Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 9;2023(10):CD011769. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011769.pub2

Luby 2006.

Study characteristics
Methods Parallel trial of risperidone versus placebo
Participants Inclusion criteria:
  • aged 2.5‐6.0 years

  • previously diagnosed with DSM‐4 criteria for autism or PDD‐NOS (American Psychiatric Association 1994)


Exclusions:
  • other known significant central nervous system (CNS) disorders

  • significant medical problems or other psychiatric disorders requiring pharmacotherapy


Location/setting: "psychiatric outpatient clinic at Washington University School of Medicine", USA
Sample size: 23 (11 risperidone, 12 placebo)
Number of withdrawals/dropouts: 1 exclusion from risperidone group as the "child did not meet the threshold for an ASD on the CARS or GARS [Gilliam Autism Rating Scale] at baseline, despite having been referred with a clinical diagnosis, and was excluded from analyses". 1 dropout from placebo group due to parent report of severe hyperactivity
Gender: risperidone 9/11 male, placebo 8/12 male
Mean age: risperidone 4.1 years, placebo 4 years
IQ: not reported
Baseline ABC‐I or other BoC: not an outcome
Concomitant medications: not reported
History of previous medications: not reported.
Interventions Intervention (risperidone) for 6 months: the majority of participants started risperidone at 0.5 mg once daily; mean starting dose was 0.03 mg/kg/day. 81.8% of risperidone participants took 1 mg (0.5 mg twice daily) after 4 weeks; 27.3% of risperidone participants were dispensed total daily doses of 1.5 mg after 8 weeks, whereas all others received total daily doses of 1 mg. The final risperidone mean dose was 0.05 mg/kg/day and mean daily final dose was 1.14 mg (SD 0.32).
Comparator (placebo) for 6 months: placebo participants were dispensed 0.5 mg daily doses. Mean final daily dose was 1.38 mg (0.57), which was comparable to risperidone.
Outcomes Primary outcomes: AEs
Secondary outcomes: none reported
Timing of outcome assessments: at baseline visit, weekly visits during the 1st study month, biweekly visits during the 2nd month, followed by monthly visits for months 3–6
Notes Study start date: November 1999
Study end date: November 2002
Source of funding: "this study was funded by Janssen Pharmaceutica as an investigator initiated project to Dr. Luby".
Conflicts of interest: none disclosed
Trial registry: not reported
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Unclear risk Patients were consecutively assigned by an unblinded child psychiatrist (J.L) to risperidone or placebo treatment using a randomisation table obtained from the WUSM pharmacy and derived using a standard software package
Allocation concealment (selection bias) High risk Quote: "Patients were consecutively assigned by an unblinded child psychiatrist"
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias)
All outcomes Low risk Quote: "Parents and raters who conducted all standardized assessments were blind to treatment group"
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias)
All outcomes Low risk Quote: "Parents and raters who conducted all standardized assessments were blind to treatment group"
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias)
All outcomes Low risk All participants, apart from one who did not meet the required baseline threshold for ASD on the CARS or Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, were included in the analysis.
LTFU: 1 participant withdrew from placebo group due to staring spells. No other LTFU reported
Selective reporting (reporting bias) High risk All children were previously diagnosed and referred by a clinician. "the treating psychiatrist (J.L) was unblinded and conducted regular clinical assessments over the 6‐month period". The unblinded child psychiatrist was also the lead investigator.
Other bias High risk All children were previously diagnosed and referred by a clinician. "the treating psychiatrist (J.L) was unblinded and conducted regular clinical assessments over the 6‐month period". The unblinded child psychiatrist was also the lead investigator.