing lower limb, trunk, and upper limb exercises sequentially

  • Materials/equipment: not reported

  • Non‐exercise component: not reported

  • Frequency and duration: 3 times per week, 1 hour each time, for a total of 8 weeks

  • Delivery: not reported

  • Provider: not reported

Outcomes Note: outcomes were not designated as major or minor outcomes.
Pain: VAS (0–10; converted to a 0–100 scale)
  • Baseline, mean (SD): EG1: 36 (7); EG2: 36 (4)

  • Post‐treatment, mean (SD): EG1: 21 (6); EG2: 25 (6)


Others: muscle activity, balance
Adverse events: not reported
Notes Authors' results and conclusions: according to the results of this study, Tai Chi is considered an appropriate exercise program to reduce acute LBP in females in their 20s. It is effective in decreasing pain.
Review authors' note: only a minimal difference was detected that was not clinically relevant
Funding: no funding sources reported
Declaration of interest: no official disclosure regarding potential conflicts of interest
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Unclear risk Equally and randomly divided, randomisation not described.
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Unclear risk Not described.
Blinding
All outcomes ‐ Participants High risk No mention of any attempts to blind participants to the other intervention or their perceptions of the potential effectiveness of the different interventions.
Blinding
All outcomes ‐ Healthcare providers High risk No mention of any attempts to blind care providers to the other group.
Blinding
All outcomes ‐ outcome assessors High risk The outcome measures were self‐reported and participants were unblinded.
Influence of co‐interventions Unclear risk Study did not mention if co‐interventions were allowed, or similar in both groups.
Group similarity at baseline Low risk Baseline pain scores similar, and all participants were women in their 20s.
Compliance Unclear risk Not reported.
Timing of outcome assessments Low risk Pre‐and post‐treatment.
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias)
Dropouts – all outcomes Unclear risk No data provided, only group means of outcomes reported.
Intention‐to‐treat‐analysis Unclear risk Not reported, an independent t‐test was used to compare the 2 groups.
Selective reporting (reporting bias) High risk Function not reported; no published protocol available.
Other bias Unclear risk No funding sources reported. No official disclosure regarding potential conflicts of interest.