Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 13;9(37):eadh2458. doi: 10.1126/sciadv.adh2458

Table 1. Current status for the planetary boundaries.

Earth system process Control variable(s) Planetary boundary Preindustrial Holocene base value Upper end of zone of increasing risk Current value of control variable
Climate change Atmospheric CO2 concentration (ppm CO2) 350 ppm CO2 280 ppm CO2 450 ppm CO2 417 ppm CO2 (41)
Total anthropogenic radiative forcing at top-of-atmosphere (W m−2) +1.0 W m−2 0 W m−2 +1.5 W m−2 +2.91 W m−2 (41)
Change in biosphere integrity Genetic diversity: E/MSY <10 E/MSY but with an aspirational goal of ca. 1 E/MSY (assumed background rate of extinction loss) 1 E/MSY 100 E/MSY >100 E/MSY (2426)
Functional integrity: measured as energy available to ecosystems (NPP) (% HANPP) HANPP (in billion tonnes of C year1) <10% of preindustrial Holocene NPP, i.e., >90% remaining for supporting biosphere function 1.9% (2σ variability of preindustrial Holocene century-mean NPP) 20% HANPP 30% HANPP (see the Supplementary Materials)
Stratospheric ozone depletion Stratospheric O3 concentration, (global average) (DU) <5% reduction from preindustrial level assessed by latitude (~276 DU) 290 DU 261 DU 284.6 DU (96)
Ocean acidification Carbonate ion concentration, average global surface ocean saturation state with respect to aragonite (Ωarag) ≥80% Ωarag of mean preindustrial aragonite saturation state of surface ocean, including natural diel and seasonal variability 3.44 Ωarag 2.75 Ωarag 2.8 Ωarag (71)
Biogeochemical flows: P and N cycles Phosphate global: P flow from freshwater systems into the ocean; regional: P flow from fertilizers to erodible soils (Tg of P year−1) Phosphate global: 11 Tg of P year−1; regional: 6.2 Tg of P year−1 mined and applied to erodible (agricultural) soils. Boundary is a global average, but regional distribution is critical for impacts. 0 Tg of P year−1 Global: 100 Tg of P year−1; regional: 11.2 Tg of P year−1 Global: 22.6 Tg of P year−1 (75); regional: 17.5 Tg of P year−1 (76)
Nitrogen global: industrial and intentional fixation of N (Tg of N year−1) Nitrogen global: 62 Tg of N year−1. Boundary is a global average. Anthropogenic biological N fixation on agriculture areas highly uncertain but estimates in range of ~30 to 70 Tg of N year−1. Boundary acts as a global “valve” limiting introduction of new reactive N to Earth system, but regional distribution of fertilizer N is critical for impacts. 0 Tg of N year−1 82 Tg of N year−1 190 Tg of N year−1 (84)
Land system change Global: area of forested land as the percentage of original forest cover; biome: area of forested land as the percentage of potential forest (% area remaining) Global: 75% values are a weighted average of the three individual biome boundaries; biomes: tropical, 85%; temperate, 50%; boreal: 85% 100% Global: 54%; biomes: tropical, 60%; temperate, 30%; boreal: 60% Global: 60% [(72, 97) and see the Supplementary Materials]; tropical: Americas, 83.9%; Africa, 54.3%; Asia, 37.5%; temperate: Americas, 51.2%; Europe, 34.2%; Asia, 37.9%; boreal: Americas, 56.6%; Eurasia: 70.3%
Freshwater change Blue water: human induced disturbance of blue water flow Upper limit (95th percentile) of global land area with deviations greater than during preindustrial, Blue water: 10.2% 9.4% (median of preindustrial conditions) 50% (provisional) 18.2% (46)
Green water: human induced disturbance of water available to plants (% land area with deviations from preindustrial variability) Green water: 11.1% 9.8% (median of preindustrial conditions) 50% (provisional) 15.8% (46)
Atmospheric aerosol loading Interhemispheric difference in AOD 0.1 (mean annual interhemispheric difference) 0.03 0.25 0.076 (55, 57, 68)
Novel entities Percentage of synthetic chemicals released to the environment without adequate safety testing 0 0 NA Transgressed