Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Sep 15.
Published in final edited form as: Circulation. 2022 Jun 29;146(5):e18–e43. doi: 10.1161/CIR.0000000000001078

Table 1.

New and Updated Metrics for Measurement and Quantitative Assessment of CVH (see Notes for implementation of each metric; See Supplemental Material for additional information on scoring of the Diet Metric, scoring in children at different ages, and examples of overall CVH scores in diverse scenarios)

Domain CVH metric Method of measurement Quantification of CVH metric: adults (≥20 y of age) Quantification of CVH metric: children (up to 19 y of age)
Health behaviors Diet Measurement: Self-reported daily intake of a DASH-style eating pattern
Example tools for measurement: DASH diet score130,131 (populations); MEPA132 (individuals)
Quantiles of DASH-style diet adherence or HEI-2015 (population) Quantiles of DASH-style diet adherence or HEI-2015 (population) or MEPA (individuals)*; ages 2–19 y (see Supplemental Material for younger ages)
Scoring (population): Scoring (population):
Points Quantile Points Quantile
100 ≥95th percentile (top/ideal diet) 100 ≥95th percentile (top/ideal diet)
80 75th–94th percentile 80 75th–94th percentile
50 50th–74th percentile 50 50th–74th percentile
25 25th–49th percentile 25 25th–49th percentile
0 1st–24th percentile (bottom/least ideal quartile) 0 1st–24th percentile (bottom/least ideal quartile)
Scoring (individual): Scoring (individual):
Points MEPA score (points) Points MEPA score (points)
100 15–16 100 9–10
80 12–14 80 7–8
50 8–11 50 5–6
25 4–7 25 3–4
0 0–3 0 0–2
PA Measurement: Self-reported minutes of moderate or vigorous PA per week
Example tools for measurement: NHANES PAQ-K questionnaire133
Metric: Minutes of moderate- (or greater) intensity activity per week: Metric: Combustible tobacco use or inhaled NDS use at any age (per clinician discretion); or secondhand smoke exposure
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Minutes Points Minutes
100 ≥150 100 ≥420
90 120–149 90 360–419
80 90–119 80 300–359
60 60–89 60 240–299
40 30–59 40 120–239
20 1–29 20 1–119
0 0 0 0
Nicotine exposure Measurement: Self-reported use of cigarettes or inhaled NDS
Example tools for measurement: NHANES SMQ134
Metric: Combustible tobacco use or inhaled NDS use; or secondhand smoke exposure Metric: Combustible tobacco use or inhaled NDS use at any age (per clinician discretion); or secondhand smoke exposure
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Status Points Status
100 Never smoker 100 Never tried
75 Former smoker, quit ≥5 y 50 Tried any nicotine product, but >30 d ago
50 Former smoker, quit 1–<5 y
25 Former smoker, quit <1 y, or currently using inhaled NDS 25 Currently using inhaled NDS
0 Current smoker 0 Current combustible use (any within 30 d)
Subtract 20 points (unless score is 0) for living with active indoor smoker in home Subtract 20 points (unless score is 0) for living with active indoor smoker in home
Sleep health Measurement: Self-reported average hours of sleep per night Example tools for measurement: “On average, how many hours of sleep do you get per night?” Consider objective sleep/actigraphy data from wearable technology if available Metric: Average hours of sleep per night Metric: Average hours of sleep per night (or per 24 h for age ≤5 y; see notes for age-appropriate ranges)
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Level Points Level
100 7–<9 100 Age-appropriate optimal range
