Table 3.
Author(s), country, year | Aim | Sample | Age and gender distribution | Methods | Intervention/manipulation | Measure of catastrophizing | Measure of cognition | Results | Clinically relevant catastrophizing (Y/N) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baker et. Al., Australia, 2018 | To investigate the relationship between objective and self-report cognitive impairments and the contribution of psychological attributes in participants with chronic back pain | Participants with chronic back pain, n = 41 | 17 males, 24 females Mean age: 42.97 |
Observational | N/A | PCS | TMT, SDMT, SCWT, WCST, TOPF, CFQ, EMQ, BRIEF-A | Catastrophizing correlated with poorer cognitive performance and most strongly related to objective cognitive performance | Unknown |
| |||||||||
Baker et al., Australia, 2018 | To evaluate the potential efficacy of a computerized cognitive training to improve cognitive performance in participants with chronic pain | Participants with chronic pain, n = 39 | 15 males, 24 females Mean age: 43.3 |
RCT | Participants randomized to computerized cognitive training (n = 20) for 8 weeks (3x/wk) or active control intervention (n = 19) | PCS | TMT, SDMT, SCWT, WCST, n-back, CFQ, EMQ, BRIEF-A | Catastrophizing decreased in both groups, self-reported cognitive function was correlated with reduced catastrophizing, responders to the intervention had higher baseline catastrophizing | N |
| |||||||||
Crombez et al., Belgium, 2000 | To investigate whether chronic pain patients display involuntary attentional shift towards pain-related information | Participants with chronic low back pain, n = 25 | 11 males, 14 females Mean age: 48.46 |
Observational | N/A | PCS | EST | Pain intensity, but not catastrophizing, was predictive of interference time | N |
| |||||||||
Goubert et al., Belgium, 2004 | To investigate the effects of distraction from pain during and after a pain-inducing lifting task | Participants with chronic low back pain, n = 52 | 25 males, 27 females Mean age: 46.30 |
Observational | Participants performed a lifting task with and without a cognitively distracting condition. Order of tasks was randomized | PCS, researchers modified the CSQ to measure attention to pain and catastrophic thinking during the lifting task | Reaction time via random interval auditory tones | Catastrophizing was related to increased vigilance and less engagement in the distracting task. The effect of catastrophizing on cognitive performance was mediated by attention to pain | N |
| |||||||||
Jorge et al., Brazil, 2009 | To investigate whether chronic low back pain and RA patients have deficits in memory | Participants with chronic low back pain (n = 21) and RA (n = 23) | 8 males, 36 females Mean age: 55.03 |
Observational | N/A | CSQ | WMS III | Catastrophizing associated with memory deficits | Unknown |
| |||||||||
Lariviere et al., Canada, 2013 | To examine the effect of pain and attentional interference on anticipatory postural adjustments in participants with chronic low back pain | Participants with chronic low back pain, n = 59 | 30 males, 29 females Mean age: 40 |
Observational | Participants performed rapid flexion movements of the right arm under 6 conditions including a control and different attentional demands. Assessed in groups by high/low catastrophizing | PCS | Latency of trunk muscle activation as a proxy of attentional interference | Catastrophizing and attention modulate trunk muscle activation | Y |
| |||||||||
Melkumova et al., Russia, 2011 | To investigate the nature of impairments of cognitive functions and the factors influencing them in chronic pain | Participants with chronic spinal pain (n = 64) and healthy controls (n = 20) | 22 male, 42 females Mean age: 49.1 |
Observational | Participants split by age: group 1—30–50 years and group 2—51–60 years | PCS | SNLCT, SDMT, SCWT, WCST, COWAT, DST, ROCF | In older participants (group 2), cognitive functions were most influenced by affective-motivation components of pain including catastrophizing | N |
| |||||||||
Roelofs et al., Netherlands, 2005 | To examine the role of personal relevance of sensory pain-related words in selective attentional processing in chronic low back pain | Participants with chronic low back pain, n = 30 | 11 males, 19 females Mean age: 41.2 |
Observational | N/A | PCS | Modified SCWT | No correlation between cognition and catastrophizing | N |
| |||||||||
Simon et al., United States, 2016 | To determine how working memory and catastrophizing are associated with pain intensity in chronic low back pain | Participants with chronic low back pain (n = 60) and pain-free controls (n = 30) | 29 males, 61 females Mean age: 47.62 |
Observational | N/A | PCS | DSTR | Higher memory impairment and catastrophizing in chronic low back pain compared to controls but no correlation between the two | N |
| |||||||||
Tabira et al., Japan, 2020 | To investigate the relationship between attention bias and psychological assessment | Participants with chronic low back pain, n = 13 | 2 males, 11 females Mean age: 70.3 |
Observational | Participants performed a reaction time task during an attentional bias modification task including neutral and threatening faces | PCS | Reaction time during ABM task | Catastrophizing associated with an increased attentional bias towards a threatening stimulus | N |