Abstract
This study replicates from a cross-sectional study about how young Latina teen viewers identify with and socially compare to teen mothers on MTV’s Teen Mom over time. Identification and social comparison effects on attitudes toward teen pregnancy were assessed among the same group of Latina teen viewers at two different time points approximately one year apart. Results determined that upward social comparison and identification were associated with positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy in eighth grade, whereas downward social comparison was associated with negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy in ninth grade. Implications for teen mom reality programming audiences are discussed.
Keywords: identification, social comparison, attitudes, Teen Mom
Teen pregnancy remains a major public health issue in the United States, despite the recent decline in rates of teen pregnancy (Martin et al., 2021). Teen parenthood as a whole remains associated with a variety of negative outcomes, including lower education among teen mothers and lower employment income among teen fathers (Hendrick & Maslowsky, 2019; Johansen et al., 2020).
Teen pregnancy has also been portrayed in the media in various ways with reality programming in particular having a documented impact on teen attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors (e.g., Martins & Jensen, 2014). Teen mom reality programming portrays the pregnancy and parenthood experiences of actual teen parents but rarely shows the real world consequences associated with it (e.g., Martins et al., 2016). This is especially the case with the MTV program Teen Mom, which has been one of the most popular programs of this reality television subgenre (Levine, 2021), and has a target audience highly at risk for teen pregnancy.
Understanding the psychological processes of identification with and social comparison to media characters has been of interest to media scholars for several decades (e.g., Cohen, 2001; Mares & Cantor, 1992) and can offer insight into the effects reality television programming, such as MTV’s Teen Mom, can have on attitudes. Researchers have examined the influence that identification and social comparison can have on vulnerable populations, such as adolescents (e.g., Behm-Morawitz et al., 2019). In our previous work we found that young women who identify with and upwardly compare to the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom are more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy (Lewis et al., 2020). The current study serves as a replication of that previous work by examining whether or not these identification and social comparison effects are sustained over time. We assessed a second time-point with the same group of viewers from the previous study, capturing the transition to high school (a critical developmental period; Neild, 2009). We also extend earlier work by exploring the effect of birthplace (i.e., US mainland, Spanish-speaking country or US territory) on attitudes toward teen pregnancy.
Literature Review
There is a growing body of literature that has established the relationship between exposure to teen mom reality programming and attitudes toward teen pregnancy (e.g., Martins & Jensen, 2014; Moyer-Gusé et al., 2020). This relationship can be broadly summarized as follows. First, teen mom reality programming, especially programs in the Teen Mom franchise (e.g., Teen Mom, Teen Mom 2), rarely show the real negative consequences of teen pregnancy (e.g., Martins et al., 2016). Second, viewers who have the weakest connection to the teen mothers on these programs tend to have more negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy, while viewers who have the strongest connection to the teen mothers on these programs tend to have more positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy (e.g., Behm-Morawitz et al., 2019). Most recently, Lewis et al. (2020) proposed two social psychological processes as driving the connection between young viewers and teen mothers on teen mom reality programming: identification and social comparison.
Identification is defined as imagining oneself as being a media character and sharing that character’s perspectives (Cohen, 2001; Oatley, 1995). Hoffner and Buchanan (2005) described it as a process of putting oneself in the place of a media character and experiencing the character’s action through vicarious participation. Identification is rooted in developmental processes and requires the sharing of another’s perspectives (i.e., perspective taking), which is an ability that increases during adolescence (Selman, 1980; Van Der Graaff et al., 2014). Identification with others both in the media and in the real world are an important component of socialization and the formation of personal and social identity (Cohen, 2001; Mead, 1934). It is helpful to think of identification with media characters as one of vicarious experience and heightened connection – and media producers are highly invested in stimulating this process (e.g., through audio/visual and editing techniques). Importantly, Moyer-Gusé (2008) proposed that those who highly identify with media characters are less likely to question the characters’ decision making and behavior. As criticism of the character decreases, likelihood of imitating the character increases. As this relates to teen mom reality programming, Lewis et al. (2020) found that young viewers who identified with the teen mothers on Teen Mom were more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy – in line with Moyer-Gusé’s (2008) theorization.
