Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 25;35:102383. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2023.102383

Table 2.

Summary characteristics of the included studies assessing bio-aerosols.

Author(s) Country Number of participants Type of study Type of aerosol mitigation intervention Method of aerosol assessment Type of microorganism
Al-Amad et al 2017 United Arab Emirates 52 RCT Rubber dam Bacterial culture Bacterial
Ashokkumar et al 2023 India 45 RCT Mouth rinses (CHX and herbal formulation) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Das et al 2022 India 80

RCT Mouth rinses (no rinse group, water, 0.2% Chlorhexidine gluconate, herbal mouthwash) bacterial culture Bacterial
Desarda et al 2014 India 80 RCT HVE Bacterial culture Bacterial
Devker et al 2012 India 90 CCT HVE and mouth rinses (bis-biguanide) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Feres et al 2010 Brazil 60 RCT Mouth rinses (0.05 percent cetylpyridinium chloride, 0.12 percent chlorhexidine, water, no rinsing) bacterial culture Bacterial
Fine et al 1992 America 18 RCT Mouth rinses (antiseptic mouthwash, 5% hydroalcohol control rinse) bacterial culture Bacterial
Fine et al 1993 America 18 RCT Mouth rinses Bacterial culture Bacterial
Gupta et al 2014 India 24 RCT Mouth rinses (0.2% CHX gluconate, herbal mouthwash and water) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Hallier et al 2010 BRITISH 2 RCT Air cleaning system Bacterial culture Bacterial
Holloman et al 2015 America 50 RCT HVE (Isolite Systems and SE) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Jawade et al 2016 India 30 RCT Different ultrasonic liquid (distilled water, 2% povidone iodine and 0.12% CHX) Bacterial culture Bacterial
King et al 1997 America 12 CCT HEPA filter Bacterial culture Bacterial
Logothetis et al 1995 America 18 RCT Mouth rinses (chlorhexidine, antiseptic mouthwash, water) bacterial culture Bacterial
Mamajiwala et al 2018 India 60 RCT Irrigant through DUWL (chlorhexidine (CHX), cinnamon (CIN)) bacterial culture Bacterial
Muzzin et al 1999 30 RCT aerosol reduction device bacterial culture Bacterial
Nayak et al 2020 India 30 RCT Mouth rinses (0.2% CHX gluconate, Befresh™ herbal mouthwash and water) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Nisha et al 2021 India 90 RCT Mouth rinses (0.12% CHX, 0.75% BA and water) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Nisha et al 2022 India 90 RCT Mouth rinses (0.12% chlorhexidine, 1.5% hydrogen peroxide, distilled water) bacterial culture Bacterial
Paul et al 2020 India 60 RCT Mouth rinses (94.5% aloe vera to 0.2% CHX gluconate and 1% povidone–iodine) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Prasanth et al 2010 India N/A CCT HVE with sterile water, distilled water, 0.5% sodium hypochlorite Bacterial culture Bacterial
Reddy et al 2012 India 30 RCT Mouth rinses (sterile water, non-tempered chlorhexidine, tempered chlorhexidine) bacterial culture Bacterial
Retamal-Valdes et al 2017 Brazil 60 RCT Mouth rinses (cetylpyridinium chloride, zinc lactate and sodium fluoride, water, 0.12% CHX digluconate) Bacterial culture and checkerboard DNA–DNA hybridization Bacterial
Santa et al 2022 Brazil N/A CCT Individual biosafety capsule in dentistry Bacterial culture Bacterial and virus
Santos et al 2014 Brazil 23 RCT Mouth rinses (distilled water, 0.12% chlorhexidine) bacterial culture Bacterial
Sethi et al 2019 India 60 RCT Ultrasonic coolant (distilled water, chlorhexidine, cinnamon extract) bacterial culture Bacterial
Shetty et al 2013 India 60 CCT Mouth rinses (CHX digluconate, tea tree oil or distilled water) Bacterial culture Bacterial
Takenaka et al 2022 Japan 10 RCT HVE and mouth rinses Bacterial culture Bacterial
Toroğlu et al 2001 Turkey N/A CCT Mouth rinsed (CHX) Bacterial culture Bacterial

BA: boric acid; CCT: controlled clinical trials; CHX: chlorhexidine; EOSD: extra-oral suction device; HEPA: high-efficiency particulate air; HSS: high-speed suction; HVE: high-volume evacuators; N/A: not applicable; RCT: randomized controlled trials; SE: saliva ejector.