Skip to main content
. 2023 Aug 28;26(10):107736. doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2023.107736

Table 9.

Average ranking values of involved improved algorithms by Wilcoxon signed-rank test

Algorithm Rank +/ = /- ARV
PSMADE 1 4
EBOwithCMAR 4 12/6/12 4.8
LSHADE_cnEpSi 6 17/4/9 6.1
JADE 3 14/5/11 4.7
HHODE 9 24/5/1 9.3
ALCPSO 10 29/1/0 10.533333
CLPSO 7 19/7/4 6.3
LSHADE 5 15/5/10 5.566667
SADE 8 18/7/5 6.466667
SHADE 2 12/7/11 4.266667
RCBA 13 29/0/1 11.766667
CBA 15 29/1/0 12.833333
LWOA 11 29/0/1 11.133333
IWOA 14 29/0/1 12.466667
IGWO 11 29/1/0 11.133333
LGWO 16 28/2/0 14.366667