Beyond identification, the directional processes of social comparison (e.g., looking up to, looking down on) the pregnant/teen mothers featured in Teen Mom are also likely to elicit certain attitudes toward teen pregnancy. Social comparison is driven by the fundamental need to make accurate evaluations about the self (Festinger, 1954), where the direction of the comparison determines the impact on attitudes. Individuals directionally compare themselves to others, in real life and through media, where they can look up to better off others (upward comparison) or look down on those who are worse off (downward comparison). Upward social comparison is associated with self-improvement, or wanting to be more like the comparison target, whereas downward social comparisons are associated with self-enhancement, or wanting to distance oneself from the comparison target (Gibbons & Buunk, 1999). Adolescence, in particular, marks a transitional period where individuals are likely to use information from their social environment in order to evaluate themselves and can do so via social comparison (van der Aar et al., 2018; Dijkstra et al., 2008). These comparisons serve to achieve more accurate self-concepts. Thus, looking up to teen mothers featured in Teen Mom is driven by self-improvement and is expected to result in a more positive attitude about teen pregnancy, whereas looking down on the featured teen mothers is driven by self-enhancement and is expected to result in a more negative attitude (e.g., Wills, 1981).
A key factor shaping identification and directional processes of social comparison is ethnicity and culture (e.g., Tajfel, 2010). Cultural norms help shape viewers’ values based on the outcomes they observe teen mothers experience in Teen Mom. Unfortunately, many of the outcomes typically depicted run counter to the real world experiences of teen parenthood with the featured teen mothers going on to achieve multiple life goals, including graduating high school, acquiring their own apartments and homes, and co-parenting with their partners (e.g., Hendrick & Maslowsky, 2019; Martins et al., 2016). Young viewers may aspire to obtain these same outcomes and hence look up to these teen mothers when they are depicted as achieving them. However, the featured teens may also encounter negative experiences centered on conflict and absence of a social life, which can instigate downward social comparisons from viewers – who may look down on the teen mothers’ situation and see themselves as better off. Lewis et al. (2020) found support for upward social comparisons to teen mothers on Teen Mom occurring among young, Latina viewers, but not downward social comparisons.
A study of Latina teens offers opportunity to explore whether birthplace is a proxy for the cultural factors that influence identification and social comparison processes. Both adolescent and young adult Latinas born outside the US report more positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy than those born in the US (Lewis et al., 2020; Rodriguez et al., 2020). However, it is unclear if birthplace influences attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time.
A better understanding of birthplace, identification, and social comparison effects on attitudes about teen pregnancy is important because US teen birth rates for Hispanic/Latina teens remain high relative to their non-Hispanic same age peers, despite declines in overall US teen birth rates (Martin et al., 2018). Moreover, Latinos represent the largest growing ethnic and cultural subgroup within the US (Noe-Bustamante et al., 2020).
Thus, this study tests whether we can replicate our previous cross-sectional findings regarding young Latinas’ identification with and social comparison to teen mothers featured on Teen Mom and their effect on attitudes about teen pregnancy (Lewis et al., 2020) using a longitudinal design. As in the previous study, we argue that those who strongly identify with the teen mothers on Teen Mom should demonstrate positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy because identification is associated with shared goals with the characters (Oatley, 1995) and less criticism of their decision making (Moyer-Gusé, 2008). In a similar vein, those who upwardly compare to the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom should also have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy, as upward social comparison can be associated with character aspiration and inspiration (Lewis, 2021). We expect that these processes and their associated effects on attitudes toward teen pregnancy will hold over time. Regarding downward social comparison, viewers who see the teen mothers on Teen Mom as worse off than them should have more negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy (Behm-Morawitz et al., 2019). However, because this hypothesis went unsupported in the first study (Lewis et al., 2020), we propose it here as a research question. Similarly, we explore the effect that birthplace (as a proxy for cultural influence) may have on attitudes about teen pregnancy in a second research question.
H1: Viewers who strongly identify with the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom will be more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time.
H2: Viewers who look up to the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom will be more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time.
RQ1: Will viewers who look down on the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom be more likely to have negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time?
RQ2: Does birthplace influence attitudes toward teen pregnancy in viewers exposed to Teen Mom over time?
Method
Survey data were collected from a larger efficacy trial on an early pregnancy prevention intervention called Mighty Girls3 at two different time points (eighth grade and ninth grade). Results from the eighth grade assessment alone were published in a previous effort (Lewis et al., 2020). The current study assesses the change in attitudes from the first (eighth grade) to the second time point (ninth grade). As in the first study, the current analyses were limited to respondents who reported having heard of Teen Mom and watching it at least sometimes. Participants were Latina girls enrolled in public middle schools in Miami-Dade County (Florida) with a Hispanic enrollment greater than or equal to 60%, and 50% or more of students qualifying for reduced/free lunch. Low income level was reflected by 85% of the sample qualifying for reduced/free lunch.
