Table 1.
Summary of included articles in a review of Creative Approaches to Reflective Learning amongst Medical Students.
|
| ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| REFERENCE | STUDENT NUMBER | STUDY DESIGN | RLMETHOD | ACTIVITY | REPORTED OUTCOMES | CASP OUTCOME |
|
| ||||||
| Brand et al. [38] | 10 (4 medical students) | Pre-post survey. Focus groups. | Viewing | Reflection on and discussion of photographs of older persons | Challenged assumptions about ageing and improved Geriatrics Attitudes Scale scores | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Brand et al. [39] | 128 | Pre-post survey. Written reflections. | Viewing | Reflection on and discussion of photographs of older persons | Challenged assumptions about ageing and improved Geriatrics Attitudes Scale scores | No concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Centeno et al. [41] | 20 | Post survey. Focus groups. | Viewing | Reflection on museum art works | Improved understanding of decision making and individualized care plans | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| De la Croix et al. [40] | Not stated |
Post survey. Written reflections. | Performing | Learning pre-performative theatre skills | Improved communication, confidence, and provided space for balance, reflection, and understanding | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Gowda et al. [42] | 44 | Pre-post survey. Focus groups. Written evaluation. | Viewing | Viewing and discussing museum art works | Improved observational skills, awareness of multiple perspectives, a place for restoration and connection with peers | No concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Green [43] | 42 | Pre-post survey. | Viewing | Creating and reading graphic novels | Cultivated a culture of sharing and reflecting upon experiences | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Hayes et al. [44] | 10 | Reflective diary | Performing | Learning and delivering devised theatre | Developed emotional honesty with peers | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Hoffman et al. [45] | 18 | End of course evaluation | Performing | Learning improvisational theatre | Improved active listening and appreciation of the perspectives of others | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Neel et al. [46] | 21 | Pre-post survey | Performing | Learning improvisational theatre | Improved proactivity, wellbeing, and communication | Moderate concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Osman et al. [47] | 42 | Written reflections | Imagining | Prioritizing end of life decisions | Developed recognition of differing priorities and highlighted the importance of personalized care | Moderate concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Pacala et al. [48] | 477 | End of course evaluation | Imagining | Role playing the ageing process | Improved attitudes towards aging and understanding of older adults’ experiences and perspectives | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Potash et al. [49] | 20 | Pre-post survey | Creating | Art making (poem and artwork) | Increased emotional awareness and self-understanding | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Sandars et al. [50] | 12 | Focus group | Creating | Creating digital storytelling videos | Encouraged deeper reflection | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Saunders et al. [51] | 82 | Open-ended reflection questions | Mind-body | Mind-body skills course | Built connections with peers, increased self-awareness, and changed attitudes towards medical school | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
| Shapiro et al. [52] | 25 | Group interview. Written feedback. | Viewing | Viewing and discussing art or dance | Increased awareness of emotional responses in self and others and helped students see more depth in patients | Minor concerns |
|
| ||||||
Abbreviations: CASP = Critical Appraisal Skills Programme; RL = Reflective Learning.