Table 1.
List of representative stress-tolerant crops developed by genetic modification (GM). OE: overexpression; TSE: tissue-specific expression; COE: co-overexpression.
Crop | GM | Promoter | Gene | Details of the gene | Source | Tolerance trait | Physiological benefit in response to stress | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Barley | OE | 35S | AtAVP1 | H+-pyrophosphatase | Arabidopsis | Salt | In field, higher grain yield and higher shoot biomass | [431] |
Rice | OE | Maize Ubi1 | AtHsp101 | Chaperone | Arabidopsis | Heat | Better growth performance in the recovery phase following the stress | [384] |
Rice | OE | Maize Ubi1 | TaMBF1c | MBF TF | Wheat | Heat | Tolerance during both vegetative and reproductive stages | [369] |
Rice | OE | Maize Ubi1 | OsRab7 | Small GTP-binding protein | Rice | Heat | Higher yield | [432] |
Rice | OE | SNAC3 | NAC TF | Rice | Heat, drought | Better survival rate | [433] | |
Rice | COE | Tissue-specific or stress-dependent | otsA and otsB (Fusion) | Trehalose biosynthetic genes | E. coli | Salt, cold, drought | Sustained plant growth, less photo-oxidative damage, and more favourable mineral balance | [386] |
Rice | OE | ABA-inducible promoter | SAMDC | S-adenosylmethionine decarboxylase | Tritordeum | Salt | Increased seedling growth | [434] |
Rice | OE | 35S | P5CS | Proline synthesis gene | Vigna aconitifolia | Salt | Wild type died after 10 days of salt stress whereas, even after 4 weeks of stress transgenics were capable of flowering and seed-setting | [435] |
Rice | OE | 35S | PpENA1 | Na+ pumping ATPase | Physcomitrella patens | Salt | Higher biomass production | [436] |
Rice | CE | 35S (pyramiding) | SaSRP3-1, SaVHAc1 | Salt Responsive Protein 3-1, Vacuolar H+-ATPase subunit c1 | Spartina alterniflora | Salt | Higher grain yield weight, and improved shoot and root growth | [437] |
Rice | OE | 35S | Gly I, Gly II | Glyoxalase pathway genes | Brassica, Rice | Multiple stress | High shoot and root biomass | [438] |
Rice | OE | Native promoter | SNAC1 | NAC TF | Rice | Drought | In field 22–34% higher seed setting (stress during reproductive stage) | [368] |
Rice | OE | Stress-inducible rd29A promoter | AtDREB1A | AP2/ERF TF | Arabidopsis | Drought | Tolerant during both the vegetative and reproductive stages | [391] |
Rice | TSE | Root specific RCc3 promoter | OsERF71 | AP2/ERF TF | Rice | Drought | 23% to 42% higher grain yield over WT or whole-body OE transgenic lines | [370] |
Rice | OE | PGD1 | OsNAC14 | NAC TF | Rice | Drought | In field higher number of panicle and filling rate | [439] |
Rice | OE | Rice Actin1P/LEA3-1P (stress inducible) | NPK1 | MAPKKK | Tobacco | Drought | In field higher seed setting rate | [374] |
Rice | OE | Rice Actin1P/LEA3-1P (stress inducible) | SOS2 | Serine/threonine kinase | Arabidopsis | Drought | In field higher seed setting rate | [374] |
Rice | OE | rice Actin1P/LEA3-1P (stress inducible) | AtDREB1A | AP2/ERF TF | Arabidopsis | Drought | In field higher seed setting rate | [374] |
Rice | OE | Rice Actin1P/LEA3-1P (stress inducible) | Zat10 | C2H2-EAR zinc finger | Rice | Drought | In field higher seed setting rate | [374] |
Rice | OE | Rice Actin1P/LEA3-1P (stress inducible) | LOS5 | Molybdenum cofactor sulfurase | Arabidopsis | Drought | In field higher seed setting rate | [374] |
Rice | OE | Rice Actin1P | AtNHX1 | Na+/H+ antiporter | Arabidopsis | Drought | In field higher seed setting rate | [374] |
Rice | OE | Maize Ubi1 | OsbZIP23 | bZIP TF | Rice | Salt, drought | Better growth | [440] |
Rice | RNAi | Maize Ubi1 | SQS | Squalene synthase | Maize | Drought | 14–39% higher yield | [441] |
Rice | OE | OsSKIPa | Rice homolog of human Ski-interacting protein | Rice | Drought | Resistant at both vegetative and reproductive stages | [442] | |
Rice | OE | 2X35S | OsLEA3-2 | Late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) proteins | Rice | Salt, drought | Stronger growth performance, recovery after 20 days of drought stress | [443] |
Rice | OE | 35S, drought inducible promoter | OsLEA3-1 | Late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) proteins | Rice | Drought | Higher relative yield (yield under drought stress treatment/yield under normal growth conditions) | [383] |
Rice | OE | 35S | OsIF | Intermediate filament | Rice | Heat, salt | Maintenance of yield | [444] |
Rice | OE | Maize Ubi1 | OsMYB55 | MYB TF | Rice | Heat | Lesser yield reduction | [445] |
Rice | COE | 35S | OsbZIP46CA1, SAPK6 | bZIP TF, ABA-Activated Protein Kinase | Rice | Drought, cold, heat | Higher yield, biomass, spikelet number, and grain number | [446] |
Rice | OE | 35S | RGB1 | Beta subunit of G protein | Rice | Heat, salt | Higher germination rate, root length, shoot length and plant height | [447] |
