Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 22;15(9):e45784. doi: 10.7759/cureus.45784

Table 6. Characteristics of included studies.

ctDNA, circulating tumor DNA; OS, overall survival; MCED, multi-cancer early detection; TEC-Seq, targeted error correction sequencing

Author of the Study Year of Publication Type of Publication Aim of the Study Conclusion
Dang DK et al. [26] 2022 Traditional review To determine the role of ctDNA as a cancer screening tool CtDNA could be better used as a supplemental tool, which could help guide the management of tumors and their prognosis
IA Cree et al. [33] 2017 Systematic review To identify a blood-based tumor marker for non-invasive cancer detection ctDNA has the potential to be considered as a potential biomarker for cancer detection in future
JD Merker et al. [34] 2018 Systematic review Utility of ctDNA in solid tumors No strong evidence is available on the utility of ctNA in clinical practice.
Ocana A et al. [35] 2016 Systematic review Association between ctDNA and overall survival in solid tumors Positive ctDNA assay is associated with worse outcomes
X Chen et al. [36] 2021 Case-control study To determine OS in patients who tested positive for MCED study The outcome of patients with negative MCED was better when compared to those with a positive MCED
X Chen et al. [37] 2020 Longitudinal study Detection of ctDNA using PanSeer, a non-invasive blood test four years before conventional tumor diagnosis PanSeer could successfully detect cancer in asymptomatic individuals four years earlier than standard screening or diagnostic techniques
Schwaederle M et al. [38] 2016 Cross-sectional study The ability of ctDNA to detect tumor mutations and its concordance with tissue biopsies The ability of ctDNA to determine treatment and prognosis
J Phallen et al. [39] 2017 Clinical evaluation study Evaluating the ability of the TEC-Seq technique to detect cfDNA The test is useful in detecting early-stage cancers and assists in determining prognosis
JD Cohen et al. [40] 2018 Clinical evaluation study Evaluating the ability of CancerSEEK, a multi-analyte blood test in tumor detection CancerSEEK was successful in identifying and locating the majority of the tumors
C Fiala et al. [41] 2018 Traditional review Applications of ctDNA in different aspects of cancer management focusing on early cancer detection The sensitivity and specificity of ctDNA in tumor detection are fairly low and are not advisable to implement at the level of clinical practice
M Scarlotta et al. [42] 2019 Traditional review Applications of the biomarkers - ctDNA, tumor cells, extracellular vesicles in the management of tumor All three techniques showed promising results, while ctDNA was superior
AH Ren et al. [43] 2020 Traditional Review Limitations of ctDNA as a tumor marker The limitations of ctDNA are high enough to prompt further research for its implementation in routine care