Table 9.
Average ranking values of involved improved algorithms by Wilcoxon signed-rank test
| Algorithm | Rank | +/ = /- | ARV |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSMADE | 1 | ∼ | 4 |
| EBOwithCMAR | 4 | 12/6/12 | 4.8 |
| LSHADE_cnEpSi | 6 | 17/4/9 | 6.1 |
| JADE | 3 | 14/5/11 | 4.7 |
| HHODE | 9 | 24/5/1 | 9.3 |
| ALCPSO | 10 | 29/1/0 | 10.533333 |
| CLPSO | 7 | 19/7/4 | 6.3 |
| LSHADE | 5 | 15/5/10 | 5.566667 |
| SADE | 8 | 18/7/5 | 6.466667 |
| SHADE | 2 | 12/7/11 | 4.266667 |
| RCBA | 13 | 29/0/1 | 11.766667 |
| CBA | 15 | 29/1/0 | 12.833333 |
| LWOA | 11 | 29/0/1 | 11.133333 |
| IWOA | 14 | 29/0/1 | 12.466667 |
| IGWO | 11 | 29/1/0 | 11.133333 |
| LGWO | 16 | 28/2/0 | 14.366667 |