Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 19;2023(9):CD014791. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD014791.pub2

NCT00241280.

Study characteristics
Methods Study design: RCT, parallel‐group design
Numbers randomized (total and per group): total 501 participants; 247 in Etafilcon A, 254 in Galyfilcon A group
Unit of randomization: person
Masking: double (participant, investigator)
Exclusions and losses to follow‐up (total and per group): total 118 participants; 48 in Etafilcon A, 68 in Galyfilcon A group
  • 11/48 participants in Etafilcon A not completed giving "comfort" as reason

  • 16/68 participants in Galyfilcon A not completed giving "comfort" as reason


Number analyzed (total and per group):
  • VA outcome: total 385 participants (770 eyes); 199 (398 eyes) in Etafilcon A, 186 (372 eyes) in Galyfilcon A group

  • safety outcome: total 501 participants; 247 in Etafilcon A, 254 in Galyfilcon A group


Unit of analysis (person or eye): person and eye
Study duration (planned and actual): 52 weeks
Intervention duration: 52 weeks
How were missing data handled: not reported
Sample size and power calculation: not reported
Participants Country: USA
Setting: multicenter (25 sites) in university hospital and private practices
Inclusion criteria: at least 18 years of age; minimum of 7 days successful lens wear; contact lens prescription requiring between −1.00 to −6.00 D spherical power; less than 1.00 D of astigmatism in either eye
Exclusion criteria: not reported
Baseline characteristicsRefractive condition: myopia
Etafilcon A (N = 247)
  • women (n, %): 150 (60.7%)

  • age (mean, SD, range): 31.7 (18 to 51) years

  • race/ethnicity (n, %): predominantly white, 203 (82.2%)

  • habitual wearers (n, %): not reported


Galyfilcon A (N = 254)
  • women (n, %): 172 (67.7%)

  • age (mean, SD, range): 32.8 (18 to 60) years

  • race/ethnicity (n, %): predominantly white, 217 (85.4%)

  • habitual wearers (n, %): not reported


Overall (N = 501)
  • women (n, %): 322 (64.3%)

  • age (mean, SD, range): 32.3 ± 6.3 (18 to 60) years (calculated)

  • race/ethnicity (n, %): predominantly white, 420 (83.8%)

  • habitual wearers (n, %): not reported

Interventions Etafilcon A
  • material: hydrogel

  • replacement frequency: 7 days/6 nights


Galyfilcon A
  • material: silicone hydrogel

  • replacement frequency: 7 days/6 nights

Outcomes Primary outcome:
  • percentage of participant eyes reported with Snellen VA worse than 20/40 at each study visit

  • incidence of rates of contact lens‐related serious and significant adverse events (if there were multiple diagnostic findings, the event was categorized under the highest event level diagnostic)


Secondary outcomes: not specified
Adverse outcomes (Y/N), if yes, please describe: incidence of rates of contact lens‐related serious and significant adverse events
Measurement time points: baseline, 24 hours, 1, 4, 12, 24, 36, and 52 weeks
Notes Sponsorship source: Johnson & Johnson Vision Care Inc.
Author's name: David C Turner, PhD
Institution: Johnson & Johnson Vision Care Inc.
Conflicts of interest: not reported
Publication language: English
Trial register:NCT00241280