Procedure
All procedures were approved by an Institutional Review Board (University of Miami). Original recruitment took place during in-school assemblies of girls meeting study criteria. Study staff disseminated information packets that contained parental consent forms for potential participants. Additional study packets were made available in the school office and left with school staff. Completed study packets that contained signed parental consent forms were turned in at school and later picked up by study staff. Afterwards, study staff contacted parents of participants by phone to review and verify the elements of informed consent, answer any questions, and schedule participants for survey completion. Survey items related to Teen Mom viewing, pregnancy attitudes, identification, and upward and downward social comparison were included at both time points (e.g., in eighth and ninth grade assessments). Data collection occurred electronically on Chromebook computers with completion time varying from 20 to 45 minutes depending on reading ability. Participants received a $15 gift card and a community service hour for each survey they completed. Informed child assent was obtained at school prior to any of the study’s activities. For additional details about recruitment and study participation, see Lewis et al. (2020).
Participants
Of the 552 girls that enrolled in the efficacy trial in eighth grade, 204 had heard of the reality television program Teen Mom and reported watching it at least sometimes. The majority of these 204 participants were born in the United States (US) mainland (74%) and the age of this subsample ranged from 12 to 16 (M = 13.31, SD = 0.75). By ninth grade, 48 participants had either dropped out of the study or had missing data, leaving a final N of 156 for participants who completed measures of study variables at both time points (eighth grade and ninth grade). The most commonly reported reasons for attrition were life demands (e.g., parent needed the child at home to watch younger siblings) or lack of interest. Attrition also arose when a participant’s phone was disconnected, she did not return phone calls, was no longer enrolled at the study school, or entered foster care. Pregnancy at study schools was assessed but school personnel did not report any pregnancies occurring among eighth graders at their schools.
Predictor Variables
Identification.
Three items were adapted from Basil’s (1996) identification with celebrities’ scale to measure identification. They were answered using a Likert type scale from 1 (Strongly Disagree) to 4 (Strongly Agree). The items included: “I like the girls on Teen Mom,” “I can easily relate to the girls on Teen Mom,” and “I could see myself being good friends with the girls on Teen Mom.” These items were summed and averaged to create an identification score for the two different time points in eighth (M = 1.57, SD = 0.65) and ninth grades (M = 1.63, SD = 0.61). Cronbach’s alpha for this measure was .75 at both time points.
Social comparison.
Two items were used to assess directional social comparisons to the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom. Response options used a Likert type scale ranging from 1 (Strongly Disagree) to 4 (Strongly Agree). Upward comparison was measured with the following item: “I look up to the girls on Teen Mom” (Grade 8: M = 1.33, SD = 0.60; Grade 9: M = 1.34, SD = 0.63). Downward social comparison was measured with the following item: “I feel sorry for the girls on Teen Mom” (Grade 8: M = 2.85, SD = 0.98; Grade 9: M = 2.81, SD = 0.96). These items were not significantly correlated at either time point, r(156) = −.004 to −.03, p ≥ .72.
Birthplace.
Birthplace identified those who had been born in mainland US (76%) and those born in a Spanish-speaking country or US territory (24%). Of those born outside the US, 58% reported Cuba as their birthplace, 8% reported the Dominican Republic, 8% reported Nicaragua, and 5% or fewer each reported Colombia, Honduras, Peru, Venezuela, Spain, Costa Rica, Canada, and Puerto Rico.
Outcome Variable
Attitudes toward teen pregnancy.
Four items were adapted from Brückner et al.’s (2004) attitudes toward pregnancy scale and measured on a Likert type scale of 1 (Strongly Disagree) to 4 (Strongly Agree). The items included: “If I got pregnant before I finished high school, it would be embarrassing for me,” If I got pregnant before I finished high school, it would be embarrassing for my family,” “Getting pregnant right now is one of the worst things that could happen to me,” and “Getting pregnant in high school would make it hard for me to achieve my dreams.” For ease in interpretation, these items were reverse coded, summed, and averaged to create a single score for both time points where a higher score was associated with more positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy (Grade 8: M = 1.67, SD = 0.74; Grade 9: M = 1.68, SD = 0.71). Cronbach’s alpha for this measure was .82 to .83.