90 9–<10 90 <1 h above optimal range
70 6–<7 70 <1 h below optimal range
40 5–<6 or ≥10 40 1–<2 h below or ≥1 h above optimal
20 4–<5 20 2–<3 h below optimal range
0 <4 0 ≥3 h below optimal range
Health factors BMI Measurement: Body weight (kilograms) divided by height squared (meters squared)
Example tools for measurement: Objective measurement of height and weight
Metric: BMI (kg/m2) Metric: BMI percentiles for age and sex, starting in infancy; see Supplemental Material for suggestions for age <2 y
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Level Points Level
100 <25 100 5th–<85th percentile
70 25.0–29.9 70 85th–<95th percentile
30 30.0–34.9 30 95th percentile–<120% of the 95th percentile
15 35.0–39.9 15 120% of the 95th percentile–<140% of the 95th percentile
0 ≥40.0 0 ≥140% of the 95th percentile
Blood lipids Measurement: Plasma total and HDL cholesterol with calculation of non–HDL cholesterol
Example tools for measurement: Fasting or nonfasting blood sample
Metric: Non–HDL cholesterol (mg/dL) Metric: Non–HDL cholesterol (mg/dL), starting no later than age 9–11 y and earlier per clinician discretion
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Level Points Level
100 <130 100 <100
60 130–159 60 100–119
40 160–189 40 120–144
20 190–219 20 145–189
0 ≥220 0 ≥190
If drug-treated level, subtract 20 points If drug-treated level, subtract 20 points
Blood glucose Measurement: FBG or casual HbA1c
Example tools for measurement: Fasting (FBG, HbA1c) or non-fasting (HbA1c) blood sample
Metric: FBG (mg/dL) or HbA1c (%) Metric: FBG (mg/dL) or HbA1c (%), symptom-based screening at any age or risk-based screening starting at age ≥10 y of age or onset of puberty per clinician discretion
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Level Points Level
100 No history of diabetes and FBG <100 (or HbA1c <5.7) 100 No history of diabetes and FBG <100 (or HbA1c < 5.7)
60 No diabetes and FBG 100–125 (or HbA1c 5.7–6.4) (prediabetes) 60 No diabetes and FBG 100–125 (or HbA1c 5.7–6.4) (prediabetes)
40 Diabetes with HbA1c <7.0 40 Diabetes with HbA1c <7.0
30 Diabetes with HbA1c 7.0–7.9 30 Diabetes with HbA1c 7.0–7.9
20 Diabetes with HbA1c 8.0–8.9 20 Diabetes with HbA1c 8.0–8.9
10 Diabetes with Hb A1c 9.0–9.9 10 Diabetes with Hb A1c 9.0–9.9
0 Diabetes with HbA1c ≥10.0 0 Diabetes with HbA1c ≥10.0
BP Measurement: Appropriately measured systolic and diastolic BPs
Example tools for measurement: Appropriately sized BP cuff
Metric: Systolic and diastolic BPs (mm Hg) Metric: Systolic and diastolic BP (mm Hg) percentiles for age through 12 y. For age ≥13 y, use adult scoring. Screening should start no later than age 3 y and earlier per clinician discretion
Scoring: Scoring:
Points Level Points Level
100 <120/<80 (optimal) 100 Optimal (<90th percentile)
75 120–129/<80 (elevated) 75 Elevated (≥90th–<95th percentile or ≥120/80 mm Hg to <95th percentile, whichever is lower)
50 130–139 or 80–89 (stage 1 hypertension) 50 Stage 1 hypertension (≥95th–<95th percentile+12 mm Hg, or 130/80 to 139/89 mm Hg, whichever is lower)
25 140–159 or 90–99 25 Stage 2 hypertension (≥95th percentile+12 mm Hg, or ≥140/90 mm Hg, whichever is lower)
0 ≥160 or ≥100 0 Systolic BP ≥160 or ≥95th percentile+30 mm Hg systolic BP, whichever is lower; and/or diastolic BP ≥100 or ≥95th percentile+20 mm Hg diastolic BP
Subtract 20 points if treated level Subtract 20 points if treated level
Points Level (kg/m2)
100 18.5–22.9
75 23.0–24.9
50 25.0–29.9
25 30.0–34.9
0 ≥35.0

