Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 1;9(9):e19771. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e19771

Table 4.

Panel-unit root test.

Panel A: Levin, Lin & Chu Unit Root Test
Decision
Variables Level
First difference
Test statistics P-value Test statistic P-value
EGR 6.101 1.000 −3.071*** 0.001 I (1)
EIN 1.034 0.849 −4.598*** 0.000 I (1)
ES −1.255 0.104 −4.690*** 0.000 I (1)
PDN −1.262 0.100 −3.366*** 0.000 I (1)
RDN −0.727 0.233 −8.908*** 0.000 I (1)
RIN −0.363 0.358 −8.983*** 0.000 I (1)
RTEC
3.982
1.000
−2.780***
0.002
I (1)
Panel A: Im, Pesaran and Shin Unit Root Test Decision
Variables
Level First difference
Test statistic
P-value
Test statistic
P-value

EGR 7.385 1.000 −2.264*** 0.011 I (1)
EIN 3.300 0.999 −5.421*** 0.000 I (1)
ES −0.098 0.460 −4.890*** 0.000 I (1)
PDN −0.904 0.182 −2.643*** 0.004 I (1)
RDN 1.251 0.894 −9.334*** 0.000 I (1)
RIN −0.464 0.321 −9.355*** 0.000 I (1)
RTEC 5.193 1.000 −2.974*** 0.001 I (1)

“*** significant at 0.01”.