Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 3;15(9):2272. doi: 10.3390/pharmaceutics15092272

Table 1.

Possibilities and technical characteristics of the optical methods used in vivo/ex vivo to determine skin penetration.

Optical Method Imaging
Method
(2D/3D)
Screening Depth, µm Lateral/Axial
Resolution
Penetration of Non-Particulate Substances Penetration of Particulate Substances Possibility to
Quantify the Substances Used
FCLSM in vivo Yes ≈100 µm <1 µm/
<5 µm
Yes 1,2
(low sensitivity)
Yes 1,2
(low sensitivity)
Yes
[73]
ex vivo Yes
RCLSM in vivo Yes ≈150 µm No Yes
(low sensitivity)
No
ex vivo Yes
2PT-AF in vivo Yes ≈150 µm <1 µm/
<2 µm
Yes 2
(low sensitivity)
Yes 2
(low sensitivity)
No
ex vivo Yes
2PT-FLIM in vivo Yes Yes 3
(high sensitivity)
Yes 3
(high sensitivity)
ex vivo Yes
SHG in vivo Yes No Yes
(high sensitivity)
ex vivo Yes
2PT-CARS in vivo Yes Yes
(low sensitivity) 4
Yes
(low sensitivity) 4
ex vivo Yes
3PT in vivo Yes <900 µm <1 µm/
<2 µm
No No
No
ex vivo Yes
CRM in vivo No 5 ≈50 µm <5 µm Yes
(high sensitivity)
Yes
(high sensitivity)
Yes
[207,209]
ex vivo Yes
SERS in vivo No 5 ≈50 µm <5 µm No 6 Yes 7
(high sensitivity)
No
ex vivo Yes
SRS in vivo Yes ≈150 µm <2 µm Yes
(high sensitivity) 4
Yes
(high sensitivity) 4
Yes
[160]
ex vivo Yes
OCT in vivo Yes <2 mm <2 µm/
<5 µm
No Yes
(low sensitivity) 8
No
ex vivo Yes

1 The applied substances should be inherently fluorescent or covalently bound with a fluorescent dye; 2 The applied substances should have intense AF whose intensity exceeds skin AF; 3 The applied substances should have AF lifetimes that are different from the AF lifetimes of the skin; 4 Sensitivity will be higher for substances whose Raman spectrum do not overlap with the skin spectrum; 5 Only 1D (z-stack point measurements) imaging is possible; 6 Non-particulate substances can be identified with SERS-labeled detection microneedles or with TERS (low-invasively on tape strips); 7 Only the detection of SERS-active nanostructures is possible; 8 The higher the density of target substances, the higher the contrast of OCT images.