Table 1.
The basic characteristics of the included literatures.
| Document source | Sample size | Male/female/case | Average age | Average course of disease | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T/C | T | C | T | C | T | C | Intervention | Course of treatment per wk | Outcome index | Adverse reaction | |
| Li Dongmei 2023[4] | 49/49 | 27/22 | 26/23 | 58.60 ± 5.02 | 58.65 ± 4.78 | 7.60 ± 2.53 | 7.62 ± 2.56 | LW + CT | 8 | ③ | Report |
| Ma Yaping 2015[5] | 74/74 | 39/35 | 30/44 | 57.00 ± 5.80 | 54.00 ± 5.80 | 5.70 ± 1.50 | 5.20 ± 1.70 | LW + CT | 36 | ② | Report |
| Liu Chaoju 2012[6] | 30/30 | 17/13 | 16/14 | 63.75 ± 5.85 | 62.75 ± 5.75 | – | – | LW + CT | 8 | ③ | Unreported |
| Li Xuexia 2011[7] | 30/30 | 18/12 | 19/11 | 52.73 ± 12.61 | 52.98 ± 13.46 | 8.92 ± 3.63 | 7.29 ± 4.21 | LW + CT | 12 | ① | Unreported |
| Xie Jiajia 2011[8] | 30/30 | 17/13 | 16/14 | 50.70 ± 5.32 | 51.20 ± 6.13 | 12.30 ± 2.80 | 12.10 ± 3.50 | LW + CT | 12 | ②④ | Unreported |
| Zhou Junping 2021[9] | 34/34 | 18/16 | 19/15 | 67.80 ± 3.50 | 67.24 ± 3.15 | 7.15 ± 1.12 | 7.20 ± 1.15 | LW + CT | 4 | ③④ | Report |
| Feng Sanhua 2015[10] | 60/60 | 35/25 | 33/27 | 46.30 ± 3.80 | 46.70 ± 4.00 | 8.30 ± 1.50 | 8.40 ± 1.70 | LW + CT | 12 | ①④ | Unreported |
| Li Yun 2019[11] | 52/52 | 31/21 | 30/22 | 58.94 ± 8.75 | 59.23 ± 8.84 | 8.61 ± 5.29 | 8.52 ± 5.33 | LW + CT | 8 | ①③④ | Unreported |
| Jia Fan 2017[12] | 65/65 | 33/32 | 35/30 | 52.47 ± 2.85 | 52.07 ± 2.73 | – | – | JG + CT | – | ②③④ | Unreported |
| Hou Cuirong 2017[13] | 45/45 | 24/21 | 23/22 | 61.38 ± 10.36 | 61.84 ± 10.46 | 8.31 ± 2.16 | 8.62 ± 2.32 | JG + CT | – | ②③④ | Unreported |
| Sun Hongyun 2018[14] | 33/31 | 18/15 | 17/14 | 55.60 ± 11.20 | 54.80 ± 11.40 | – | – | JG + CT | – | ②③④ | Unreported |
| Jiang Bin 2020[15] | 60/60 | 35/25 | 34/26 | 54.65 ± 5.50 | 55.20 ± 5.24 | 3.26 ± 1.43 | 3.50 ± 1.51 | JG + CT | 4 | ②④ | Unreported |
| Zhang Jingzu 2019[16] | 118/118 | 68/50 | 67/51 | 53.10 ± 3.10 | 53.70 ± 3.10 | 3.20 ± 0.30 | 3.10 ± 0.30 | JG + CT | 4 | ②④ | Unreported |
| Li Caijing 2018[17] | 40/40 | 24/16 | 23/17 | 66.30 ± 6.20 | 66.20 ± 6.30 | 6.90 ± 1.20 | 6.80 ± 1.30 | JG + CT | 4 | ①②④ | Unreported |
| Wang Zheng 2019[18] | 43/41 | 29/14 | 28/13 | 57.60 ± 7.90 | 57.20 ± 8.10 | 9.50 ± 2.20 | 9.10 ± 2.40 | JG + CT | 12 | ② | Report |
| He Jianjun 2016[19] | 39/39 | 24/15 | 22/17 | 55.00 ± 4.80 | 55.10 ± 5.00 | 3.40 ± 0.90 | 3.20 ± 0.70 | JG + CT | 4 | ①②④ | Report |
| Liu Dongmei 2022[20] | 62/62 | 31/31 | 32/30 | 54.03 ± 3.39 | 53.96 ± 3.28 | – | – | JG + CT | 4 | ②③④ | Unreported |
| Tan Jian 2014[21] | 22/21 | 12/10 | 11/10 | 59.72士3.17 | 61.32 ± 2.27 | – | – | LW + CT | 8 | ②③④ | Unreported |
| Sun Guisheng 2012[22] | 35/35 | 20/15 | 21/14 | 57.33 ± 11.54 | 58.94 ± 11.36 | 3.35 ± 1.23 | 3.14 ± 1.05 | JG + CT | 4 | ②③ | Unreported |