Analytical Strategy
This study used a linear mixed-effects model to analyze repeated measures data over the two time points (eighth and ninth grade). The predictors of identification, upward comparison, downward comparison, and birthplace were entered as fixed factors with attitudes toward teen pregnancy as the outcome variable.4 The random effect of the variance of the intercept was estimated along with the repeated effect of the variance in residuals for each time point. Means, standard deviations, and zero-order correlations for the variables of interest at both time points are reported in Table 1 and Table 2.
Table 1.
Means, Standard Deviations, and Zero-Order Correlations for Variables in Eighth Grade
| M | SD | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Birthplace | - | - | ||||
| 2. Identification | 1.57 | 0.65 | .06 | |||
| 3. Upward | 1.33 | 0.60 | −.02 | .59** | ||
| 4. Downward | 2.85 | 0.98 | .03 | .02 | −.004 | |
| 5. Attitudes | 1.67 | 0.74 | −.16* | .21* | .20* | −.16 |
Note: N = 156.
p < .01.
p < .05.
Table 2.
Means, Standard Deviations, and Zero-Order Correlations for Variables in Ninth Grade
| M | SD | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Birthplace | - | - | ||||
| 2. Identification | 1.63 | 0.61 | −.12 | |||
| 3. Upward | 1.34 | 0.63 | −.08 | .62** | ||
| 4. Downward | 2.81 | 0.96 | −.02 | .05 | −.03 | |
| 5. Attitudes | 1.68 | 0.71 | −.20* | .10 | .20* | −.32** |
Note: N = 156.
p < .01.
p < .05.
Results
H1 suggested that viewers who strongly identified with the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom would be more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time. As seen in Table 3, H1 was not supported: Identification did not influence attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time (t = 1.18, p = .24).
Table 3.
Mixed-effects Regression on Attitudes Toward Teen Pregnancy Over Time
| Estimate | SE | df | CI | t | p | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (Intercept) | 1.98 | .18 | 278.61 | 1.62 – 2.34 | 10.94 | < .001 |
| Birthplace | −.31 | .10 | 149.87 | −.52 – −.11 | −3.00 | .003 |
| Identification | .09 | .08 | 302.19 | −.06 – .24 | 1.18 | .24 |
| Upward | .13 | .08 | 280.31 | −.02 – .28 | 1.77 | .08 |
| Downward | −.14 | .04 | 302.99 | −.22 – −.07 | −3.61 | < .001 |
Note. N = 156. Reference category for Birthplace (1 = US Born)
H2 posited that viewers who looked up to the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom would be more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time. Upward social comparison approached but did not reach significance in predicting more positive attitudes toward pregnancy over time (t = 1.77, p = .08; see Table 3). Hence, H2 was not supported.
RQ1 asked whether viewers who looked down on the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom would be more likely to have negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time. Downward social comparison was associated with more negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy over time (t = −3.61, p < .001; see Table 3) in this longitudinal analysis.
RQ2 explored whether birthplace influenced attitudes toward teen pregnancy in viewers exposed to Teen Mom over time. Those who were born in the US mainland had more negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy than those born in a Spanish-speaking country or US territory (t = −3.00, p < .001; see Table 3).
Discussion
The goal of this study was to determine whether we could replicate previous findings regarding the identification and social comparison processes associated with reality television cast members (i.e., teen mothers featured on Teen Mom) using a longitudinal design. Contrary to our previous study (Lewis et al., 2020), the effects for identification and upward comparisons as being associated with positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy among eighth grade Latinas did not hold up over time. Instead, we found that downward comparisons to teen mothers featured on Teen Mom were associated with negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy among this same group of Latinas approximately one year later (ninth grade).
It is first important to consider the current findings in light of the results from the previous study. When the participants were in eighth grade, those who highly identified with the teen mothers featured on Teen Mom were more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy. It was argued that for this vulnerable population, they were more likely to share the teen mothers’ perspectives (Oatley, 1995) and less likely to question the teen mothers’ behavior (Moyer-Gusé, 2008). Similarly, those who upwardly compared to the teen mothers were also more likely to have positive attitudes toward teen pregnancy. It was suggested that upward comparisons leant to assimilative effects, or a desire to be more like the teen mothers (Gibbons & Buunk, 1999). These findings were concerning; a population that was extremely vulnerable to the risks of teen pregnancy was found to perceive teen pregnancy, via identification and upward social comparison, in a positive light. Furthermore, in that same study, downward social comparisons to the teen mothers demonstrated no measureable effects on attitudes toward teen pregnancy at all.
