Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 5;24(18):13680. doi: 10.3390/ijms241813680

Table 3.

GRADE criteria for risk of bias evaluation. Green: No Risk of Bias; Yellow: Maybe Risk of Bias; Red: High Risk of Bias.

Reference Methodological Quality Directness of Evidence Heterogeneity Precision of Effect Estimates Publication Bias Level of Evidence Recommendation for Use
Cattaneo et al. [51] Moderate Moderate
Mitano et al. [52] Moderate Moderate
Vogt et al. [41] Moderate Moderate
Araos et al. [48] Low Low
Nguyen et al. [53] Moderate Moderate
Saji et al. [54] Moderate Low
Qian et al. [55] Moderate Moderate
Zhuang et al. [50] Moderate Moderate
Haran et al. [56] Moderate Low
Liu et al. [49] Moderate Moderate
Saji et al. [57] Moderate Low
Ren et al. [58] Moderate Moderate
Liu et al. [59] Moderate Moderate
Scheperjans et al. [60] Moderate Moderate
Cerroni et al. [61] Moderate Moderate
Unger et al. [62] Moderate Moderate