Table 3.
WHERE: country (LMIC designation), sites | WHEN: year of training | WHO: population trained | WHY: purpose of training | WHAT: structure of training | HOW: pulse oximetry related outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Region of the Americas
| |||||
Argentina (UMIC): 1 hospital in San Luis, 1 hospital in Rosario [58] |
San Luis – 2019; Rosario – 2017-2018 |
Neonatal nurses and neonatologists |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Increased screening after training with plans for universal screening |
Bolivia (LMIC): 1 hospital in La Paz, 1 hospital in Sucre [58] |
2018 |
Staff |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Unable to routinely screen due to lack of equipment and staff |
Brazil (UMIC), 5 NICUs in Rio de Janeiro [59] |
2009 |
Neonatal nurses and nurse assistants |
Improving nursing care to decrease mortality and incidence of ROP |
3-mo self-administered education package |
78% of qualified nurses and 82% of nurse assistants were trained and knowledge improved after training. No significant impact on survival or ROP was found. |
Colombia (UMIC): 1 hospital in Barranquilla [58] |
2014 |
Neonatal group |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Increased screening after training and screening became mandatory in 2018 |
Costa Rica (UMIC): Nationwide [58] |
2016 |
Not clearly stated, screening by respiratory therapists, nurses |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Screening nationwide after training |
Cuba (UMIC): not stated [58] |
Cuba: not provided |
Not stated, screening in some neonatal centres |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Limited screening due to pulse oximetry shortage |
Dominican Republic (UMIC): Nationwide [58] |
2019 |
Neonatologists, neonatal nurses, neonatology residents |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Screening not yet started |
El Salvador (LMIC): 1 hospital in San Salvador [58] |
Not provided |
Not stated |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Screening not yet started |
Guatemala (UMIC), Tecpán municipality [60] |
Year not provided. Study published in 2018. |
Traditional birth attendants |
Improve detection of maternal and perinatal complications and facility referral |
4-d training on perinatal complications, indications for referral, and use of the mHealth platform and device (which included a pulse oximeter) |
Rate of emergency referrals to facilities increased with the mHealth intervention and training. |
Honduras (LMIC): Nationwide [58] |
Not provided |
Staff providing neonatal care |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Increased screening after training |
Paraguay (UMIC): 1 hospital in Asunción [58] |
2013 |
Nurses |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Increased screening after training |
Peru (UMIC): 1 hospital in Lima. [58] |
2018 |
Not clearly stated, screening by nurses |
CCHD screening |
SIBEN Clinical Consensus |
Increased screening after training, pulse oximeter provision, and hiring dedicated staff for screening |
African Region
| |||||
South Africa (UMIC), 1 hospital in Port Elizabeth [61] |
2012-2014 |
Paediatricians and NICU nurses |
ROP prevention |
Paediatric academic programme for paediatricians and educational sessions for nursing staff |
More infants being screened for ROP after developing an ROP screening clinic. Training and provision of pulse oximeters and oxygen blenders made targeted oxygen supplementation possible. |
Eastern Mediterranean Region
| |||||
Iran (LMIC), Sistan and Baluchestan provinces [62] |
2014 |
Midwives and general practitioners |
Improve management of postpartum haemorrhage |
2-d training based on WHO guidelines |
Pulse oximetry use increased from 0 to 81.5% after the workshop. |
South-East Asia Region
| |||||
India (LMIC), Centres with high incidence of aggressive posterior ROP in North Karnataka [63] |
2011-2015 |
NICU nurses and paramedical staff, paediatricians |
Attempt to reduce severe ROP |
ROP prevention guidelines and targeted training |
More infants being are being screened for ROP but no mention of improved pulse oximetry use |
Western Pacific Region
| |||||
China (UMIC), Rural areas [64] |
2015 |
Public health stakeholders, clinicians, rural health workers |
CCHD, pneumonia, and sepsis detection |
Train the trainer model |
More than 52 000 newborns have been screened |
China (UMIC), Rural county hospitals in Yunnan Province [65] | 2015-2016 | Obstetricians and obstetric nurses | CCHD screening training | 1-d hands on training | Improved knowledge via MCQs immediately after training and at 3 mo follow up 61.6% of nurses reported frequent pulse oximeter and 23.2% reported sometimes using pulse oximeters at follow up. Newborn screening rates were 90.6%-98.0% |
LMIC – lower middle-income country, UMIC – upper middle-income country, CCHD – critical congenital heart defects, SIBEN – Ibero American Society of Neonatology, NICU – neonatal intensive care unit, ROP – retinopathy of prematurity, m – months, d – days, MCQ – multiple choice question
*Stratified by WHO Regions.