In the current study, identification and comparison processes among the same Latina viewers shifted, lending to more encouraging results. Downward social comparisons to the teen mothers were associated with negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy, whereas identification and upward social comparisons were no longer associated with attitudes toward teen pregnancy at all.
Four changes in cognitive development during this time period may explain why we failed to replicate our previous cross-sectional findings. First, an increasing ability to engage in abstract thinking emerges (Blakemore & Mills, 2014), which brings both an awareness of how society is structured (e.g., social class distinctions) and the onset of negative downward comparisons towards the less fortunate (Leahy, 1990). Second, the ability to understand another’s perspective increases (Van der Graaff et al., 2014) and results in more realistic expectations about teen parenthood (Hatcher, 1973). Third, educational and life experiences further develop formal operations, which increase awareness of the consequences of one’s own behavior as well as others’.5 Finally, increasing experience with educational activities enhance ninth graders’ abilities to evaluate and refute arguments (i.e., argumentation; Kuhn et al., 2013).6 Thus, as educational and life experiences increase, Teen Mom viewers become more aware of the implications of teen pregnancy (both for themselves and others). The onset of negative downward comparisons toward the less fortunate during this development period is also relevant – as it is reflected in both the findings of the current study and in Behm-Morawitz et al.’s (2019) research that associated downward social comparisons among teen viewers of teen mom reality programming with more negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy.
When considering why downward social comparisons presented a stronger relationship with attitudes toward teen pregnancy in ninth grade than upward social comparisons and identification did, it is possible that self-evaluations obtained by feeling sorry for media characters in undesirable situations (via downward social comparison) become more salient during this time period than looking up to media characters (via upward social comparison) or imagining oneself as a media character (via identification). Although each process is an important component of socialization (van der Aar et al., 2018; Cohen, 2001; Dijkstra et al., 2008; Mead, 1934), downward social comparisons during adolescence may serve to provide more accurate self-concepts – especially when the targets they are comparing to are similar in gender, age, and life stage. The negative consequences that teen mothers featured on Teen Mom experience may contain more diagnostic information for adolescent girls via the negativity bias, e.g., the tendency to focus on negative information over positive information (Baumeister et al., 2001) as they see themselves as potentially more at-risk for becoming pregnant during the transition from middle school to high school.
One additional consideration is the similarity in results related to identification and upward social comparison. Both here and in the previous study (Lewis et al., 2020) they were highly correlated. Although identification and upward social comparison are distinctly different social psychological processes, it is clear how there might be some conceptual overlap. Identification involves imagining oneself as a media character and also lends to imitation of that character (e.g., Moyer-Gusé, 2008; Oatley, 1995), while upward social comparison involves looking up to a character one sees as better off and instigates a desire to be like them (Gibbons & Buunk, 1999). Both processes involve viewers assessing the attributes of media characters and placing the characters in a positive light. However, Cohen (2001) notes that comparison requires assessments of the self and comparison target, whereas identification does not require the same self-assessment – only the imagination of being someone else. Comparison positions the viewer in parallel with the character and identification positions the viewer as the character. Thus, these processes may individually contribute to attitudes toward teen pregnancy or may mask each other’s influence. Parsing out these differences and determining whether identification or upward social comparison lend to stronger effects on viewer attitudes would be a valuable direction for future research.
Overall, the current results demonstrate how identification and social comparison processes can change over time. Especially considering the sample of participants in this study – young Latinas aging from eighth to ninth grade – the findings lend insight into the maturation process as it occurs, especially during the formative middle school years as early adolescents age into high school. These findings argue for the importance of reaching these individuals to mitigate the potential detrimental effects that media exposure can have on outcomes such as attitudes toward teen pregnancy. The time points of this data collection tell us that in eighth grade, young Latina women who highly identified with and upwardly compared to the teen mothers on Teen Mom were less likely to think getting pregnant in high school would be embarrassing, a terrible event, or prevent them from achieving their dreams (Lewis et al., 2020). Alternatively, by ninth grade, young Latina women who downwardly compared were more likely to think that getting pregnant in high school would be embarrassing, a terrible event, or prevent them from achieving their dreams. Considering this, it is most important to reach young adolescents early in their middle school years to increase their media literacy skills and reduce their vulnerability to programs like Teen Mom. Moreover, media literacy skills and beliefs acquired in early adolescence can become habits and knowledge that are retained to shape future behavior, thereby having a protective effect throughout adolescence and adulthood (Perlstein, 2004).