| Zhang Hongxia 2009[23] | 35/33 | 18/17 | 17/16 | 61.98 ± 5.69 | 62.06 ± 5.52 | 7.93 ± 1.65 | 7.96 ± 0.96 | JS + CT | 4 | ①②③ | Unreported |
| Deng Cui 2019[24] | 34/34 | 22/12 | 21/13 | – | – | 7.66 ± 2.39 | 7.43 ± 2.46 | JS + CT | 8 | ①②④ | Unreported |
| Xiong Manqi 2003[25] | 40/38 | 23/17 | 20/18 | 46.35 ± 4.17 | 43.58 ± 4.16 | 4.32 ± 4.21 | 4.27 ± 2.15 | JS + CT | 6 | ②③④ | Unreported |
| Luo Yifeng 2021[26] | 25/25 | 14/11 | 13/12 | 49.22 ± 3.17 | 49.18 ± 3.26 | – | – | JS + CT | 8 | ②④ | Unreported |
| Li Minji 2018[27] | 43/43 | 24/19 | 25/18 | 47.24 ± 9.45 | 48.62 ± 9.78 | 5.87 ± 3.87 | 5.27 ± 4.14 | JS + CT | 8 | ① | Unreported |
| Li Shuang 2020[28] | 50/50 | 26/24 | 27/23 | 55.10 ± 9.40 | 54.60 ± 8.90 | 10.20 ± 1.10 | 9.80 ± 0.90 | JS + CT | 8 | ③④ | Unreported |
| Wang Yongzheng 2015[29] | 30/30 | 14/16 | 12/18 | 59.10 ± 9.10 | 53.50 ± 9.50 | – | – | LW + CT | – | ①④ | Unreported |
| Xie Long 2019[30] | 78/77 | 45/33 | 44/33 | 61.47 ± 8.46 | 61.46 ± 8.44 | 12.60 ± 5.47 | 12.58 ± 5.46 | LW + CT | 8 | ②④ | Unreported |
| Xu Yingbo 2021[31] | 50/50 | 28/22 | 30/20 | 39.21 ± 2.74 | 38.83 ± 2.96 | – | – | JS + CT | 3 | ③ | Unreported |
| Ma Jiaping 2020[32] | 41/41 | 24/17 | 20/21 | 64.10 ± 2.30 | 63.20 ± 2.40 | – | – | ZB + CT | 4 | ①②③ | Unreported |
| Cao Zhanhua 2013[33] | 36/36 | 22/14 | 20/16 | 52.10 ± 3.70 | 51.70 ± 3.20 | 6.10 ± 2.40 | 6.30 ± 2.60 | LW + CT | 8 | ②④ | Report |
| Ge Lijun 2013[34] | 35/30 | 22/13 | 16/14 | 57.00 ± 4.20 | 58.00 ± 5.10 | LW + CT | 8 | ①②④ | Unreported | ||
| Yuan Feng 2016[35] | 36/35 | 18/18 | 18/17 | 54.40 ± 5.50 | 54.2 ± 5.8 | 3.70 ± 0.80 | 3.60 ± 0.80 | LW + CT | 8 | ①③④ | Unreported |
| Shi Aimei 2022[36] | 98/98 | 73/25 | 68/30 | 62.78 ± 8.51 | 58.78 ± 7.32 | 8.18 ± 3.13 | 7.63 ± 2.25 | ZB + CT | 4 | ③④ | Report |
| Liu Mengzhen 2013[37] | 28/28 | 15/13 | 18/10 | 53.60 ± 5.10 | 54.50 ± 6.20 | 9.40 ± 1.80 | 9.90 ± 1.90 | ZB + CT | 8 | ①④ | Unreported |
| Liang Xuefang 2012[38] | 27/27 | 17/10 | 18/9 | 57.80 ± 15.30 | 58.20 ± 14.80 | 11.20 ± 8.60 | 10.90 ± 8.50 | JG + CT | 4 | ②③ | Unreported |
| Li Fuping 2011[39] | 15/10 | 9/6 | 6/4 | 53.10 ± 10.20 | 59.20 ± 12.60 | 9.33 ± 3.79 | 8.25 ± 5.16 | LW + CT | 12 | ①③④ | Unreported |
| Wang Yijun 2013[40] | 33/30 | 18/15 | 16/14 | 60.20 ± 5.10 | 59.90 ± 4.80 | 12.50 ± 1.20 | l1.90 ± 0.690 | LW + CT | 4 | ① | Report |
| Wang Jiuxiang 2015[41] | 50/50 | 26/24 | 22/28 | 65.24 ± 8.63 | 64.96 ± 7.65 | 11.56 ± 1.22 | 10.45 ± 1.44 | LW + CT | 8 | ①③ | Report |
| Wen Pingfan 2011[42] | 20/20 | 9/11 | 10/10 | 52.50 ± 11.50 | 50.10 ± 10.70 | 12.50 ± 4.00 | 11.00 ± 5.00 | LW + CT | 4 | ②③ | Unreported |
| Yi Yuanyue 2016[43] | 34/34 | 16/18 | 17/17 | 53.00 ± 1.40 | 52.00 ± 1.40 | – | – | LW + CT | – | ②③ | Unreported |
| Chen Bing 2009[44] | 34/34 | 18/16 | 20/14 | 46.83 ± 13.25 | 44.29 ± 14.12 | – | – | LW + CT | – | ①③④ | Unreported |