Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 14;5:ojad084. doi: 10.1093/asjof/ojad084

Table 2.

Readability and Reliability of the Responses of Large Language Models

Model Prompts Readability Suitability
Flesch reading ease score Flesch–Kincaid grade level Coleman–Liau index DISCERN score
ChatGPT (Open AI) Correcting internal valve dysfunction 42.98 9.56 15 42
Correcting external valve collapse 41.43 9.69 16 42
Correcting caudal septal dislocation 33.97 10.59 6 44
Managing turbinate hypertrophy 13.27 13.62 12 41
Managing tip support after submucous resection 49.02 8.46 18 43
When to do nasal bone fractures in rhinoplasty 45.42 8.99 12.17 41
Mean (SD) 37.68 (±12.96) 10.15 (±1.84) 12.00 (5.10) 42.17 (±1.17)
Google's BARD Correcting internal valve dysfunction 61.26 6.98 10 44
Correcting external valve collapse 61.63 7.25 9 47
Correcting caudal septal dislocation 36.08 11.27 13 42
Managing turbinate hypertrophy 23.03 15.2 14 48
Managing tip support after submucous resection 54.89 8.15 9 47
When to do nasal bone fractures in rhinoplasty 47.91 9.4 10 50
Mean (SD) 47.47 (±15.32) 9.71 (±3.12) 10.83 (±2.14) 46.33 (±2.88)
Bing AI(Microsoft) Correcting internal valve dysfunction 25.95 20 16 39
Correcting external valve collapse 10.17 20.86 14 30
Correcting caudal septal dislocation 14.41 19.2 14 36
Managing turbinate hypertrophy 4.89 18.37 19 38
Managing tip support after submucous resection NA 25.34 14 NA
When to do nasal bone fractures in rhinoplasty 36.03 13.56 12 46
Mean (SD) 18.29 (±12.59) 18.25 (±4.84) 12.00 (5.10) 35.75 (±4.03)

NA, not applicable; SD, standard deviation.