This study also extends previous research regarding the effects of identification and social comparison processes on attitudes by examining the influence of ethnicity and culture as reflected in birthplace, specifically being born either in or outside of mainland US. We found that birthplace also influenced attitudes toward pregnancy over time. Young Latinas who were born in the US mainland had more negative attitudes toward teen pregnancy than those born outside of the US mainland. This may be due to Latino cultural values that celebrate and often normalize young motherhood (Aparicio et al., 2014). Those born in Latino countries outside the US may hold on to more traditional Latino values as they shape attitudes toward pregnancy. Birthplace may be a particularly useful demographic variable for researchers who examine the process of changing as a result of long term exposure to a new culture (i.e., acculturation; Ward & Geeraert, 2016). Acculturation is important to research involving immigrant populations, but has been difficult to define and measure (Juang & Syed, 2019). It is possible that birthplace, an easier variable to assess, could help advance our understanding of acculturation effects in communication and other sciences.
Of course, there are some limitations to report with this study. Although we were able to collect longitudinal data from the same group of Latina adolescent viewers at two different time points over the course of approximately one year, our assessment was limited to only one program (Teen Mom) under a wide umbrella of teen mom programming (e.g., 16 and Pregnant, Unexpected). We were able to learn valuable insights regarding these Latina viewers, but there are potential issues with generalization of study findings to Latina adolescents from a wider range of birthplaces than the ones examined here. Nevertheless, replication of these results in other Latina subgroups as well as other ethnic and cultural subgroups is essential for understanding the influence these types of programs have on adolescents in general. Finally, because this study was part of a larger intervention study, we were limited in the number of items we could include, which may have prevented us from capturing a more in-depth understanding of the processes assessed here.
In conclusion, this study contributes to the existing knowledge that observing teen mothers on Teen Mom influences attitudes toward teen pregnancy (e.g., Martins & Jensen, 2014). These outcomes appear to be largely reliant on how viewers perceive the central teen cast members in these programs and how those perceptions change over time. Study findings argue for building media literacy skills in early adolescents (e.g., in seventh grade) to increase their resistance to the influence of reality TV programs, such as Teen Mom, that have the potential to increase risk taking behavior through their impact on attitudes. Further, the results highlight the need for future research that examines the influence of a variety of teen mom programming longitudinally across different developmental points in middle and high school, and among additional at-risk populations (e.g., rural, urban). More broadly speaking, these findings argue for the benefits of using a developmental lens to examine identification with and social comparison to media characters in various television genres (e.g., teen mom programming, true crime) as a means for better understanding the processing and effects of media consumption.
Acknowledgments:
Funding for the collection of this data was provided by the University of Miami School of Nursing and Health Studies and NINR (R01NR014851; PI, Norris).
Footnotes
This clinical trial is registered under the name “JUEGA: A fun study for Hispanic/Latino adolescent girls” (#NCT02578147).
The survey data used in this study were collected as part of a clinical trial. This clinical trial is registered under the name “JUEGA: A fun study for Hispanic/Latino adolescent girls” (#NCT02578147).
Mighty Girls is a culturally and developmentally tailored intervention consisting of 6 lessons delivered face-to-face and a highly interactive computer game used for skill building purposes (Norris et al., 2018). Mighty Girls teaches decision making and goal setting, evaluation of risky behavior, peer resistance communication skills, and resistance to descriptive norms. It does not discuss teen pregnancy or media content about teen pregnancy. The intervention also had no effect on attitudes toward teen pregnancy (p > .05).
To determine whether being of Cuban origin skewed the results toward this particular country’s cultural attitudes versus attitudes among Latinas in general (of the 24% of participants who were born outside of the US, 58% reported Cuba as their birthplace), a linear mixed-effects model was conducted using a Cuban/Non-Cuban origin variable both with and without birthplace (US born/Non-US born) and had no significant relationship on attitudes toward teen pregnancy nor did it significantly influence the final model’s results. As a result, this variable was excluded from further analysis.
Ability to engage in formal operations emerges in early adolescence and is responsible for an imaginary audience effect that drives concern for peer approval (Elkind, 1981), but ability to use causal reasoning requires domain specific practice gained through education and life experience (Cvetkovich et al., 1975).
