Table 2.
Recommendations for investigators based on achievement of expert panel consensus
No. of respondents in agreement | % of respondents in agreement | Round consensus achieved | |
---|---|---|---|
Definitions and validity | |||
Muscle and nerve stimulation provide a valid assessment of voluntary activation | 22 | 73 | Round 1 |
Stimulation configuration and parameters | |||
Self-adhesive stimulation pads preferred to a stimulating pen of metal plate electrodes | 24 | 80 | Round 1 |
Twin (doublet stimulation) required for valid assessment of voluntary activation | 19 | 73 | Round 2 |
Reliability and familiarisation | |||
A single familiarisation session is sufficient to achieve valid and reliable measures during experimental sessions | 23 | 76 | Round 1 |
Verbal encouragement and feedback from force/torque traces are equally acceptable forms of feedback | 20 | 77 | Round 2 |
Real-time feedback improves the validity and reliability of voluntary activation estimates | 21 | 81 | Round 2 |
Increase the current eliciting a maximal twitch response by 20% during voluntary activation assessments | 18 | 70 | Round 2 |
Analysis, interpretation, and other methodological considerations | |||
A single contraction is sufficient to estimate voluntary activation | 26 | 87 | Round 1 |
Twitch interpolation (comparing the difference between maximal voluntary and maximal stimulated force to resting potentiated twitch force) provides a more valid estimate of voluntary activation than the central activation ratio (comparing maximal voluntary force against maximal voluntary force and maximal stimulated force) | 22 | 73 | Round 1 |
Stimulation will always activate antagonists, although this only has a minor effect on validity | 21 | 70 | Round 1 |
Manual triggering of the stimulus is the most consistent and accurate method of stimulus administration | 20 | 77 | Round 2 |
Some participants did not complete both rounds of the questionnaire (Round 1: n = 30; Round 2: n = 26). Percentages will correspond to a different absolute response rate between rounds