Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 14;15(8):4530–4543. doi: 10.21037/jtd-23-325

Table 2. Search criteria.

Exclusion criteria Inclusion criteria
Manuscript characteristics • Interventional studies
• studies not in English language
• Studies not published by a peer-reviewed scientific journal, conference abstracts and proceedings, unpublished data, preprints, government publications, scientific or case reports, dissertations, and theses, review articles and follow-up studies
• Guidelines, statements, and comments
• No measurement of the SOP
• No reliable and scientifically valid methods of sleep measurements
• Original and peer reviewed research articles
• Observational, descriptive, longitudinal, retrospective, cross-sectional, cohort, studies that investigate SOP
• Methodologies and samples were well-described (e.g., scoring criteria, modality and measurement of the exact point of SO)
Population’s characteristics • Participants under 18, infants, paediatric • Healthy controls >18 years of age
• Animal studies • Individuals with sleep disorders
• Diagnoses made in accordance with DSM-IV, clinical review and laboratory examinations to rule out other medical and psychiatric disorders [Spitzer et al., 1992 (42)]
Study design RCT; CCT Appropriate and clinically valid designs to measure the SOP

SO, sleep-onset; SOP, sleep-onset period; RCT, randomized controlled trial; CCT, controlled clinical trial.