Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 11;12(1):361–371. doi: 10.5334/pme.914

Table 1.

Summary of included articles in a review of Creative Approaches to Reflective Learning amongst Medical Students.


REFERENCE STUDENT NUMBER STUDY DESIGN RLMETHOD ACTIVITY REPORTED OUTCOMES CASP OUTCOME

Brand et al. [38] 10 (4 medical students) Pre-post survey. Focus groups. Viewing Reflection on and discussion of photographs of older persons Challenged assumptions about ageing and improved Geriatrics Attitudes Scale scores Minor concerns

Brand et al. [39] 128 Pre-post survey. Written reflections. Viewing Reflection on and discussion of photographs of older persons Challenged assumptions about ageing and improved Geriatrics Attitudes Scale scores No concerns

Centeno et al. [41] 20 Post survey. Focus groups. Viewing Reflection on museum art works Improved understanding of decision making and individualized care plans Minor concerns

De la Croix et al. [40] Not
stated
Post survey. Written reflections. Performing Learning pre-performative theatre skills Improved communication, confidence, and provided space for balance, reflection, and understanding Minor concerns

Gowda et al. [42] 44 Pre-post survey. Focus groups. Written evaluation. Viewing Viewing and discussing museum art works Improved observational skills, awareness of multiple perspectives, a place for restoration and connection with peers No concerns

Green [43] 42 Pre-post survey. Viewing Creating and reading graphic novels Cultivated a culture of sharing and reflecting upon experiences Minor concerns

Hayes et al. [44] 10 Reflective diary Performing Learning and delivering devised theatre Developed emotional honesty with peers Minor concerns

Hoffman et al. [45] 18 End of course evaluation Performing Learning improvisational theatre Improved active listening and appreciation of the perspectives of others Minor concerns

Neel et al. [46] 21 Pre-post survey Performing Learning improvisational theatre Improved proactivity, wellbeing, and communication Moderate concerns

Osman et al. [47] 42 Written reflections Imagining Prioritizing end of life decisions Developed recognition of differing priorities and highlighted the importance of personalized care Moderate concerns

Pacala et al. [48] 477 End of course evaluation Imagining Role playing the ageing process Improved attitudes towards aging and understanding of older adults’ experiences and perspectives Minor concerns

Potash et al. [49] 20 Pre-post survey Creating Art making (poem and artwork) Increased emotional awareness and self-understanding Minor concerns

Sandars et al. [50] 12 Focus group Creating Creating digital storytelling videos Encouraged deeper reflection Minor concerns

Saunders et al. [51] 82 Open-ended reflection questions Mind-body Mind-body skills course Built connections with peers, increased self-awareness, and changed attitudes towards medical school Minor concerns

Shapiro et al. [52] 25 Group interview. Written feedback. Viewing Viewing and discussing art or dance Increased awareness of emotional responses in self and others and helped students see more depth in patients Minor concerns

Abbreviations: CASP = Critical Appraisal Skills Programme; RL = Reflective Learning.