Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 5;9:20552076231198702. doi: 10.1177/20552076231198702

Table 2.

The final inclusion and exclusion criteria using the PICO method.

PICO Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population First screening: Vulnerable people (e.g. chronically ill, elderly, ethnic minority)
Second screening: People with a low socioeconomic position, i.e. people with a low income or low-income countries, people with a low education attainment, people from ethnic minorities, or people from deprived countries
Studies that address the opinion or evaluation of other stakeholders, or healthcare workers specifically
Intervention Autonomous mHealth applications that can be adopted by low SEP individuals on a mobile device (e.g. smartphone, tablet, computer) without requiring interaction with a third party (e.g. caregivers, relatives, other devices). Examples are as follows:
  • Mental health applications

  • Chronic disease management applications

  • Self-monitoring applications

  • Medical applications focused on healthcare personnel or relatives of the low SEP individual.

  • Interventions that are not autonomous but interact with other persons (e.g. caregivers) by, e.g. SMS, phone contact, instant messages, video calls, and social media.

  • Studies focused on AR/VR/AI/robots

  • Studies that focused on motion sensors or activity trackers.

  • Feasibility-, cost-specific-, and protocol studies

Comparator NA NA
Outcome of interest Factors that promote or hinder adoption. These may include (among others) psychosocial, technical, demographic, and environmental factors. Studies that do not focus primarily on or explicitly address the factors that promote or hinder adoption.