Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 19;7(9):101988. doi: 10.1016/j.cdnut.2023.101988

TABLE 1.

Methodologies and features of the 2 assessments

Assessment 1 Assessment 2
Settings 1 country (Burkina Faso) 4 countries (Chad, DRC, Senegal, and Sierra Leone)
Evaluative approaches and steps Contribution analysis:
1) Set out the cause–effect question to be addressed
2) Develop a theory of change (ToC) and risks to it
3) Gather the existing evidence on the ToC
4) Assemble and assess the contribution story and challenges to it
5) Seek out additional evidence
6) Revise and strengthen the contribution story and the ToC
Outcome harvesting:
1) Design the harvest
2) Document search
3) Engage with human sources
4) Substantiate with external sources
5) Analyze and interpret
6) Support use of findings
Timing of data collection Retrospective
Prospective (real-time)
Retrospective
Prospective (real-time)
Data sources Desk review
Ongoing documentation
Interviews
Questionnaire
Desk review
Interviews
Data curation Transcription of interviews
Chronology of events
Logic model
ToC
Transcription of interviews
Chronologies of events
Outcomes listing
Data analysis and interpretation Verification of the assumptions
Examination of the external influences
BFGM lens
BFGM lens

Abbreviations: BFGM, Breastfeeding Gear Model; DRC, Democratic Republic of the Congo; ToC, theory of change.