Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 19;2023(9):CD014791. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD014791.pub2

NCT01354223.

Study characteristics
Methods Study design: RCT, parallel‐group design
Numbers randomized (total and per group): total 90 participants; 60 in Stenfilcon A group, 30 in Ocufilcon B
Unit of randomization: person (1 eye per person)
Masking: open‐label
Exclusions and losses to follow‐up (total and per group): total 4 participants; 3 in Stenfilcon A, 1 in Ocufilcon B
Number analyzed (total and per group): total 86 participants; 57 in Stenfilcon A, 29 in Ocufilcon B
Unit of analysis (individual or eye): person
Study duration (planned and actual): 3 months
Intervention duration: 3 months
How were missing data handled: not reported
Sample size and power calculation: not reported
Participants Country: USA
Setting: 4 centers
Inclusion criteria: at least 18 years of age; good general health; adapted current full‐time silicone hydrogel or soft contact lens wearer (at least 8 hours per day, worn daily for at least 1 month); requires spectacle lens powers between −1.00 and −6.00 DS; no more than 1.00 D of refractive astigmatism; willing to wear contact lenses in both eyes; manifest refraction Snellen VA equal to or better than 20/25 in each eye; contact lens correction to Snellen VA equal to or better than 20/30 in each eye
Exclusion criteria: monovision modality; unwilling to be fit with distance lenses in both eyes; poor personal hygiene; active participation in another clinical trial within 30 days prior to this study; pregnant lactating or is planning a pregnancy within the next 3 months; a member, relative, or household member of the investigator or of the investigational office staff; sensitivity to study lubricants; previous refractive surgery; history of orthokeratology treatment; aphakic or pseudophakic; ocular diseases (glaucoma, uveitis, iritis, keratoconus); systemic diseases (diabetes, Sjögren's syndrome, lupus erythematosus); use of topical ocular medications or any medication that might interfere with contact lens wear or that would require the lenses to be removed during the day; clinically significant (grade 3 or 4) anterior segment abnormalities; history of corneal hypoesthesia, corneal ulcer, corneal infiltrates or fungal infections, papillary conjunctivitis. Slit lamp findings that would contraindicate contact lens wear (dry eye, punctate staining over grade 2, corneal scars, neovascularization, seborrheic conjunctivitis, seborrheic eczema, blepharitis)
Baseline characteristicsRefractive condition: myopia
Stenfilcon A (N = 60)
  • women (n, %): 38 (63%)

  • age (mean, SD, range): 32.6 ± 8.88 years

  • race/ethnicity (n, %): not reported

  • habitual wearers (n, %): 60 (100%)


Ocufilcon B (N = 30)
  • women (n, %): 21 (70%)

  • age (mean, SD, range): 29.8 ± 8.55 years

  • race/ethnicity (n, %): not reported

  • habitual wearers (n, %): 30 (100%)


Overall (N = 90)
  • women (n, %): 59 (66%)

  • age (mean, SD, range): 31.7 ± 8.82 years

  • race/ethnicity (n, %): not reported

  • habitual wearers (n, %): 90 (100%)


Notes: baseline characteristics were comparable
Interventions Stenfilcon A
  • material: silicone hydrogel

  • replacement frequency: daily


Ocufilcon B
  • material: hydrogel

  • replacement frequency: daily

Outcomes Primary outcomes:
  • incidence of biomicroscopy

  • number of adverse events in unique eyes

  • Snellen VA of 20/25 or better


Secondary outcomes:
  • percentage of unique eyes that were reported to have no symptoms of discomfort

  • average hours of daily wearing time


Adverse outcomes (Y/N), if yes, please describe: Y, serious and non‐serious adverse events (papillary conjunctivitis: 6 events in 3 participants (5.00%) in Stenfilcon A group)
Measurement time points: baseline, weeks 1, 2, months 1, 2, and 3
Notes Sponsorship source: CooperVision Inc.
Authors' names: Stephen Byrnes, Lee Rigel, Mary Jo Stiegemeier, Peter Van Hoven, Eric White
Institution: Eric M. White, OD, Inc
Conflicts of interest : not reported
Publication language: English
Trial register:NCT01354223

CCLRU: Cornea and Contact Lens Research Unit
CL: contact lens(es)
D: diopters
DS: diopters sphere
logMAR: Logarithm of the Minimum Angle of Resolution
NEI: National Eye Institute
OSDI: Ocular Surface Disease Index
RCT: randomized controlled trial
SCL: soft contact lens(es)
SD: standard deviation
TBUT: tear breakup time
VAS: visual analog scale
VA: visual acuity