Rice | OE | Promoter of Rca-a from Oryza meridionalis | Rubisco activase | Rubisco activase | Oryza australiensis | Heat | Higher yield (stress during vegetative stage) | [448] |
Rice | COE | Rice Cab promoter | Rubisco, Rubisco activase | Rubisco, Rubisco activase | Rice, maize | Heat | Higher biomass and improved photosynthesis | [449] |
Rice | OE | Actin | miRNA319 | miRNA | Rice | Cold | Increased leaf width and vein number, and better acclimation | [378] |
Rice | OE | 35S | TERF2 | AP2/ERF TF | Tomato | Cold | Better survival rate | [450] |
Rice | OE | COLD1 | Regulator of G-protein signalling | Rice | Cold | Enhanced chilling tolerance | [451] | |
Rice | OE | Ubiquitin | MYBS3 | MYB TF | Rice | Cold | In field no yield penalty | [452] |
Rice | OE | Ubiquitin | OsMYB3R-2 | MYB TF | Rice | Cold | Higher cold resistance, higher levels of proline | [453] |
Rice & Tomato (small fruit species) | OE | 35S | ERECTA | LRR-RLK | Arabidopsis | Heat | Increased biomass and yield | [454] |
Rice | OE | OsMADS57 | MADS-box TF | Rice | Cold | Maintenance rice tiller growth | [455] | |
Wheat | OE | Ubiquitin | betA | Choline dehydrogenase | E. coli | Salt | In field higher grain yields, more tillers, and higher germination rates | [456] |
Wheat | OE | pIND | HaHB4 (mutated) | Homeodomain-leucine zipper I family gene | Helianthus annus | Drought | In field higher spikelet numbers per spike, tillers per plant, and fertile florets per plant | [457] |
Wheat | OE | Barley Dhn8s | TaHsfC2a | HSF TF | Wheat | Heat | Enhanced thermotolerance | [458] |
Wheat | OE | Maize Ubi1 | TaFER-5B | Ferritin gene | Wheat | Heat | Enhanced stress tolerance | [459] |
Wheat | OE | Hordein B1 promoter | HvSUT1 | Sucrose Transporter | Barley | Heat | Better performance for many yield-related traits and enhanced sucrose transport | [460] |
Wheat | OE | Maize Ubi1 | EF-Tu | Elongation factor | Maize | Heat | Reduced heat injury to photosynthetic membranes (thylakoids), and enhanced rate of CO2 fixation | [461] |
Wheat | OE | Drought inducible Barley HVA1s | Hsf6a | HSF TF | Wheat | Heat | Enhanced thermotolerance | [462] |
Wheat | OE | 35S | AtWRKY30 | WRKY TF | Arabidopsis | Heat, drought | Improved biomass and photosynthesis | [463] |
Maize | OE | Rd29A | ZmbZIP4 | bZIP TF | Maize | Salt, drought | Enhanced root development and ABA synthesis | [464] |
Maize | CRISPR | Maize GOS2 | ARGOS8 | Negative regulator of ethylene signalling | Maize | Drought | In field increased grain yield by five bushels per acre (stress exposure during flowering) | [465] |
Maize | OE | 35S | NPK1 | MAPKKK | Tobacco | Drought | No yield loss under stress | [375] |
Maize | OE | Novel promoter | LOS5 | Molybdenum cofactor sulfurase | Arabidopsis | Drought | Increased root system development and biomass yield after re-watering | [466] |
Maize | OE | Maize Ubi1 | OsMYB55 | MYB TF | Rice | Heat, drought | Higher plant biomass and reduced leaf damage | [467] |
Cotton | OE | AhCMO | Choline monooxygenase | Atriplex hortensis | Salt | Higher seed yield | [385] | |
Cotton | COE | AtNHX1, AtAVP1 | Na+/H+ antiporter, H+-pyrophosphatase | Arabidopsis | Salt, drought | 24% and 35% higher fibre yield under low-irrigation and dryland conditions, respectively | [468] | |
Cotton | OE | 35S | AtAVP1 | H+-pyrophosphatase | Arabidopsis | Salt, drought | In field 20% higher yield under dry-land conditions | [469] |
Cotton | OE | 35S | GhDof1 | DOF TF | Cotton | Salt, cold | Higher oil content and reduced protein in seeds | [470] |
Tomato | CE | 35S | PgNHX1, AVP1 | Na+/H+ antiporter, H+-pyrophosphatase | Pennisetum glaucum, Arabidopsis | Salt | Better survival rate | [471] |
Tomato | OE | 35S | SbNHXLP | Na+/H+ antiporter-like protein | Sorghum bicolor | Salt | Higher fruit yield | [381] |
Tomato | OE | APX (cytosolic) | Ascorbate peroxidase | Pea | Heat | Enhanced tolerance to heat stress in lab and field | [382] | |
Tomato | OE | 35S | SAMDC | S-adenosyl-l-methionine decarboxylase | Saccharomyces cerevisiae | Heat | Improved the efficiency of CO2 assimilation | [472] |
Tomato | OE | 35S | ShDHN | Dehydrin | Wild tomato | Cold, drought | Better survival rate | [473] |
Tomato | OE | Stress inducible AtRd29A | BoCRP1 | Novel cold-responsive protein1 | Brassica oleracea | Cold | Higher seed germination, increased root length, reduced membrane damage and increased accumulation of osmo-protectants | [474] |
Tomato | OE | 35S | LeCOR413PM2 | Cold-regulated gene | Tomato | Cold | Reduced damage to cell membrane, accumulation of ROS, and photoinhibition of PSII, but also maintain high activity of antioxidant enzymes and content of osmotic regulators | [475] |