Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 22;11(8):23259671231182978. doi: 10.1177/23259671231182978

Table 3.

Inter- and Intraobserver Reliabilities of the Medial Meniscal Extrusion Measurements a

Intraobserver
Meniscal State Observer 1 Observer 2 Observer 3 Interobserver b
Intact
 0° of flexion 0.969 (0.914-0.992) 0.881 (0.705-0.965) 0.945 (0.853-0.985) 0.896 (0.732-0.971)
 30° of flexion 0.910 (0.766-0.975) 0.935 (0.828-0.982) 0.887 (0.713-0.968) 0.817 (0.549-0.947)
 60° of flexion 0.877 (0.693-0.965) 0.897 (0.741-0.971) 0.842 (0.626-0.953) 0.872 (0.686-0.963)
 90° of flexion 0.900 (0.741-0.972) 0.948 (0.861-0.986) 0.926 (0.802-0.979) 0.718 (0.394-0.912)
Segmental medial defect
 0° of flexion 0.917 (0.787-0.977) 0.847 (0.622-0.955) 0.952 (0.868-0.987) 0.874 (0.655-0.965)
 30° of flexion 0.983 (0.953-0.995) 0.980 (0.944-0.995) 0.953 (0.873-0.987) 0.919 (0.693-0.980)
 60° of flexion 0.939 (0.838-0.983) 0.935 (0.823-0.982) 0.937 (0.834-0.982) 0.939 (0.837-0.983)
 90° of flexion 0.925 (0.801-0.979) 0.923 (0.799-0.978) 0.959 (0.883-0.989) 0.618 (0.269-0.871)
Inside-out
 0° of flexion 0.859 (0.650-0.959) 0.778 (0.507-0.932) 0.882 (0.705-0.966) 0.564 (0.195-0.848)
 30° of flexion 0.867 (0.670-0.961) 0.813 (0.564-0.944) 0.929 (0.805-0.980) 0.582 (0.125-0.866)
 60° of flexion 0.704 (0.377-0.906) 0.749 (0.436-0.923) 0.788 (0.511-0.936) 0.589 (0.114-0.871)
 90° of flexion 0.772 (0.496-0.930) 0.895 (0.733-0.970) 0.830 (0.598-0.950) 0.570 (0.095-0.863)
Anchor + inside-out
 0° of flexion 0.869 (0.672-0.962) 0.809 (0.555-0.943) 0.861 (0.658-0.960) 0.780 (0.500-0.933)
 30° of flexion 0.903 (0.751-0.972) 0.900 (0.746-0.971) 0.903 (0.751-0.973) 0.772 (0.406-0.934)
 60° of flexion 0.851 (0.640-0.956) 0.852 (0.645-0.957) 0.865 (0.673-0.961) 0.647 (0.214-0.890)
 90° of flexion 0.925 (0.805-0.979) 0.757 (0.453-0.926) 0.809 (0.556-0.943) 0.602 (0.214-0.867)

a Data are reported as intraclass correlation coefficient (95% CI).

b Interobserver reliability was assessed from the measurements between the 3 observers.