See Felton’s (2004) comparison of seventh and eighth graders argumentation skills.
References
- Van der Aar LPE, Peters S, & Crone EA (2018). The development of self-views across adolescence: Investigating self-descriptions with and without social comparison using a novel experimental paradigm. Cognitive Development, 48, 256–270. 10.1016/j.cogdev.2018.10.001 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Aparicio E, Pecukonis EV, & Zhou K (2014). Sociocultural factors of teenage pregnancy in Latino communities: preparing social workers for culturally responsive practice. Health & Social Work, 39(4), 238–243. 10.1093/hsw/hlu032 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Basil MD (1996). Identification as a mediator of celebrity effects. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 40(4), 478–495. 10.1080/08838159609364370 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Baumeister RF, Bratslavsky E, Finkenauer C, & Vohs KD (2001). Bad is stronger than good. Review of General Psychology, 5(4), 323–370. 10.1037/1089-2680.5.4.323 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Behm-Morawitz E, Aubrey JS, Pennell H, & Kim KB (2019). Examining the effects of MTV’s 16 and Pregnant on adolescent girls’ sexual health: The implications of character affinity, pregnancy risk factors, and health literacy on message effectiveness. Health Communication, 34(2), 180–190. 10.1080/10410236.2017.1399506 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Blakemore SJ, & Mills KL (2014). Is adolescence a sensitive period for sociocultural processing?. Annual Review of Psychology, 65(1), 187–207. 10.1146/annurev-psych-010213-115202 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Brückner H, Martin A, & Bearman PS (2004). Ambivalence and pregnancy: Adolescents’ attitudes, contraceptive use and pregnancy. Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health, 36(6), 248–257. 10.1111/j.1931-2393.2004.tb00029.x [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Cohen J (2001). Defining identification: A theoretical look at the identification of audiences with media characters. Mass Communication & Society, 4(3), 245–264. 10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Cvetkovich G, Grote B, Bjorseth A, & Sarkissian J (1975). On the psychology of adolescents’ use of contraceptives. Journal of Sex Research, 11(3), 256–270. 10.1080/00224497509550900 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Dijkstra P, Kuyper H, Van der Werf G, Buunk AP, & van der Zee YG (2008). Social comparison in the classroom: A review. Review of Educational Research, 78(4), 828–879. 10.3102/0034654308321210 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Elkind D (1981). Understanding the young adolescent. In Steinberg LD (Ed.), The life cycle. New York: Columbia University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Felton MK (2004). The development of discourse strategies in adolescent argumentation. Cognitive Development, 19(1), 35–52. 10.1016/j.cogdev.2003.09.001 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Festinger L (1954). A theory of social comparison processes. Human Relations, 7(2), 117–140. 10.1177/001872675400700202 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Gibbons FX, & Buunk BP (1999). Individual differences in social comparison: Development of a scale of social comparison orientation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76(1), 129–142. 10.1037/0022-3514.76.1.129 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hatcher SLM (1973). The adolescent experience of pregnancy and abortion: A developmental analysis. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 2(1), 53–102. 10.1007/BF02213922 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hendrick CE, & Maslowsky J (2019). Teen mothers’ educational attainment and their children’s risk for teenage childbearing. Developmental Psychology, 55(6), 1259–1273. 10.1037/dev0000705 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hoffner C, & Buchanan M (2005). Young adults’ wishful identification with television characters: The role of perceived similarity and character attributes. Media Psychology, 7(4), 325–351. 10.1207/S1532785XMEP0704_2 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Johansen ER, Nielsen HS, & Verner M (2020). Long-term consequences of early parenthood. Journal of Marriage and Family, 82(4), 1286–1303. 10.1111/jomf.12634 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Juang LP, & Syed M (2019). The evolution of acculturation and development models for understanding immigrant children and youth adjustment. Child Development Perspectives, 13(4), 241–246. 10.1111/cdep.12346 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Kuhn D, Zillmer N, Crowell A, & Zavala J (2013). Developing norms of argumentation: Metacognitive, epistemological, and social dimensions of developing argumentative competence. Cognition and Instruction, 31(4), 456–496. 10.1080/07370008.2013.830618 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Leahy RL (1990). The development of concepts of economic and social inequality. New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 1990(46), 107–120. 10.1002/cd.23219904608 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Levine DS (2021, April 20). MTV reportedly decides if ‘Teen Mom OG’ will get new episodes. Popculture.com. https://popculture.com/reality-tv/news/teen-mom-og-mtv-reportedly-renews-season-9b/ [Google Scholar]
