Table 1.
Intervention studies investigating stress management for oncology nurses
| Author (year) | Country | Design | Participants; sample size (n) | Intervention information | Control group (YES/NO) | Assessment information (including time frames) | Effect size interpretation | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Onan et al. | Turkey | Quasi-experi- | Oncology | Coping skills interven- | NO | Outcomes: stress, ways of | Not reported | |
| (2013) | ment | nurses; n = 30 | tion; nine 90-minute | coping, and burnout. (Pre-and | ||||
| sessions | post-intervention, 1-month | |||||||
| follow-up) | ||||||||
| Udo et al. | Sweden | Mixed-methods | Oncology | Educational interven- | YES – non-edu- | Outcomes: Attitudes towards | Not reported | |
| (2013) | quasi-experi- | nurses; n = 42 | tion on existential | cational group | caring for patients feeling | |||
| ment | issues; five 90-minute | meaningless scale, sense of | ||||||
| sessions | coherence scale. (Post-interven- | |||||||
| tion and 6-month follow-up) | ||||||||
| Le Blanc | Nether- | Longitudinal | Physicians, on- | Team-based burnout | YES – received | Outcomes: Burnout (emotional | Small negative rela- | |
| et al. (2007) | lands | quasi-experi- | cology nurses, | programme target- | no intervention | exhaustion and depersonali- | tionships (B = –.06 | |
| ment | radiotherapy | ing various concepts | at all | sation), social support, deci- | to –.18) between all | |||
| assistants; | (e.g. decision making, | sion making participation, job | outcomes, apart from | |||||
| n = 664 | social support, problem | control, job demands. (Pre-and | a medium to strong | |||||
| solving); six monthly | post-intervention, 6-month | positive association | ||||||
| 3-hour sessions | follow-up) | between workload and | ||||||
| emotional exhaustion | ||||||||
| Kravits | USA | Mixed-methods | Oncology | One 6-hour psycho- | NO | Outcomes: burnout, Draw-a- | Not reported | |
| et al. (2010) | nurses; n = 248 | educational pro- | Person-in-the-Rain Art Assess- | |||||
| gramme on self-care | ment (PIR) to measure inter- | |||||||
| strategies | action between stressors and | |||||||
| coping resources to augment | ||||||||
| burnout scores. (Pre-and post- | ||||||||
| intervention) | ||||||||
| Potter et al. | USA | Descriptive | Oncology | Compassion fatigue | NO | Outcomes: Burnout, compas- | Not reported | |
| (2013) | pilot study | nurses; n = 14 | resiliency programme; | sion fatigue, impact of events, | ||||
| four 90-minute ses- | nursing job satisfaction. (Pre- | |||||||
| sions | and post-intervention, 3 and | |||||||
| 6-month follow-ups) | ||||||||
| Cohen-Katz | USA | Randomised- | Oncology | Mindfulness Based | YES – waitlist | Outcomes: Burnout, emotional | Not reported | |
| et al. (2005) | controlled trial | nurses; n = 27 | Stress Reduction; | condition | exhaustion, psychological dis- | |||
| eight weekly 2.5-hour | tress. Process measure: Mind- | |||||||
| sessions | fulness Attention Awareness | |||||||
| Scale. (Pre-and post-interven- | ||||||||
| tion, 3-month follow-up) | ||||||||
| Duarte | Portugal | Non-ran- | Oncology | Mindfulness Based | YES – waitlist | Outcomes: Professional quality | Medium to large ef- | |
| and Pinto- | domised con- | nurses; n = 48 | Stress Reduction; six | condition | of life; depression, anxiety and | fects (d values not pre- | ||
| Gouveia | trolled study | weekly 2-hour group | stress; self-compassion. Pro- | sented in the paper) | ||||
| (2016) | sessions | cess measures: psychological | on stress, burnout and | |||||
| inflexibility and mindfulness. | compassion fatigue | |||||||
| (Pre-and post-intervention, no | ||||||||
| follow-up) | ||||||||
| Villani et al. | Italy | Randomised- | Oncology | Stress Inoculation | YES – neutral | Outcomes: stress, anxiety, | Not reported | |
| (2013) | controlled trial | nurses; n = 30 | Training (SIT) through | video clips, pre- | coping and job content. (Pre- | |||
| mobile phone applica- | senting natural | and post measures after each | ||||||
| tion; 8 sessions over | landscapes, with- | session) | ||||||
| 4 weeks | out any narrative | |||||||
| Poulsen | USA | Randomised- | Radiation | One-day educational | YES – written- | Outcomes: recovery, satisfac- | Medium significant | |
| et al. (2015) | controlled trial | therapists | workshop on recov- | educational | tion with self-care practices, | effects (d = .72 to .77) | ||
| and oncology | ery-related self-care | information only | perceived sleep quality. (Pre- | observed for all | ||||
| nurses; n = 70 | practices | intervention, then every week | outcomes at six-week | |||||
| for a 6-week period) | follow-up | |||||||