BMI indicates body mass index; BP, blood pressure; CVH, cardiovascular health; DASH, Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension; FBG, fasting blood glucose; HbA1c, hemoglobin A1c; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; HEI, Healthy Eating Index; MEPA, Mediterranean Eating Pattern for Americans; NDS, nicotine-delivery system; NHANES, National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys; PA, physical activity; PAQ-K, Physical Activity Questionnaire K; and SMQ, smoking assessment.

*

Cannot meet these metrics until solid foods are being consumed.

Notes on implementation:

Diet: See Supplemental Material Appendix 1. For adults and children, a score of 100 points for the CVH diet metric should be assigned for the top (95th percentile) or a score of 15 to 16 on the MEPA (for individuals) or for those in the ≥95th percentile on the DASH score or HEI-2015 (for populations). The 75th to 94th percentile should be assigned 80 points, given that improvement likely can be made even among those in this top quartile. For individuals, the MEPA points are stratified for the 100-point scoring system approximately by quantiles. In children, a modified MEPA is suggested that is based on age-appropriate foods. The writing group recognizes that the quantiles may need to be adjusted or recalibrated at intervals with population shifts in eating patterns. In children, the scoring applies only once solid foods are being consumed. For now, the reference population for quantiles of HEI or DASH score should be the NHANES sample from 2015 to 2018. The writing group acknowledges that this may need to change or be updated over time. Clinicians should use judgment in assigning points for culturally contextual healthy diets. For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

PA: Thresholds are based in part on US Physical Activity Guidelines. For adults, each minute of moderate activity should count as 1 minute and each minute of vigorous activity should count as 2 minutes toward the total for the week. For children, each minute of moderate or vigorous activity should count as 1 minute. The score for PA is not linear, given that there is a greater increase in health benefit for each minute of marginal exercise at the lower end of the range and the association tends to approach an asymptote at the higher end of the range.

If scoring is desired for children ≤5 years of age, see Supplemental Material. For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

Nicotine exposure: The writing group recommends subtracting 20 points for children and adults exposed to indoor secondhand smoke at home, given its potential for long-term effects on cardiopulmonary health.135 For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

Sleep health: Thresholds are based in part on sleep guidelines. Clinicians may consider subtracting 20 points from the sleep score for adults or children with untreated or undertreated sleep apnea if information is available. Note that overall scoring reflects the inverse-U–shaped association of sleep duration with health outcomes, such that excessive sleep duration is also considered to be suboptimal for CVH.

For children, age-appropriate optimal sleep durations are as follows121:

Age 4 to 12 months, 12 to 16 hours per 24 hours (includes naps);

Age 1 to 2 years, 11 to 14 hours per 24 hours;

Age 3 to 5 years, 10 to 13 hours per 24 hours;

Age 6 to 12 years, 9 to 12 hours; and

Age 13 to 18 years, 8 to 10 hours.

For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

BMI: Thresholds are based in part on National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) guidelines. The writing group acknowledges that BMI is an imperfect metric for determining healthy body weight and body composition. Nonetheless, it is widely available and routinely calculated in clinical and research settings. BMI ranges may differ for individuals from diverse ancestries. For example, the World Health Organization has recommended different BMI ranges for individuals of Asian or Pacific ancestry. For individuals in these groups, point scores should be aligned as appropriate:

Clinicians may want to assign 100 points for overweight individuals (BMI, 25.0–29.9 kg/m2) who are lean with higher muscle mass. For underweight individuals (<18.5 kg/m2 in adults or below the fifth percentile in children), the writing group defers to clinician judgment in assigning points on the basis of individual assessment as to whether the underweight BMI is healthy or unhealthy. Conditions that should be considered unhealthy include chronic catabolic illnesses (eg, cancer), eating disorders, and growth failure (for children). For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

Blood lipids: Thresholds are based in part on 2018 Cholesterol Clinical Practice Guideline.129a The levels of non–HDL cholesterol for adults were selected on the basis of current guideline recommendations and in concert with the observation that non–HDL cholesterol levels are generally ≈30 mg/dL higher than low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels in normative ranges in the population. For children, thresholds for non–HDL cholesterol were chosen on the basis of NHLBI pediatric guidelines, pediatric low-density lipoprotein cholesterol thresholds for diagnosis of familial hypercholesterolemia phenotypes (+30 mg/dL), and current distributions of non–HDL cholesterol to smooth transitions to adult point scales. The writing group recommends subtracting 20 points from the blood lipid score if the level of non–HDL-cholesterol represents a treated value, given the residual risk present in those who require treatment. There may be a modest shift in point scores for this metric as individuals age from pediatric to adult metrics. For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

Blood glucose: Thresholds are based in part on American Diabetes Association guidelines.129b If an individual patient with prediabetes (ie, not yet diagnosed formally with diabetes) is being treated with metformin to prevent the onset of diabetes and has normoglycemic levels, the writing group recommends clinician judgment for assigning point values (ie, consider subtracting 20 points). The maximal point value for patients with well-controlled diabetes was set at 40, given the residual risk present in those with diabetes. For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.

BP: Thresholds are based in part on the 2017 Hypertension Clinical Practice Guidelines and the guidelines for children.129c The writing group recommends subtracting 20 points from the BP score if the level of BP represents a treated value, given the residual risk present in those who require treatment. For additional notes on scoring in children, see Supplemental Material Appendix 2.