- Lewis N (2021). Experiences of upward social comparison in entertainment contexts: Emotions, state self-esteem, and enjoyment. The Social Science Journal, 58(3), 339–354. 10.1016/j.soscij.2019.04.011 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Lewis N, Norris AE, & Martins N (2020). Latina teens’ identification with and social comparison to mothers on Teen Mom. Mass Communication and Society, 23(2), 206–229. 10.1080/15205436.2019.1682169 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Mares ML, & Cantor J (1992). Elderly viewers' responses to televised portrayals of old age: Empathy and mood management versus social comparison. Communication Research, 19(4), 459–478. 10.1177/009365092019004004 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Martin JA, Hamilton BE, & Osterman MJK (2018). Births in the United States, 2017. NCHS Data Brief, 318, 1–8. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db318.pdf [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Martin JA, Hamilton BE, Osterman M, & Driscoll AK (2021). Births: Final data for 2019. National Vital Statistics Reports: From the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, National Vital Statistics System, 70(2), 1–51. 10.15620/cdc:100472 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Martins N, & Jensen RE (2014). The relationship between “Teen Mom” reality programming and teenagers’ beliefs about teen parenthood. Mass Communication and Society, 17(6), 830–852. 10.1080/15205436.2013.851701 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Martins N, Malacane M, Lewis N, & Kraus A (2016). A content analysis of teen parenthood in “teen mom” reality programming. Health Communication, 31(12), 1548–1556. 10.1080/10410236.2015.1089465 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Mead GH (1934). Mind, self and society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [Google Scholar]
- Moyer-Gusé E (2008). Toward a theory of entertainment persuasion: Explaining the persuasive effects of entertainment-education messages. Communication Theory, 18(3), 407–425. 10.1111/j.1468-2885.2008.00328.x [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Moyer-Gusé E, Woods K, Rader K, & Luong KT (2020). Talking about TV: Mother daughter viewing and discussion of an entertainment narrative about teen pregnancy. Health Communication, 35(10), 1200–1209. 10.1080/10410236.2019.1623642 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Neild RC (2009). Falling off track during the transition to high school: What we know and what can be done. The Future of Children, 19(1), 53–76. http://www.jstor.org/stable/27795035 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Noe-Bustamante L, Hugo Lopez M, & Manuel Krogstad J (2020, July 7). U.S. Hispanic populations surpassed 60 million in 2019, but growth has slowed. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/07/07/u-s-hispanic-population-surpassed-60-million-in-2019-but-growth-has-slowed/ [Google Scholar]
- Norris AE, Delcampo Thalasinos R, Miller-Day M, Hecht M, & Hofler R (2018, September 14). Building peer resistance skills in 7th grade Latinas: Results from the Mighty Girls efficacy trial. Paper presented at the State of the Science Congress on Nursing Research, Washington, DC. [Google Scholar]
- Oatley K (1995). A taxonomy of the emotions of literary response and a theory of identification in fictional narrative. Poetics, 23(1-2), 53–74. 10.1016/0304-422X(94)P4296-S [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Perlstein L (2004). Not much, just chillin': The hidden lives of middle schoolers. Random House Digital, Inc. [Google Scholar]
- Rodriguez AL, Arcara J, Deardorff J, & Gomez AM (2020). The association between religiosity and pregnancy acceptability among Latino/a young adults: Does generational status matter?. Culture, Health & Sexuality, 22(2), 184–200. 10.1080/13691058.2019.1581260 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Selman RL (1980). The growth of interpersonal understanding: Developmental and clinical analyses. New York, NY: New York Academic Press. [Google Scholar]
- Tajfel H (2010). Social identity and intergroup relations. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Van der Graaff J, Branje S, De Wied M, Hawk S, Van Lier P, & Meeus W (2014). Perspective taking and empathic concern in adolescence: Gender differences in developmental changes. Developmental Psychology, 50(3), 881–888. 10.1037/a0034325 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Ward C, & Geeraert N (2016). Advancing acculturation theory and research: The acculturation process in its ecological context. Current Opinion in Psychology, 8, 98–104. 10.1016/j.copsyc.2015.09.021 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Wills TA (1981). Downward comparison principles in social psychology. Psychological Bulletin, 90(2), 245–271. 10.1037/0033-2909.90.2.245 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
