Table 2.

Mean (standard deviation) of belief in the theory in percentages, for every number of significant results, k, and for the different compositions of statistical results

	Participants’ mean belief in Study 1	Participants’ mean belief per composition in Study 1		Participants’ mean belief in Study 2	Participants’ mean belief per composition in Study 2
		A’ significant	B significant		A’ significant	B significant
k = 0	25.33 (16.83)	-	-	23.98 (18.50)	-	-
k = 1	33.04 (17.14)	33.93 (17.82)	32.15 (16.42)	33.51 (19.04)	34.36 (20.35)	32.75 (18.13)
k = 2	49.34 (15.27)	50.65 (15.27)	48.00 (15.19)	46.67 (17.52)	48.65 (17.49)	43.62 (18.06)
k = 3	65.77 (16.18)	67.13 (16.11)	64.38 (16.16)	61.15 (18.77)	64.16 (17.16)	57.78 (19.86)
k = 4	73.02 (17.65)	-	-	71.08 (18.47)	-	-

k refers to the number of significant results within the scenario. ‘A’ significant’ means that the direct replication was significant, ‘B significant’ means that the conceptual replication was significant