Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 9;2023(10):CD015144. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD015144

5. Included studies and ratings of methodological quality.

Physical distancing measure Study ID (type of study) Quality, assessment tool
Contact tracing Chung 2021(SR)# Low, AMSTAR
Gilmore 2020(SR)#^ Moderate, AMSTAR
Heuvelings 2018 (SR)* Moderate, AMSTAR
Khorram‐Manesh 2021(SR)# Moderate, AMSTAR
Megnin‐Viggars 2020(SR)# High, AMSTAR
Saurabh 2017 (SR)* Low, AMSTAR
Szkwarko 2017 (SR)* Moderate, AMSTAR
Bodas 2020 (survey)# Low‐moderate
Isolation WHO 2021(GL)# Moderate, AGREE II
Cardwell 2021(SR)#^ Moderate, AMSTAR
Chu 2020(SR)#^ Moderate, AMSTAR
ECDC 2020b(GL)# Moderate&, AGREE II
ECDC 2020a(GL)# Low, AGREE II
Mao 2021(SR)# Moderate, AMSTAR
Mobasseri 2020(scoping review)# Low, AMSTAR
Regmi 2021(SR)# Moderate, AMSTAR
Seale 2020(SR)# Low, AMSTAR
WHO 2020c(GL)# Moderate, AGREE II
Burnet 2020 (qualitative)# Moderate, CASP
Burnet 2020a (qualitative)# Moderate, CASP
Farooq 2020 (survey)# Low
Qazi 2020 (survey)# Low
Quarantine Brooks 2020 (SR)*^ Low%, AMSTAR
Gomez‐Duran 2020(SR)#^ Moderate, AMSTAR
Lin 2014 (SR)* Moderate, AMSTAR
Sopory 2021(qualitative, SR)#^ High, AMSTAR
Webster 2020 (SR)#^ Moderate, AMSTAR
WHO 2021b(GL)# Low, AGREE II
Zhu 2020 (survey)# Moderate
School measures Brooks 2020a (SR)*^ Low%, AMSTAR
CDC 2022(GL)# Low, AGREE II
CDC 2022a(GL)# Low, AGREE II
CDC 2022b(GL)# Low, AGREE II
DES 2020(GL)# Low, AGREE II
Work measures
Crowd avoidance, including individual physical distancing measures ECDC 2020(GL)# Low, AGREE II
NACCHO 2006 (guideline)+* Moderate, AGREE II
PHAC 2021(GL)# Low, AGREE II
PHAC 2021a(GL)# Low, AGREE II
Teasdale 2014 (SR, qualitative)* Moderate, AMSTAR
Tooher 2013 (SR)* High, AMSTAR
WHO 2020b(GL)# Moderate, AGREE II
Eaton 2020 (scoping review)*^ Low, AMSTAR
Lor 2016 (qualitative)* Moderate, CASP
Atchison 2020 (survey)# Moderate
Briscese 2020 (survey)# Moderate
Clements 2020 (survey)# Low
Kwok 2020 (survey)# Low‐moderate
Lohiniva 2020 (qualitative)# Moderate, CASP
Lunn 2020 (RCT)# Moderate, CASP
Meier 2020 (survey)# Low‐moderate
Roy 2020 (survey)# Low
Zhong 2020 (survey)# Low
General Bekele 2020(SR)# Moderate, AMSTAR
Berg 2021(scoping review, rapid)# Low, AMSTAR
ECDC 2020g (review of guidelines)# Low, AMSTAR
Gupta 2021(SR)# Low, AMSTAR
JHCHS 2019 (guideline)* Moderate, AGREE II
Li 2020(SR)# Moderate, AMSTAR
Majid 2020(scoping review) #^ Low, AMSTAR
Noone 2021(scoping review, rapid)# High, AMSTAR
PHAC 2022(GL)# Low, AGREE II
Sarria‐Guzman 2021(SR)# Low, AMSTAR
WHO 2017 (guideline)* High, AGREE II
WHO 2020(GL)# Low, AGREE II
WHO 2020a(GL)# Low, AGREE II
WHO 2021a(GL)# Low, AGREE II
Lim 2020 (survey)# Moderate

# COVID‐19‐specific, #^ included research not COVID‐19‐specific but review conducted explicitly in the context of the current pandemic outbreak, *non‐COVID‐19‐specific study

Bold text indicates new studies added in this update.

AMSTAR ratings categorised as follows (scored out of 11): 1‐4 low, 5‐7 moderate, 8+ high‐quality

AGREE II ratings categorised as follows (mean scores across 6 domains): < 40% low, 40 to < 70% moderate, 70%+ high‐quality

&AGREE II overall rating calculated based on mean of 3 domains (1, 3, 6) rather than all 6 domains of the tool

% AMSTAR rating from McMaster Health Forum (via Health Systems Evidence https://www.healthsystemsevidence.org)